Big Idea: God’s justice draws Job toward confidence, but God’s sovereignty intimidates him.
Understanding the Text
In Job 23, Job rejects what Eliphaz has just said in the previous chapter, when he counseled Job to “submit to God and be at peace with him” (22:21). This is yet another indicator that the communication between Job and his friends is breaking down. Instead of speaking directly either to his friends or to God, Job speaks in a soliloquy, as he did in chapter 3. His internal conversation reflects how solitary and lonely he feels, as he is increasingly isolated from both humans and God. In the first twelve verses, Job expresses confidence before God but also his inability to find God in order to present his case before him. In verses 13–17, however, Job discloses that he also feels terror before Almighty God.
Historical and Cultural Background
In 23:10, Job alludes to the refining of gold as he expresses what God seems to be doing in his life. In the ancient world, gold was refined by placing it in a crucible along with lead. As great heat was applied to it, the gold melted, and when it cooled the dross would adhere to the lead, leaving the purified gold (cf. Ezek. 22:17–22). In 23:10 this process is used to picture how God employs adversity either to refine Job from his sin (as the friends insist), or, better, to reveal the sterling quality of Job’s life, which will be indicated by Yahweh’s reproof of the friends in 42:7–8. The same image is used in Psalm 66:10, only with adversity being compared to the refining of silver, rather than gold.
Interpretive Insights
23:3–4 If only I knew where to find him! Job does not follow the counsel of his friends, who urge him to repent of sins that Job knows he has not committed. Confident of his own innocence, Job has a strong desire to meet God face-to-face, so that he can present his legal arguments before him (23:4). Job is prepared to argue for his own innocence, but he cannot find the Judge. Job does not suggest that he can manipulate or deceive God into doing his bidding, but he wants a fair trial that will clear him of the false charges that the friends have raised against him.
23:5 I would find out what he would answer me. Because Job cannot locate God, he is unable to present the evidence for his own innocence. Worse than that, God will not speak to Job, so Job is left to speculate what God would say if he were to break his silence. When Yahweh eventually does speak, beginning in 38:1, what he says is different from what both Job and the friends have anticipated.
23:6–7 No, he would not press charges against me. Job here is more optimistic than he was previously, in chapter 9, when he thought that God would pronounce him guilty, even though he is blameless. He now is confident that God will pay attention to him and treat him justly (23:7). Because Job anticipates that he will be able to establish his innocence before an impartial judge, he believes he can come before God with confidence.
23:8–9 But if I go to the east, he is not there. In verses 8–9, Job looks in all directions for God, but he cannot find him wherever he searches. Because God seems inaccessible, Job feels frustrated. If Job cannot locate the courtroom and the judge, then how will he be able to get his case resolved? Job will have to wait until God chooses to reveal himself, and there is no way that Job can compel him to do that.
23:10 But he knows the way that I take. This statement by Job has been interpreted in two different ways. The NIV interprets it to refer to the omniscient God knowing the way that Job takes, in contrast to Job’s lack of knowledge of God’s whereabouts (23:8–9). Literally, the Hebrew reads, “God knows [his] way with me,” which means that God knows what he is doing in Job’s life. This more likely reading indicates that God is sovereign in directing Job according to the path that he has ordained for his servant (cf. 23:11–12). Job here reflects his trust that God knows what he is doing, even if Job cannot discern how this all makes sense.
when he has tested me, I will come forth as gold. Job is clearly convinced that God is not punishing him for his sins, so it is not likely that he here is referring to God’s process of refining impurity out of his life. Rather, what God is doing through this intense adversity will demonstrate that Job’s character has been gold all along. Through this painful experience, the exemplary quality of Job’s character, which has been in dispute, will be recognized. This, then, is not refining that will make Job into gold, but it is an evaluation that will reveal that Job already is gold in God’s eyes.
23:11 I have kept to his way without turning aside. The Old Testament wisdom literature often speaks of walking in the way of the Lord. Job does not turn aside to the right or to the left (cf. Prov. 4:26–27), but he keeps on God’s path. God’s way means following God’s word (23:12; cf. Ps. 119:105). By his commitment to God’s way, Job demonstrates that Yahweh’s original evaluation of his life in 1:8 and 2:3 was accurate.
23:12 I have treasured the words of his mouth more than my daily bread. How a person lives reflects what a person loves, because actions follow values. Job’s heart is devoted to God, so his behavior is directed according to God’s way. By his commitment to God’s words, Job evidences that he values God’s wisdom more than even his daily food (cf. Prov. 8:10–11). Job lives a godly life because he loves God and all that God says.
