John 18:1-11 · Jesus Arrested
What Is Truth?
John 18:1--19:42
Sermon
by Schuyler Rhodes
Loading...

Tonight we gather in darkness to hear a tale of darkness. It is, for many of us, a familiar story. This is the story of the arrest, torture, and execution of Jesus. It is a difficult and bloody narrative that concludes this night with his being laid in the tomb and with each one of us praying and processing what all this means in this time and this place. I know. For some, the mention of the word, “politics” from the pulpit is troublesome. But friends, let us be clear and unambiguous. This was a political execution. Jesus was set up as a would-be “King of the Jews” and neither Jews nor Romans were eager for competition in the power game. So Jesus got eliminated.

In order for such a process to proceed, however, it was important that a narrative be constructed that met the needs of the “principalities and the powers (Ephesians 6:10f),” who cared less about truth than they did about domination and power. So it was that the famous conversation between Jesus and Pilate took place with words that could be issuing forth from the tweets of certain leaders even today.

Jesus was being abused and shuffled between the religious authorities and the state authorities and found himself finally in Pilate’s presence. The conversation didn’t go well. It began with Pilate asking Jesus if he’s “King of the Jews.” Jesus, with what could be discerned as sarcasm says, “Do you ask this on your own, or did others tell you about me?” Pilate retorts, and I paraphrase, saying that he’s not a Jew and points out that it’s his own people who want him eliminated. And Pilate pushes Jesus with the question, “What have you done?”

It’s the usual question spat out by those who assume that if you get arrested and find yourself in front of the interrogator that you must be guilty of something. From the Gestapo to our own immigration police, to local police rounding up African American young men, the presumption of guilt accompanies all who are seized. Jesus, nonetheless persisted, pointing out that his alleged kingdom was not a kingdom like Rome or even the temple authorities. But Pilate pressed him saying, “So, you are a king?” Jesus proceeded to point out that it was Pilate who was calling him a king, it was not a title Jesus sought or used. Jesus summed up his defense saying he was born to testify to the truth. Then Pilate in words that were both ancient and achingly contemporary said, “What is truth?”

I hear these words, and I cannot unhear all the cries swirling in our current malaise about “fake news” and “alternative facts.” The parallelisms here are stunning. It is a trick as old as time. Confuse, malign, and obfuscate by pretending that truth doesn’t actually exist. Dismantle the carefully woven constructs of consensus and covenant and pit the people against one another so that they will not notice what authority is doing.

Pilate aimed the question like a weapon. “What is truth?” It was asked as though every simpleton knew that there was no real discernible answer. It was asked with the bullying swagger of the authoritarian whose cynicism knows no bounds. It was asked with a dismissive derisive tone.

Friends, we are here tonight, not merely to grieve and to embrace the death that comes. We are here tonight because, even in the face of suffering we have an answer to Pilate. We know truth. We are not arrogant enough to claim possession of absolute truth, but we do know this. We know that truth lives, breathes, and grows in the building of life-giving, authentic human community. We know, even in the darkness of the tomb, that there is truth found in the integrity of human relationships. We know, even in the terror and the torture, that in compassion there is truth. We know that all the yelling and spewing of hatred and bigotry cannot erase the power of self-giving love.

We are here tonight to feel the pain of loss, it’s true. But in that pain we reach for one another and claim the truth that is love, the truth that is hope, the truth that is the new life we know will come among us. So let us on this night of darkness clasp one another’s hands and dare to answer Pilate when asks us….What is truth?

Amen.

CSS Publishing Company, Inc., Shout Joy to the Storm: Cycle C sermons for Lent and Easter based on the Gospel texts, by Schuyler Rhodes