Return to Me (3:6-12): The fifth speech returns to the present with an appeal for repentance demonstrated in a concrete act of obedience, tithing. This obligation contributes to proper worship at the temple and to feeding even the poorest of the people. The Lord, who loves Israel, offers them reconciliation and promises blessing.
3:6–7a The opening statement of this address is a stunning non sequitur, “I the LORD do not change. So you, O descendants of Jacob, are not destroyed.” The Lord has remained the same God known to Israel since the time of their ancestor Jacob. This is the same God whose will had been known through the law (torah), who abhors violence, judges evildoers, and commands reverence. In the preceding verse one reads the promise of God’s coming day of judgment (3:5). God’s justice and integrity should have required the end of Israel because of their habitual unfaithfulness: “Ever since the time of your forefathers you have turned away from my decrees and have not kept them.” Yet the consequences of God’s stability are just the opposite from what his hearers assume. The use of the name Jacob takes the hearer or reader back to the first speech (1:2–5), which begins, “I have loved you” and “I have loved Jacob.” For as long as they have been turning away, even that long and longer, God has loved them (cf. Hos. 11:1–11). Therefore, God urgently calls, “Return to me, and I will return to you.”
The invitation to return in verse 7 is a call to repentance. Because of God’s unchanged fidelity and forbearance, God’s people have the opportunity to repent and to be restored to relationship with God. The invitation and promise echo Zechariah 1:3, and God’s word to (Jer. 15:19) and through the earlier prophets (Jer. 31:20–22; Hos. 14:1–8). Indeed, OT prophecy views Israel’s history as the arena in which God, through the prophets, called on Israel over and over to return (e.g., 2 Kgs. 17:13; Jer. 25:4–7; 35:15; Zech. 1:6). This promise of reconciliation provides another answer to the question in 2:17. The God of justice turns to those who repent and walk in God’s way.
3:7b–10 The people’s quoted response is a practical question, “How are we to return?” God’s response is also practical, identifying a particular offense from which they can turn back. God does not, however, meet their question with tenderness but instead addresses them with a cleansing accusation: “Will a man rob God? Yet you rob me.” The choice of words emphasizes the difference between the two parties, God the creator and ʾadam, “human being” (NIV “a man”), the creature. No domestic metaphor softens the contrast. God is charging Israel with the unthinkable. They rob God by withholding their tithes and offerings. These dues were to be paid out of the produce of the soil, which God had provided to humankind as food. The land itself belonged to God, and the Israelites were “aliens and . . . tenants” (Lev. 25:23). The offerings named here are contributions for the support of priests and Levites (e.g., Num. 5:9; 18:8, 11, 19). Laws requiring the gift of the tenth are found in Numbers and Deuteronomy, and they do not reflect a uniform requirement. Deuteronomy calls for tithes of crops to be brought annually to Jerusalem, to be eaten there as a feast to the Lord (12:6–7, 11–12; 14:22–27). Every third year they were to be set aside at home to feed widows, orphans, resident foreigners, and Levites (14:28–29; 26:12–15). These landless people had no way to raise their own food, but they could come to the towns to obtain provisions (14:29). Numbers 18:21–24 assigns all tithes to the Levites as their inheritance from the Lord in lieu of land and in payment for their service at the tent of meeting. Malachi 3:6–12 does not mention priests or Levites, so their worthiness to receive this support is not the issue in this passage. The purpose of bringing the tithes to the temple storehouse (as in Neh. 13:12) is that there may be food in my house. The word for “food” (teref) is rare (Ps. 111:5; Prov. 31:15), but the idea is similar to that in Malachi 1:12, which calls sacrifices “food” (ʾokel). This concept is not common in the OT and it should not be understood as a claim that God needs sacrifices or offerings as nourishment (Ps. 50:9–13). The landless were fed by tithes paid in grain, wine, and oil (Deut. 14:23; Lev. 18:27; Neh. 10:37) and, according to Leviticus 27:32, from the flock and herd. They were to “eat and be satisfied” (Deut. 14:29; 26:12).