23:13 He does whatever he pleases. Job’s friends have insisted that the retribution formula is a rigid and reliable description of how God always works in the world. By their reckoning, God always rewards those who are righteous, and he always punishes those who are wicked, so that when a person like Job experiences adversity, that means he must have sinned. Job argues against his friends that God as sovereign is free to work according to his own plan, and he is not bound by some external rule like retribution. Even if God typically acts consistently with the retribution principle, his actions cannot be reduced to a neat and predictable formula that dictates how he must act at all times. Job has not arrived there yet, but in his thinking he is beginning to move toward the recognition of this that he will come to at the end of the book. No one is able to manipulate or coerce God to act in a particular way, because God’s actions are totally under his own control.
23:15–16 when I think of all this, I fear him. As Job reflects on God’s transcendent knowledge and power, he confidently feels drawn to God, but he also feels intimidated by him. The term “fear” in this verse is a different word from the one used in the expression “the fear of the Lord,” which is the beginning of wisdom (Job 28:28; Prov. 9:10). Job here speaks of the terror that is evoked in his heart by God’s overwhelming power; in verse 16, he continues by saying, “God has made my heart faint; the Almighty has terrified me.”
Theological Insights
In Psalm 139:7–12, the psalmist states that no matter what direction he may go, God will certainly be there. The omnipresence of God is a great comfort to the psalmist. By contrast, in Job 23:8–9 Job searches for God in the east, west, north, and south but is incapable of finding him. This hiddenness of God prompts Job to wonder if God is not there, or if he is there but not willing to communicate with Job. This silence of God is difficult for Job to understand or to accept, just as it is for many of the psalmists (e.g., Ps. 13:1–2).
The language of divine testing is used frequently in the Old Testament. In Genesis 22, God tests Abraham’s faith by directing him to offer up his son Isaac as a sacrifice. Psalm 66:10 pictures God as testing humans, using the language of the refining of silver. Because the Bible reveals God as omniscient, knowing all things, this testing is not designed to teach God something that he does not already know. Rather, testing, as in Job 23:10, is a demonstration of what is actually in the heart of the person who experiences God’s affliction.
Teaching the Text
In chapter 23, Job is torn between two strong and conflicting feelings. On the one hand, as he reflects on God’s justice, Job feels confident. Unlike the pagan gods of the ancient Near East, who are morally arbitrary and capricious, Yahweh is just in his character. Because Yahweh is just, Job can be confident that Yahweh will do the right thing for him. On the other hand, as the Sovereign God, Yahweh is free to do as he pleases. Job, therefore, cannot manipulate what Yahweh does, and he finds this disconcerting and even intimidating. We can be confident that the Lord will always be true to his unchanging holy character, but we also must remember that his ways are higher than our ways (Isa. 55:9).
Friends can often be a useful mirror to us, because they can see aspects of our lives that we are prone to overlook. In particular, they can alert us to flaws and faults that we conveniently neglect to observe in ourselves. Job’s friends think that they are helping Job by insisting that he needs to confess the sins that have brought adversity into his life, but in fact they are seeing things that are not really there. As Job searches his heart, he cannot agree with them. When he scrutinizes his actions, attitudes, and motives, Job does not detect sin but rather finds genuine righteousness. Because of this rigorous self-examination, Job is confident that he is innocent before God as he seeks to approach God with his legal defense.
Like many of the psalmists, Job complains that God seems silent and hidden. As Job prays and cries out to God, God does not answer him. No matter where he searches for God, Job cannot locate him. Job longs to regain communication with God, and he wants to stand before God to appeal his case, but God is nowhere to be found. Job’s prolonged time of waiting is often echoed in the lives of Christians who have to learn through long and painful experience to trust God even when he seems silent and hidden.
Despite all his unanswered questions, Job also has some answers to share. He insists that God knew what he was doing as he ordered Job’s life. Job also knows that his adversity, as painful as it is, will clearly demonstrate the quality of his life as a righteous man. He is confident that he has followed God’s steps and treasured God’s words. Job does not know what God is doing in his life, but he is convinced that God does know what Job is doing. By this, Job teaches us to place our trust in God himself, even when we cannot make sense of what he is doing in our lives.
