John 1:35-42 · Jesus’ First Disciples
In the Shadow of His Brother
John 1:35-42
Sermon
by King Duncan
Loading...

A priest at a parochial school, wanted to point out the proper behavior for church.  He was trying to elicit from the youngsters, rules that their parents might give before taking them to a nice restaurant.

“Don’t play with your food,” one second grader cited.

“Don’t be loud,” said another, and so on . . .

“And what rule do your parents give you before you go out to eat?” the priest inquired of one little boy.

Without batting an eye, the child replied, “Order something cheap.” (1)

Some of you with children can relate to those parents. It’s not easy being a parent. One of the issues that has to be dealt with in many families is that of sibling rivalry.  I read recently of a woman who came home from the hospital with her second baby. She hired Annie, a live-in nurse, to help out for the first few weeks.  Having read up on sibling rivalry, the new mother watched her 18-month-old daughter, named Robyn, for signs of jealousy or insecurity. But Robyn seemed to adore her little sister from the start.  She loved to help Annie feed and bathe the baby, and she even offered to share her toys.

Several weeks passed and the mother, convinced that Robyn was suffering no ill effects, decided she could manage without a nurse.  As she watched Annie walk out to her car that last day, she heard an unmistakable cry of distress.

“Annie!” yelled Robyn, running after her former live-in nurse. “You forgot your baby!” (2) Perhaps it’s easier for a child to adjust to an interloper in the family if she believes the new baby isn’t a permanent member of the family, but belongs to someone else.

I did hear about another family, however, that had a strange twist on the reality of sibling rivalry.

“I don’t want a new baby,” said Brian, the older of two brothers. Brian was adamant when his mother told him that they were expecting a new addition to the family. The family had survived the first round of sibling rivalry when Brian’s younger brother, Damian, was born, so his Mom and Dad were surprised that Brian was digging in his heels over a new baby.

They spent nearly an hour trying to convince him that a new baby in the family was a good thing.  Three-year-old Brian, however, made his stand about this new baby, and neither logic nor persuasion could budge him. 

Puzzled, his mother finally confronted him with a straight-forward question, “Why don’t you want a new baby?”

With wide and teary eyes, Brian looked straight at her and said, “Because I like Damian, and I want to keep him.” (3) 

Brian wasn’t worried about being displaced by a new little sister. He was afraid they would have to send back his brother Damian.

The Bible tells of many sets of siblings. Among the most famous are Cain and Abel . . . Isaac and Ishmael . . . Jacob and Esau . . . Joseph and his brothers . . . Jesus and his brothers . . . the sons of Zebedee, James and John . . .  and Mary, Martha and Lazarus. Some of these sibling relationships turned out well, but most turned out, well, badly. Some had their rocky patches, but in the end turned out positive. In almost all of the relationships, however, one of the siblings became more prominent than the other. That was certainly true of the two brothers in our lesson for today.

 If we begin with verse 35 of our lesson for the day, we read, “The next day John was there again with two of his disciples. When he saw Jesus passing by, he said, ‘Look, the Lamb of God!’ When the two disciples heard him say this, they followed Jesus. Turning around, Jesus saw them following and asked, ‘What do you want?’

“They said, ‘Rabbi’ (which means Teacher), ‘where are you staying?’

‘“Come,’ he replied, ‘and you will see.’ So they went and saw where he was staying, and they spent that day with him. It was about four in the afternoon.

“Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, was one of the two who heard what John had said and who had followed Jesus. The first thing Andrew did was to find his brother Simon and tell him, ‘We have found the Messiah’ (that is, the Christ). And he brought him to Jesus. Jesus looked at [Andrew’s brother] and said, ‘You are Simon son of John. You will be called Cephas’ (which, when translated, is Peter).”

And so we are introduced to two brothers, Andrew and Peter. Andrew was the first disciple Jesus called, but for the rest of the New Testament, Andrew is over-shadowed by his brother Simon Peter. 