The divine word interprets the straitened circumstances of the whole nation of Israel in terms of the Sinai/Horeb covenant. They are under a curse because they have violated covenant obligations by withholding part or all of the required tithes and offerings (Lev. 27:32; Num. 18:8, 11, 19, 21–24, 27; Deut. 12:6–7, 11–12; 14:22–27). The nation under covenant accepted the threat of being cursed for their disobedience (Deut. 28:15–19) along with the promise of blessing if they obeyed the Lord (Deut. 28:1–6). Rain and abundant crops are among the primary blessings of the covenant (Lev. 26:3–5; Deut. 28:4–5, 11–12).
The Lord’s offer, “Test me in this,” is made within the context of covenant. Israel will carry out the test by obeying the covenant requirement to bring the whole tithe, the full ten percent, and they will see the results when God gives them blessing (v. 10), as Deuteronomy 14:29 promises. This is not just a test of God’s power and will to do them good; it is specifically a test of God’s faithfulness to the covenant with Israel. For this reason, individuals who desire to demonstrate their own faith in God’s power and goodness by asking for some personal benefit cannot simply take up the invitation to “test me.” Israel’s tithes fed people who had no land on which to raise their own food and God’s covenant blessings were for the whole nation. Furthermore, it is dangerous to test God (Ps. 95:9). God invites this examination of divine integrity only two times in the OT—here in Malachi 3:10 and in Isaiah 7:12, where Ahaz is encouraged to ask for a sign to confirm the prophet’s word.
Two unusual expressions describe the blessing that God will pour out. Through the floodgates of heaven the waters flooded the earth in Genesis 7:11, but this picture of destruction is an image for an abundance of food in 2 Kings 7:2, 19 and Malachi 3:10. It will be a veritable flood, so much blessing that you will not have room enough for it. Storehouses at home and at the temple will overflow with provisions. Paul extends a similar promise in 2 Corinthians 9:6–15; generous giving to supply the needs of God’s people will overflow in blessing to the giver and in thanksgiving to God, because such generosity is consistent with faith in the gospel of Christ.
3:11–12 Furthermore, God promises to prevent pests from devouring your crops. “Prevent” (gaʿar) is also used in Malachi 2:3, where the NIV translates it “rebuke.” God’s wrath will be turned against the agents of the covenant curse, the devouring insects, to paralyze them, thereby reversing the curses in Deuteronomy 28:38–39, 42 and Leviticus 26:20. The book of Joel parallels the movement in Malachi 3:9–12 from curse to return and blessing. Joel 1 gives a detailed description of destruction by locusts and promises recovery from this loss after the people return to God with mourning and prayer (2:12–27). God also promises that the vines . . . will not cast their fruit. This verb (shikkel) is used elsewhere only of women and female animals and means “miscarry.” The grapes will ripen to harvest, because neither drought nor pest will interfere. Such blessings will cause other nations to admire and envy Israel, and to pronounce a beatitude on them (call you blessed), for such a fertile country will truly be a delightful land—one to be desired for the bounty and pleasure it provides. Israel’s fame among the nations and the fertility of the land are both important elements in the OT portrayal of end-time blessings (e.g., Isa. 62:1–5; Amos 9:13–15).
Deuteronomy provides the text of a confession of obedience to be recited by the Israelite who had brought the third year tithe for Levites, resident foreigners, orphans, and widows. One was to confess ritual purity and obedience, “I have not turned aside from your commands nor have I forgotten any of them” (Deut. 26:13; cf. Mal. 4:4). The text ends with a prayer for blessing and thanks for the land God had promised to their ancestors and had given to them, “a land flowing with milk and honey” (Deut. 26:15).