Job is beginning to realize that God is both just and free. Job senses that in his sovereignty God acts in ways that may diverge from his general pattern. This unpredictable aspect of God’s activity may be disconcerting, but to a person who truly trusts God, this divine sovereignty can be a welcome mystery. Every time we receive a surprising answer to prayer or an unexpected blessing, we experience God’s sovereign freedom as his gift to us.
Illustrating the Text
At times, God seems silent and hidden to his children, as he does to Job.
Memoir: Lament for a Son, by Nicholas Wolterstorff. Wolterstorff is an American philosopher and professor emeritus of philosophical theology at Yale. In this moving and beautifully written piece, composed after the tragic death of his son in a mountain-climbing accident, Wolterstorff records the process of grieving, one similar to Job’s. In a dark time Wolterstorff writes, “I am at an impasse, and you, O God, have brought me here. From my earliest days, I believed in you, I shared in the life of your people: in their prayers, in their work, in their songs. . . . For me your yoke was easy. On me your presence smiled. Noon has darkened. . . . And where are you in this darkness? I cannot find you.” He concludes this passage: “The songs I learned were all of praise and thanksgiving and repentance. Or in the dark, is it best to wait in silence?”1
Song: “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For,” by U2. In one of contemporary music group U2’s most famous songs, the lead singer, Bono, sings that he still hasn’t found what he is looking for. He illustrates with several scenarios, returning to the lines “but I still haven’t found what I’m looking for.” The artist’s search for meaning in life is comparable to Job’s; however, Job explicitly searches for God, while Bono’s search and repeated disappointments ultimately lead him to God.
Even when God is silent, we can trust in divine sovereignty as a welcome mystery.
Human Experience: Adversities as different as floods, volcanoes, earthquakes, recession, job loss, and illness all have the same effect: they reveal who people really are inside. When health and wealth are stripped away, how a person responds eventually shows either good character or poor character inside that person. Job’s response to his adversity demonstrates that he is indeed every bit the righteous man that Yahweh said he was at the beginning of the book. In recent times, the various responses to the September 11 attack spoke volumes about the true values of many people. Every week one can find stories of people’s responses to hardship.
Literature: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, by C. S. Lewis. In the Chronicles of Narnia, Lewis (1898–1963) pictures Aslan (who represents Christ) as a powerful lion. When the question is asked if Aslan should be feared, it is made clear that Aslan is great, but he also is good. He will not abuse his power to do what is evil, but his goodness means that he can be trusted to use his power for blessing, just as the Lord does.
Job Asks Why God Allows Sin to Continue Unpunished
Big Idea: Rampant injustice in the world prompts Job to long for God to bring justice.
Understanding the Text
Job’s final point in chapter 23 was that the Sovereign God is free to act in ways that may not fit into a tidy formula of retribution. In chapter 24, Job builds on that point by demonstrating that the retribution system of his friends does not explain all of life. Observation clearly shows that people do sin, even in grievous ways, and yet they are not brought to judgment. In 24:1–12, Job points to the widespread oppression of the poor and the needy. In 24:13–17, he describes people who flagrantly rebel against God’s moral standards. In 24:18–24, Job either expresses his longing for divine judgment on these evildoers or predicts that God will eventually judge them. He closes his speech with a fiery challenge to his friends, daring them to prove him false if they can (24:25). Bildad’s perfunctory final speech in chapter 25 and Zophar’s failure to speak in the third round indicate that the friends are not up to Job’s challenge.
Historical and Cultural Background
Job’s description of the brutal and heartless actions by the wicked closely parallels crimes that were widely condemned in ancient Near Eastern legal codes. These actions that defrauded the needy of their property, peace, and protection denied basic human rights and dignity to those who were powerless—the orphan, the widow, and the poor. Even though behaviors like these were condemned by virtually all cultures, Job complains that God does not step in to charge the perpetrators with wrongdoing (24:12). Consequently, God seems to apply lower moral standards than what the pagan cultures require, and Job cannot understand why that should be.
Interpretive Insights
24:1 Why does the Almighty not set times for judgment? By this rhetorical question, Job implies that by neglecting to bring regular and swift judgment upon evildoers, God seems not to enforce his own righteous standards. It appears that there is no impending judgment day scheduled for those who act unjustly.1This serves to discourage those who are righteous, who look forward in vain to their divine vindication.
24:2 There are those who move boundary stones. In the ancient world, as in many places today, boundary stones were used to mark property lines. By this means, societies protected the land and financial security of families. Throughout the ancient Near East it was considered a grievous crime to move a boundary stone, because that was tantamount to stealing a portion of another’s property. In the Old Testament, this illegal practice is roundly condemned (Deut. 19:14; 27:17; Prov. 22:28; 23:10). Job has observed people doing this and yet not being judged by God for their sin.