I think it is interesting that before Andrew was a disciple of Jesus he was a disciple of John the Baptist. This emphasizes John’s stature in New Testament times. John had disciples people who followed him and studied under him, just as Jesus did. We usually put the emphasis on how strange John the Baptist was with his diet of locusts and honey and wearing skins and living in the desert. But John was regarded by many of the people as a prophet. Remember how it was said of him that “people went out to him from Jerusalem and all Judea and the whole region of the Jordan” (Matthew 3:5). 

But, like Andrew, John’s destiny was also to live in the shadow of another in this case his younger cousin Jesus. In fact, John’s main role in life was to point to one greater than himself.

One day, when Andrew was nearby, John the Baptist spotted Jesus. “Look,” he exclaimed, “the Lamb of God!” And Andrew made a decision to leave John and follow Jesus. Andrew, I’m sure, appreciated John the Baptist and all he had done for him, but he needed more. That happens, doesn’t it? We find something better, so we transfer our loyalties. So Andrew traded in John for Jesus.

That reminds me of a little book that was written years ago by Southern Baptist pastor turned comedian, Grady Nutt. It was titled The Gospel according to Norton.

The Gospel according to Norton is a humorous, but touching story about a young man, a fictional character named Norton who, like Andrew, was a disciple of John the Baptist. The first time Norton met John the Baptist he was struck by John’s appearance. He described him like this: wearing a “double-breasted camel hair suit (wrong-side out), platform high-top sandals, teased hair, the works . . .”

The first night by the river, says Norton, was the beginning of a deep friendship with John. “In only four days I was arriving early enough to get a front rock!” is the way Norton put it. “In short, I became an ardent follower  . . . he was my hero great dresser, unique, distinctive, outspoken, honest. I tried more and more to be like him . . .”

Until one afternoon Norton was with John when John baptized Jesus. Norton says he was amazed at John’s attitude toward Jesus, at his strange statements statements like, “[I] should let you baptize me . . .” and “[I’m] not worthy to tie your shoes.” He was amazed at John’s general sense of awe in Jesus’ presence.

Later Norton hears that Jesus has a group of disciples following him “further back up the river.” One night he goes to scout out this new teacher and his followers.

The first time he hears Jesus teach, it happens! Here was the Messiah about whom John had been preaching! In just three visits, says Norton, he transferred his membership! Like Andrew, he left John the Baptist and became a follower of Jesus and John became a distant memory.

One day Jesus asked Norton if he had seen John lately. Norton chuckled, thinking about his crude, bombastic former teacher. Jesus frowned. Then Jesus asked Norton why he chuckled. Norton replied, concerning John: “Oh, he’s still wearing that double-breasted camel hair suit and preaching blisters on his throat . . .” and he added a few other curt, sarcastic things as well.

At this, a disappointed Jesus looks at Norton and asks, “Norton, do you know where you’d be if it hadn’t been for John?”

Norton blushed, squirmed and dropped his eyes. “Still snitching fruit hanging . . .  [and] around the market,” he replied.

“Exactly,” Jesus said . . . and at that point, Norton says, Jesus taught Norton one of the greatest lessons he had ever learned that young idealists frequently find their Messiah and then spend their time belittling his Forerunner! (4)

At the time Grady Nutt invented the character of Norton, he was on the staff of the Southern Baptist Seminary in Louisville, KY. He saw many young seminarians come to that school where they learned a more progressive view of the Christian faith than they had grown up with. The first thing these young men did [and yes they were all men back then] was to belittle and ridicule the conservative, fundamentalist, narrow-mindedness out of which they had come to seminary. In the person of Norton, Nutt was saying to these young men, “Remember where you came from. Would you be where you are today without that background?”

I make this point because some of you have come to this church out of similar backgrounds backgrounds where you experienced more legalism than love, more judgment than grace. Gratefully you say, you could never go back. And yet you are here. And you are faithful and you are supportive and it just may be that some of what you learned back then is bearing positive fruit today.