The best result of this concrete act of repentance will be the restoration of Israel’s relationship with God. Malachi 3:6–7 prevents any reading of the covenant as a way for Israel to manipulate the Lord. From earliest times they had failed to remain faithful and to fulfill their obligations. But God remained committed to them and continued to offer the covenant as a way to return (Deut. 4:25–31; 30:1–10).
When you are in distress and all these things have happened to you, then in later days you will return to the LORD your God and obey him. For the LORD your God is a merciful God; he will not abandon or destroy you or forget the covenant with your forefathers, which he confirmed to them by oath. (Deut. 4:30–31)
Those Who Fear the Lord (3:14--4:1):
3:13 The final address returns to the question of justice. God charges the people of Malachi’s audience with saying harsh things against me. The reflexive verb form in verse 13b, “‘What have we said [nipʿal of dbr] against you?’” indicates that they had said these words to one another rather than addressing them to God in prayer. Yet in verses 14 and 15 God reveals their strong words and the false conclusions they express.
3:14–15 They have said, “It is futile to serve God.” They do not observe any concrete benefit that they had expected from the God they served. The rhetorical question in verse 14b expresses the same idea. They looked for gain from their service, a word that most often means “ill-gotten gain” (as in Ezek. 22:27). They claim to have served God by carrying out his requirements—a general term for obedience to God’s law, as in Deuteronomy 11:1, or a designation for particular priestly duties (e.g., Lev. 8:35; Zech. 3:7)—and by going about like mourners before the LORD Almighty, that is, by exhibiting gestures of repentance (as in Ps. 38:4–6; Joel 2:12–17; cf. Mal. 2:13). The book of Malachi mentions several times that Malachi’s audience brings offerings, makes and pays vows, and prays for God’s acceptance. Yet actions that seem to them, and to their priests, to be carrying out God’s requirements were worse than doing nothing (1:10). The accusation of the people is that “the arrogant” (those who seem, in comparison to themselves, to be godless and rebellious), enjoyed prosperity in their families, flocks, and fields. So Malachi’s audience formulates a beatitude: “we call the arrogant blessed.” Their beatitude is the opposite of God’s promise in 3:12, “Then”—after you have returned and been obedient—“the nations will call you blessed.” Furthermore, they say, “the evildoers prosper” and “those who challenge God escape.” “Challenge” translates the same word as “test” in 3:10 (bakhan). In the previous speech God had invited them to “test me,” but here the people recall the danger of doing so (as in Ps. 95:9). The reasoning behind the statements in verse 15 serves as a warning against a mistaken reading of 3:10. Malachi’s audience was wrong. One must not conclude from the success of other people that they are right with God, and then deduce God’s standards from their conduct. The audience’s theological argument would destroy the distinction between the righteous and the evildoers. This difference, they think, is not being sustained by God’s character (“All who do evil are good in the eyes of the LORD,” 2:17), nor by divine power (“even those who challenge God escape,” v. 15).
3:16 At this point the usual format of the speeches in Malachi leads one to expect a word of judgment or promise from God. Instead one finds a narrative in verse 16 about the response of part of Malachi’s audience. It is the only narrative in the book. After hearing this much, Then those who feared the LORD talked with each other. They talked among themselves, just as the larger audience had done in 3:13b. Although Malachi does not quote their words, their identification as Yahweh-fearers provides the key to understanding them. “Those who fear the LORD” is a typical designation in the Psalms for worshippers (e.g., Pss. 22:23; 66:16; 115:9–13). In Malachi it epitomizes the response God desires from the people (1:6, 14; 2:5–7; cf. 3:5). It is the goal of Malachi’s ministry that the people to whom the prophet and the book speak may come to fear the Lord. They will recognize and honor God as parent, master, and great King over all nations and will turn themselves and others away from sin and toward God. This “fear,” then, is not a feeling of terror or panic at the prospect of punishment. It is the product of genuine encounter with, and knowledge of, God—a fitting response to God’s holiness, power, and love. As this spiritual relationship matures, an increasing sense of awe and reverence for the greatness, goodness, and grace of God nourishes a growing love for, and desire to serve, God.
