John 19:17-27 · The Crucifixion
Why A Cross?
John 19:17-27
Sermon
by Robert Beringer
Loading...

Why A Cross?

Some years ago the motion picture industry did a great service to the cause of Christianity with its epic production of Lew Wallace's Ben Hur. The crucifixion scene in that film is unforgettable, and recreates a truer picture of our Lord's death than almost any other dramatic production I have ever seen. Looking at that movie, you can feel the injustice, the callousness, and the sheer brutality of Calvary. Executioners pound home huge spikes into quivering hands and feet. Rivulets of blood trickle down the side of the cross. On the faces of Jesus' disciples is a look of incredible bewilderment as they wrestle with the question of how God's Messiah could be put to death like a common criminal. The film is a forceful reminder that the cross is more than a decorative symbol we wear as a piece of jewelry, or a part of the furnishings of our church buildings. The cross in the first century was an instrument of execution not unlike the guillotine, the gas chamber, the firing squad or the electric chair. It was simply the way the Romans got rid of their enemies. For us the question is still "Why?" Why did Jesus have to die like a common criminal? Why could he not have slipped away quietly to Galilee, and continued his ministry of healing, preaching, and teaching? Why could he not have lived a little longer, and perhaps trained hundreds of disciples instead of just a dozen. Why was the cross necessary, and what difference does it make in our lives today?

1. The Logical Outcome Of Jesus' Life

From a historian's point of view, the cross was the only logical outcome of our Lord's life and ministry. To be sure, he could have stayed at the carpenter's bench in Nazareth. He could have refrained from attacking the hypocrisy of the priests and Pharisees. If only he had held his tongue, Jesus might well have lived to be as venerable as Caiaphas, the High Priest. He might even have been invited to join that very select group of scribes and Pharisees that eventually handed him over to Pilate for execution. Perhaps Jesus could have lived longer if only he had heeded the advice I once heard a business person giving his son who had just graduated from college: "Son, if you want to get ahead in the business world, don't rock the boat. Never mind all that stuff about your principles. You can stand on them after you retire. Stick with the majority, bend the rules if you have to, and above all else, don't try to change the system!" But that was never the way of Jesus Christ! Jesus was not some kind of mystic or visionary, laboring under some false illusions about what might happen to him. Jesus Christ was a realist. He saw clearly how events were unfolding, and he alone was not surprised when the soldiers came at night with swords and staves to arrest him. All through his ministry, our Lord chose the path that led to the cross. His whole life had a beauty and purity that exposed the ugliness and the brokenness of life about him. It was because his enemies could not stand that exposure that they were driven to take his life. The artist, Holman Hunt, has captured this sense of the cross as the logical outcome of our Lord's whole life in a painting that is titled, The Shadow Of Death.1 The picture shows Jesus as the village carpenter in Nazareth, earning his bread by the sweat of his brow. I understand that when this picture was first exhibited in England, working people saved their weekly wages to buy a small engraving of this scene. For the picture is not of some pale, stained glass window Jesus, but rather that of a man hard at work. The picture itself shows the young carpenter rising from his cramped position at the workbench, and stretching out his arms to relax them. But as he does so, the young carpenter's body with the outstretched arms casts a shadow on the wall behind him in the outline of a cross. Nearby stands Mary, his mother, and the artist has pictured for us her fear-stricken face as she beholds the ominous shadow of a cross. In a dramatic way, the artist is saying that the cross was the only logical outcome of such a life.