24:5 the poor go about their labor of foraging food. In contrast to Eliphaz’s accusation of him in 22:5–7, Job clearly empathizes with the plight of those who are oppressed and in dire financial need. He has seen how the wicked have reduced the poor to abject destitution rather than using their resources to assist those in need, as he has done (cf. 29:14–16). As a result, the poor are reduced to having to forage in the wasteland for their sustenance as though they are wild animals, even though there is very little food to be found there for their hungry children.
24:9–11 the infant of the poor is seized for a debt. In several ancient Near Eastern cultures, children could serve as collateral for their father’s loan, and thus they could be taken to settle a debt. In 2 Kings 4:1, a widow’s complaint to Elisha indicates that she fears she will lose her sons because of the debt of her deceased husband. Job here points to a particularly horrific example of oppression, as creditors insist on seizing a nursing infant as payment for a debt. He goes on to show how the poor suffer the loss of their family, home, clothes, and dignity (24:10–11). Nevertheless, in this extreme situation God does not intervene, not even when the suffering of the poor reaches such a terrible level.
24:12 But God charges no one with wrongdoing. After describing the desperate condition of the poor as they are oppressed by those who are evil, Job states in verse 12 that God does not step in to stop the wrongs they do. They seem to get away with their evil, and that is profoundly troubling to Job. Job has managed to demonstrate that the retribution formula of the friends does not hold up under scrutiny, but in doing that Job comes to an even more troubling observation, that the just God does not seem to insist on justice in his world. Too many times people do what is wrong and get away with it. Too many times those who are oppressed unjustly cry out hoping for God to intervene on their behalf, and yet he does not respond to them, in contrast to his response to the cries of the Israelites in their Egyptian bondage (Exod. 2:23–25). This is indeed a troubling state of affairs for Job, because God’s inactivity against injustice seems to conflict with his holy character.
24:13–17 For all of them, midnight is their morning. In verses 13–17, Job describes the unimpeded wickedness of those who flout God’s righteous standards. They maliciously plan to defraud others by murder, adultery, and theft. They are unrestrained by God’s law, and they have no fear that they will be called to account for their criminal acts. Working under the cover of darkness (cf. John 3:19, where Jesus says that “people loved darkness instead of light because their deeds were evil”), they suppose that if no human can see them, then their wrongdoing will remain undetected. They act as if there is no God who can see through the darkness to observe their sin.
24:20–21 the worm feasts on them; the wicked are no longer remembered. In the book of Job, the worm is repeatedly used to picture decay (7:5), because it feeds on rotting corpses (21:26). In Psalm 22:6 and Job 25:6, “worm” is a derogatory expression for what is revolting or despised. By picturing the wicked in this way, Job desires God to bring total destruction and humiliation to them, or he anticipates that this is what God will do to them eventually.
In the ancient world, much emphasis was placed on being remembered by future generations. Typically, this was accomplished through children, and that is why to be childless is regarded as a great grief by Abraham (Gen. 15:2–3) and by Hannah (1 Sam. 1:1–20). Some try to gain a form of social immortality by building monuments to themselves (cf. Absalom in 2 Sam. 18:18, who has no son to preserve his name) or by calling their lands after their own names (Ps. 49:11). In Psalm 83:4, the enemies of Israel want to defeat them so thoroughly that their name will not be remembered. This is the degree of divine judgment that Job wants to see upon the wicked who oppress others so severely.
24:22–24 But God drags away the mighty by his power. Even though Job is hurting deeply, and he cannot understand why God does not exact swift judgment on evildoers, he does not become cynical against God. Job derives hope from his faith that God will act justly and powerfully to take down sinners. Job believes that in the big picture God will do as the retribution doctrine teaches. However, in the short run there are apparent anomalies in which God works in ways that escape human comprehension as he accomplishes his overall purpose, which is just and good.
24:25 If this is not so, who can prove me false? As Job completes his speech in chapters 23–24, he throws out a challenge to his friends. He dares them to try to disprove his argument that there is observable injustice in the world today but that God will eventually balance the scales of justice in his world. If they cannot meet Job’s challenge, then their silence will tacitly acknowledge that he is right. It is significant that none of the friends takes Job up on his challenge.
