Luke 9:10-17 · Jesus Feeds the Five Thousand
So Close ... But Yet So Far
Luke 9:10-17
Sermon
by Larry Powell
Loading...

Several summers ago, my wife and I had occasion to be in a little community in New York state which included the famous St. Elmo Hotel. Word had come to us that a former employee of the hotel, inspired by people and incidents encountered in and around the landmark building, had written a story titled, "St. Elmo's Fire." The story was eventually made into a movie by the same name. Naturally, we surveyed the premises for any sign of fire damage. Seeing none, we supposed that the fire at St. Elmo must have been confined to the interior. We wondered if a room had caught fire, a floor, a ceiling, a piece of furniture ... what? Whatever it was apparently had been restored with masterful skill because there was no visible evidence of damage or repair. Oh well, at least we would be able to report to our friends that we had actually been in the building and close to the story.

A few weeks later, we saw the movie, St. Elmo 's Fire in a local theater. We were confident that we would have the advantage of immediately recognizing certain things and be able to anticipate much of the story. We would soon discover, however, that although we had been in the hotel, we were painfully ignorant about the actual story being portrayed on the screen. As a matter of fact, the reason we had been unable to determine any fire damage is because there had been no fire in the first place.

Picture this one scene: a young lady, overwhelmed by life, on the verge of attempting suicide. A friend manages to get her attention long enough to explain that the trials and tribulations of life are not real. They are like "St. Elmo's Fire," only appearing to be real.

Following the movie, I went immediately to the encyclopedia and read: "St. Elmo's fire is the name given to a round flash of light that is seen around ships in a thunderstorm." The flash of light is so named because it gives the appearance of fire. In stormy weather, this charge of electricity may be seen around airplanes, masts of ships, steeple tops, and tree tops ... as well as around horses' manes and people's heads! St. Erasmus (St. Elmo, for short) was the patron saint of Mediterranean sailors.

We had missed the point completely. Familiar with peripheral associations, yes; but there was more, much more.

Although we may be "close to the story," it is usually a good idea to allow for further light.

I. Premature Conclusions

The great multitude had been with Jesus and the 12 for better part of the day. Jesus had spoken to them about the kingdom of God and healed those who had need of healing. Now, the sun was low in the sky and it was time to think of physical provisions. The disciples are to be commended for approaching Jesus on behalf of the faithful who had stayed for the duration, rather than referring to their own fatigue and hunger, "And the 12 came and said to him, 'Send the crowd away, to go into the villages and country round about, to lodge and get provision, for we are here in a lonely place.' " They were considerate. We will give them that. But as the conversation progressed, there was some indication that they had not taken everything into account. Jesus acknowledged their concern with an unexpected reply, "You give them something to eat." Perhaps Jesus had been so involved with teaching and healing that he had not had the opportunity to accurately assess the situation. They would inform him, "We have no more than five loaves and two fish, unless we are to go and buy food for all these people (for the men alone numbered about 5,000)." It was a logical conclusion, wasn't it? Logical, yes, but premature.

"And he said to his disciples, 'Make them sit down in companies, about 50 each.' And they did so, and made them all sit down. And taking the five loaves and the two fish he looked up to heaven, and blessed and broke them, and gave them to the disciples to set before the crowd. And all ate and were satisfied. And they took up what was left over, 12 baskets of broken pieces (9:14b-1 7)."

Illogical arithmetic: 5 (loaves) times 2 (fish) equal in excess of 5,000 (servings), with a remainder of 12 (baskets). We will not dwell on the numbers however, for they are incidental to the primary revelation. The disciples were in the company of one who had direct access to the incalculable abundance of God! They should have anticipated that the situation would be handled. They were familiar with his manner, accustomed to his revolutionary teachings about the kingdom, and eyewitnesses to numerous previous miracles. They were "close to the story," but had missed it. They had prematurely concluded that there was not the wherewithal to meet the need. Even for them, the lesson "Everything is possible for him who believes" would be hard for the learning.

Our assessments are often lacking. There is a much-traveled story about a poor derelict whom police discovered crumpled on the streets of Paris many years ago. The man was in a bad way. Supposing him to be ill, or inebriated to the point of danger - they did not know - they immediately transported him to the nearest hospital. In a matter of moments, he was placed upon a table in the emergency room and surrounded by doctors. The doctors, speaking in Latin, conferred with one another. Finally, one of them said, "What shall we do with this worthless wretch?" Much to their surprise, the man on the table weakly replied in flawless Latin: "Gentlemen, do not call him worthless for whom Christ has died." He, too, had been a doctor and, as they so rudely discovered, there was more to his story than they had judged. Such is usually the case, isn't it? I remember reading somewhere that it is difficult to determine whether a ship's deck is in disarray due to neglect or because of a storm.

We have received the sacrament of holy communion many times. We know that it originated in the upper room on the night that Jesus was betrayed. We are familiar with the symbolic nature of the elements, and understand the significance of the words spoken in the ritual. Because we have received the sacrament and know something about historical and theological meanings, we feel "close to the story." That is good. However, our text suggests that there may be additional components to the sacrament which we have not always taken into account.