2. God's Way Of Dealing With Us

But if we stop there, we are merely historians recording the facts of Jesus' life on this earth. At a far deeper level, we need to understand that the cross has always been God's way of dealing with sinful people. Marc Connolly's famous play, Green Pastures,2 pictures God as having created a good earth. God has left men and women to care for the earth, but rebellious human beings have turned the earthly paradise into chaos. God is angry -- angry enough to punish the inhabitants of the earth and bring them to their senses. But no one on earth is willing to listen to God, so God appears ready to chuck the whole business, and let the earth be destroyed. At the last moment, the angel Gabriel tells God about an obscure Jewish prophet on the earth named Hosea. Hosea's wife has been unfaithful to her husband over and over again. Yet, Hosea still loves this sinful woman, clings to her, and will not let her go. And then God says, "Is that how I must reach out to my children on the earth? Must I suffer like that poor prophet to show them how much I really love them? The play closes with the angels of heaven looking over the rim, and listening to the cries of wailing that are rising up from the earth. One angel turns to another and says, "Look at that man carrying a cross up that hill! That's a terrible burden for one man to carry all by himself." The play leads us to a deeper truth about the necessity of Christ's death on the cross. For this was not just any cross. This was the cross of Jesus, God's own beloved Son. It is God who is bearing that terrible burden to show the world in all its rebellion just how far the great heart of God is willing to go to redeem sinful human beings. What God did at Calvary, God has been doing since the beginning of time. God enters the mess and the shame we have made of our lives. God, through prophets in every age, keeps calling us to a life of righteousness, peace and justice. The writer of the 139th Psalm asks, "Whither shall I flee from thy presence?" Even the Psalmist caught the wonder of a God who not only holds the stars in their courses, but who loves us like a shepherd, and pursues us like a shepherd seeking a lost lamb. What God did at Calvary, God has always been doing. In cosmic terms, the cross demonstrates how it is only the one who has been wronged and hurt who can reach across the brokenness, and make possible reconciliation, forgiveness, and a new relationship we now call "at-one-ment." Many years ago I came to know a family with a teenager who did everything he could to destroy his parents' love and trust for him. He drank, he fought, he stole from family members, he refused to take any responsibility, and when threatened with punishment he would run away. His parents were good people who had a wonderful relationship with their other children. But no matter how much discipline or how much love these parents gave their youngest son, Donald continued to be a very troubled and rebellious teenager. One night I was with his father as we went to the local police station to pick up Donald. He had run away earlier in the day, and gotten into a whole new set of troubles. It was past midnight, and I was amazed at the calmness of the father. As we walked into the station, Donald said to his father, "Dad, why do you even bother coming after me? Don't you and Mom know by now that I'm just no good? Why don't you just give up on me?" Now I tell you quite honestly that no one in that community would have blamed that father if he had done exactly that! But I will never forget what Donald's father said to his son that night. "Don, your mother and I love you, and as long as there is breath in our bodies, we will go on loving you and standing beside you!" In a profound sense, God is saying something like that to us from the cross of Jesus Christ.

3. The Cross Is God's Challenge To Us

At a still deeper level, the cross is God's challenge to us to make a radical break with the world, and to love others in the same incredible way that God has loved us. D. T. Niles, the great church leader from Ceylon, has written, "Christianity is not an affirmation of ideals which we must test and practice. It is not an explanation of life and its problems over which we must argue. It is rather the announcement of an event with which the world must reckon."3 The cross of Jesus demands a response from us. It is an event with which we must reckon. If God was in Christ reconciling the world, then we who follow Jesus Christ must take up that same ministry of reconciliation in our broken world. The radical love God displayed on Calvary's cross demands that we love and forgive one another in the same way God has forgiven and reconciled us. A moving illustration of this radical response occurred back in 1958 when on the evening of April 25th a young Korean exchange student at the University of Pennsylvania left his apartment, and walked to a corner mailbox to send a letter to his parents. The young man was an active leader in the student Christian movement on that campus. Turning from the mailbox, he stepped into the path of 11, leather-jacketed,teenage boys. Without a word, they attacked this "foreigner," beating him with a blackjack, a lead pipe and their fists. Later, the young student was found by the police lying dead in the gutter. All over the city of Philadelphia, there were cries for vengeance against this gang of young hoodlums. The District Attorney secured legal authority to try these teenage boys as adults, so that if found guilty, they would be eligible for the death penalty. The boys were found guilty in a much-publicized trial and were awaiting sentencing when a most unusual letter arrived from Korea addressed to the judge. It was signed by the parents of the murdered student and 20 other relatives living in Korea. It read in part:

Our family has met together and we have decided to petition the Court for the most generous treatment possible within the laws of your government for these young men who took the life of our son. In order to give evidence of our sincere hope contained in this petition, we have decided to send money to start a fund to be used for the religious, educational, vocational, and social guidance of these young men. We have dared to express our hope with a spirit received from the Gospel of our Savior, Jesus Christ, who died for the sins of us all.4

The cross is God's challenge to make a radical break with the world around us, and to love others in the same amazing way God has loved us in Jesus Christ. As the hymnwriter Isaac Watts expressed it:

Were the whole realm of nature mine,That were a present far too small;Love so amazing, so divine,Demands my soul, my life, my all.


1. Beneath The Cross Of Jesus, A. Leonard Griffith, Abingdon Press, Nashville, Tennessee, 1961, page 12. Used by permission.

2. Green Pastures, Marc Connolly, Samuel French Publishers, New York, New York. Used by permission.

3. This Jesus ... Whereof We Are Witnesses, D. T. Niles, Epworth Press, 1965.

4. Beneath The Cross Of Jesus, A. L. Griffith, page 18. Used by permission.

CSS Publishing Company, Turning Points, by Robert Beringer