Theological Insights
Throughout the Old Testament, God is repeatedly presented as caring for those who are poor and needy. As Exodus 2:23–25 demonstrates, God’s compassion for the Israelites who are crying out to him in their Egyptian bondage prompts him to intervene powerfully to deliver them from their oppression. The Lord is the defender of those who are most vulnerable in society, such as the orphans and the widows (Pss. 113:5–9; 146:8–9). Set against this theological backdrop, Job’s argument in this chapter takes on even greater significance. The same God who sides with the needy also at times seems to let oppression against the needy go unchallenged and uncondemned. As Job observes this frequent pattern, he asks why God remains silent as injustice runs rampant in his world. What Job is experiencing and observing seems to contradict the righteous character of God, and he cannot understand why this antithesis should continue.
Teaching the Text
Job wants to demonstrate to his friends that bad things can happen to good people like him, but in making his point he opens up a bigger and more troubling problem. As Job identifies various examples in life that counter the retribution formula, he realizes that there are many cases in which injustice seems to triumph in life. In fact, injustice often runs rampant, and that prompts both Job and Christians today to long for God to bring justice to the world.
Job’s description of the injustice in his day sounds very familiar to us, because we hear of the same kinds of things every day on the news. Like Job, we see people today who cheat others, even the most vulnerable people in our society, such as the poor, the elderly, and the homeless. While many people enjoy a good measure of prosperity, there are others who are consigned to desperate, grinding poverty. Within the same city some children profit from an excellent education while others are consigned to inferior schools in which they fall further behind each year. These deplorable and unjust conditions continue without God intervening to stop them. For Job and for us today, this raises profound theological questions. Why does God allow this state of affairs to go on? Why does God not bring to judgment those who oppress and exploit people who are vulnerable? Is God indeed in charge of the world, as the Bible claims?
In recent years the problem of bullying in schools has been increasingly highlighted by news stories. When bullies are allowed to intimidate other children, they are only emboldened to do worse and worse things, and their victims are tormented all the more. Because they have no fear of punishment, they live as a law unto themselves. Job speaks of the same pattern in murderers, adulterers, and thieves who get away with their crimes. Because God does not intervene to stop them, they suppose that he does not see them, or that if he does see them, he is powerless to prevent what they are doing. As a result, they act as if God does not exist, and they proceed to do wrong to others. When people live as if there is no divine judge to whom they must answer, then they cast off all restraint. Their criminal behavior runs roughshod over the rights of others, and all are vulnerable to their oppression.
Rather than stooping to their level by paying back evil with evil, Job places this unjust situation in God’s hands. He longs for God to assert his power against the wicked and to bring justice to the world. By his example, Job points in the same direction that Jesus later does when he teaches his disciples to pray that God’s kingdom come, and God’s will be done, on earth as it is in heaven (Matt. 6:10). As Christians, we are obligated to do all that we can to encourage and to insist on justice being done, but we must also remember that only the Sovereign God has the power to enforce justice completely. For justice to come to earth, more than human effort is required. God alone is sufficient to counter fully the wicked schemes and actions of humans, and to bring true and lasting justice for those who are oppressed.
Illustrating the Text
In many cases, injustice seems to triumph in this world.
Literature: Lord of the Flies, by William Golding. In this well-known novel, British novelist, poet, and playwright Golding tells the story of a group of British schoolboys who are stranded on a desert island after what seems to be a nuclear war. Left alone and without the restraint of adult supervision, they vie for leadership, form cliques, and proceed to be corrupted by power and hurt one another terribly, the most sensible and sensitive of them dying in the process. It is a profound study in the native evil of human beings and their will to power.
We often long for justice from God and are puzzled by its absence.
Song Lyrics: The spirituals of the African American slaves frequently called upon God to bring justice and relief from the oppression that they had to endure in preabolition times. In one of them, “’Buked and Scorned,” the words provide an excellent illustration of Job’s longing.
We must remember that God alone can bring lasting justice.
Hymn Text: “Battle Hymn of the Republic,” by Julia Ward Howe. The words of this song (1862), often sung only on patriotic occasions, have a timeless message about God’s calling his people to remember the truth of God’s justice.
Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord,
He is trampling out the vintage where the grapes of wrath are stored;
He hath loosed the fateful lightning of His terrible swift sword;
His truth is marching on.
He has sounded forth the trumpet that shall never call retreat;
He is sifting out the hearts of men before His judgment seat;
O be swift, my soul, to answer Him! Be jubilant my feet,
Our God is marching on.