Verse 16 then tells us that the LORD listened and heard the conversation of the God-fearers, but there is no divine word addressed directly to them. (Verses 17–18 are about the God-fearers but are addressed to the larger Malachi audience.) A scroll of remembrance was written for them instead, in the Lord’s presence. Malachi does not specify the author or scribe of this document, and the writing in his presence (i.e., before the Lord), could have taken place in heaven or at the temple. But the purpose of the book was as a remembrance for those who feared the Lord and honored his name (see the additional note).
The OT refers to various objects and specific worship practices as a “remembrance” or “memorial” (zikkaron) for Israel. For example, the twelve stones erected at Gilgal after the ark and the Israelites crossed the Jordan on dry ground were to be a remembrance “to the people of Israel forever” (Josh. 4:7). They were to perpetuate teaching about what the Lord had done for them there, so that they might “always fear the LORD” (Josh. 4:24). Worship practices such as paying atonement money (Exod. 30:16), blowing trumpets (Num. 10:10; Lev. 23:24), and Passover observance (Exod. 12:14) are also called remembrances or memorials for Israel “before the LORD,” reminders of what God had done for them and what they were to do for God. The celebration of the Feast of Unleavened Bread was to be a remembrance “that the law of the LORD is to be on your lips” (Exod. 13:9). One other remembrance in the OT is also a written document. After a victory over the Amalekites, the Lord commands Moses to write a divine word of promise in a book as a remembrance and to read it to Joshua. It is at least possible that the scroll of remembrance here in verse 16 was part of the biblical book of Malachi. Other prophets had been commanded to prepare written documents, including Isaiah (8:1, 6), Jeremiah (30:3; 36:2, 28; 51:60), and Habakkuk (2:2). The implication is that these documents were included in the canonical books that we possess. Part or all of the book of Malachi could function as a remembrance to sustain the covenant relationship between God and faithful Israel. As a concrete object its existence was a memorial of God’s presence with the postexilic Jewish community and of the commitment some of them had made to fear the Lord. As a practice, reading the book aloud supports the participation of each subsequent generation in this life-giving relationship with God, by reminding them of God’s will (torah) and God’s promises, and by calling them to return.
3:17–4:1 Malachi 3:17–4:1 addresses the concerns of Malachi’s audience directly. God promises that, “in the day when I act” (v. 17, NIV margin), you will again see the distinction between the righteous and the wicked, between those who serve God and those who do not (v. 18). On the day of divine judgment, the arrogant will not seem to be blessed and the people who challenge God will not escape (3:14–15). The arrogant and every evildoer will be destroyed by fire until there is no possibility of recovery or revival: Not a root or a branch will be left to them (4:1). Their survival and prosperity will no longer stand as evidence against the justice of God. The ones who will escape on that day will be the people who fear the Lord, because God will spare them (3:17). The God-fearers who had made a public witness to their faith (3:16) are the subjects of the promise in 3:17–18. God describes them in terms previously used for the whole people of Israel, my treasured possession (Exod. 19:5; the king’s private treasure, as in 1 Chr. 29:3–5), and his son who serves him (Exod. 4:22–24; cf. the descriptions of Christians in 1 Pet. 2:9 and John 1:12). The wider Malachi audience, addressed in 3:17–4:1 as “you,” is shown a future judgment in which two groups, the righteous and the wicked, will be distinguished. They had thought of themselves as God’s servants (3:14) and did not count themselves among the arrogant and evildoers. But in 3:17–4:1 the God-fearers of 3:16 are God’s servants and the ones who will be spared. The Malachi audience addressed as “you” belongs for a moment to neither group. In that moment the Malachi audience in every generation has an opportunity to choose: Will they be among the arrogant evildoers or will they choose to follow the example of the God-fearers? Will they, and we, heed the message of Malachi and live as the Lord’s servant daughters and sons?