Let’s not be too critical of those who follow a different path, regardless of where we are in our Christian life. John the Baptist had his faults, but he pointed people toward Jesus. And that, of course, is what Andrew did as well.

Andrew was not one of the more prominent disciples. He is better known in the New Testament simply as Simon Peter’s brother. Simon was the rock star; Andrew was the one who carried the instruments.

I like how one speaker described his own brother who was always in the spotlight. He said his brother was “quarterback of the high school football team, editor of the school paper and Joseph in the annual Christmas play.” He also probably got the prettiest girls and was the teacher’s pet.

Some of you probably had siblings like that. Andrew was always in Peter’s shadow. Peter was part of Jesus’ inner circle (along with James and John). He was there every time something significant happened in Jesus’ ministry. It was Peter who tried to walk on water, and Peter on whom Christ bestowed the name “The Rock.” On this rock,” said the Master, I will build my church.”

Andrew may have been present for some of these experiences, but he is rarely mentioned. In fact he is only mentioned by name in twelve verses in all the New Testament. In eight of those verses he is referred to as Simon Peter’s brother.

Andrew had only one gift as far as we know: he introduced people to Jesus. In fact, it was he who brought his more celebrated brother Simon Peter to Jesus. John tells us that the first thing Andrew did after he began following Jesus was to find his brother Simon and tell him, “We have found the Messiah.” Then John writes, “And he brought him to Jesus.”

That would be a good epitaph for Andrew’s tombstone, “He brought his brother to Jesus.” That would be a good epitaph for our tombstones, friend. He [or she] brought a friend to Jesus. It’s akin to the epitaph that should have graced John the Baptist’s tombstone, “He pointed others to Jesus.” What greater compliment can you pay to any human being than that? He, or she, cared enough to share his or her faith with a friend.

Some of you are uncomfortable about bringing people to Jesus. It is a fact of church life that most people who come to church do so because a friend invited them, and yet very few church members ever invite a friend to church. Don’t you think that is ironic? If we did invite more people more often, the church would be packed every Sunday. That’s what the studies show, and yet we hesitate.

Some of you are much more comfortable about witnessing for Christ with your actions than your words. I understand. That’s far better than those who witness with their words, but live such shoddy lives that they defeat their witness. But as you leave this house of worship today, I want to ask you to do something. I want you to ask yourself even better to prayerfully ask God if there is something you can do to bring someone else or to point someone else to Jesus. You might do that by being a good neighbor. You might do it by talking in depth with a family member about their faith. Do it in a loving way. You’re not called to be a sales person for Jesus. You’re called to listen carefully and answer honestly on the basis of your own walk with the Master.

Here is the most important truth: you don’t have to be a superstar in order to impact this world. Most people are not superstars. That doesn’t mean you cannot make a significant contribution to the kingdom of God.

There is an old African-American spiritual titled, “There Is a Balm in Gilead.” Do you remember it? It speaks to the Andrew in each of us. It begins like this:

“Sometimes I feel discouraged and think my work’s in vain, / But then the Holy Spirit revives my soul again. 
“There is a balm in Gilead to make the wounded whole; / There is a balm in Gilead to heal the sin sick soul.”

It is the second verse that I love:

“If you cannot preach like Peter, if you cannot pray like Paul, / You can tell the love of Jesus and say, ‘He died for all.’
“There is a balm in Gilead to make the wounded whole; / There is a balm in Gilead to heal the sin sick soul.”

Andrew couldn’t preach like his brother Simon Peter; neither could he pray like the Apostle Paul. But he could “tell the love of Jesus and say, ‘He died for all.’” And so can you and I.


1. @Doc’s Daily Chuckles - go here http://family-safe-mail.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=55 to subscribe.

2. Wendela Whitcomb Marsh in Reader’s Digest, May 83.

3. Sermon_Fodder-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.

4. (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1974), pp. 19-24.

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., Dynamic Preaching First Quarter 2014, by King Duncan