S. MacLean Gilmour suggests that the incident of the mu!tiplication of the loaves and fish is a miracle story which has come to be regarded as a prototype of the eucharist. In the same volume, John Knox remarks that the ritual actions which accompanied the distribution of the food confirms a relationship to the meal in the upper room, "Here is an anticipation of the last supper and a symbol of the reality of the church and Christ as the Lord of life." It comes as no surprise that scattered bits and pieces of information and random incidents are eventually understood to be snuggly fit together in the Bible's story. This piece must not be omitted:

"A man came from Baalshalishah, bringing the man of God bread of the first fruits, twenty loaves of barley, and fresh ears of grain in his sack. And Elisha said, 'Give to the men that they may eat.' But his servant said, 'How am I to set this before a hundred men?' So he repeated, 'Give them to the men, that they may eat, for thus says the Lord. "They shall eat and have some left." ' So he set it before them. And they ate, and had some left according to the word of the Lord (2 Kings 4:42-44)."

To be sure, Jesus fed more than Elisha, but Jesus was "greater than Elisha." That was the point! Greater than Elisha or Elijah, or any of the prophets. But unmistakably connected to the prophets and the intentional, consistent redemptive activity of God. Second Kings 4:42-44 is not just an isolated Old Testament miracle story. The feeding of the 5,000 is not just an isolated New Testament miracle story. The supper in the upper room is not independent unto itself. The first two incidents provide a foretaste of the third.

The disciples prematurely concluded that Jesus could not possibly feed the 5,000 hungry people with five loaves and two fish. They were so very close to the story but so far from following the main plot. We know the feeling.

II. Underestimating Resources

When all available resources were collected and brought to Jesus, the supply did not meet the demand, at least not until the supply had been blessed. The blessing did it! Like the disciples, we do not always take the possibilities of the blessing into account, nor are we always accurate in our estimates of resources. Perhaps you have heard the story of the football coach who had two quarterbacks. The first team quarterback was gifted, aggressive, and a born leader. The second string quarterback was, let us say, limited. Oh, he was athletic enough but unfortunately, his ignorance was only surpassed by his stupidity. The championship game was in progress, the score was tied, the home team had the ball, and the clock was ticking down. An opposing player broke through the line of scrimmage and slammed the star quarterback to the ground with such force that the signal-caller had to leave the game. Time was running out. The coach had no choice but to put in the back-up. The substitute trotted onto the field, huddled the team, and strode up to the line of scrimmage. Surveying the opposing team, and much to everyone's surprise, he changed the play at the line. The ball was snapped, the quarterback handed it off to the half-back who busted up the middle and sped all the way into the end zone with the winning touchdown! An amazing play. Moments later, in the ecstatic dressing room, the coach grabbed his second-team quarterback by the shoulder pads and said, "Son, that was great! How did you know to call that play?" The boy said, "Uh, well coach, it weren't easy. I got up to the line and looked across at two of the biggest players I've ever seen and I seen their numbers. One of 'em was wearing a six and the other one was wearing a seven, so I just added them numbers together and got fourteen and called number fourteen." The coach hesitated a moment and said, "But son, six and seven make 13." The boy, quite unmoved by the correction, said, "You know what coach? If I was as smart as you, we would have lost the game." Things do not always add up the way they are supposed to, do they?

See in your mind's eye a young lad, armed only with a slingshot and five smooth river stones going out to do battle with Goliath, the Philistine giant. King Saul had tried to dissuade David by saying, "You are not able to go against the Philistine to fight with him. You are but a youth and he is a man of war from his youth (1 Samuel 17:33)." It just didn't add up. But when the dust had settled over the scene,

"So David prevailed over the Philistine with a sling and with a stone, and struck the Philistine, and killed him; there was no sword in the hand of David (1 Samuel17:50)."

Saul had underestimated the available resources. A dynamic was at work that he had not taken into account.

Do you know the name, Charles A. Tindley? Charles was the son of a slave and became an orphan while still a young boy. He was passed around from farm to farm, working for one landowner, then another. Some were kind but, more often than not, the lad was dealt with harshly. Charles, like other farm laborers, was not allowed to own a book or learn how to read and write. One day on his way to the field, he noticed a small piece of newspaper lying by the side of the road. Inconspicuously, he picked it up and stuffed it inside his shirt. In time, he would collect many such bits and pieces. At night, when all the others were asleep, he would burn a pinecone and, hovering over it to hide the light, struggle to understand the words. In this manner, Charles eventually taught himself to read. At some point in his youth, he came into possession of a Bible, which his inquisitive mind eagerly consumed. The day would come when he determined to go to church regardless of the consequences. A work shirt was washed in a ditch and draped over a limb to dry. One Sunday morning, he put on the shirt, dusted off his pants, washed his feet in a puddle of water, and made for the church. When he arrived, he slipped in the door, took a deep breath, and gripped his Bible with both hands. The minister asked all the little children to come forward to the front pew and read from their Bibles. Charles went forward. Several people hissed and one person actually reached out in an attempt to grab him. He would not be denied. The children inched along laboriously with their Bible readings until they had all read their favorite passages. It was Charles' time. Without stammering or hesitation, he read verse after verse and would have completed an entire chapter had he not been interrupted by the minister "in the interest of time."

Charles A. Tindley was admitted to the Methodist ministry in 1885. He served the same church for several years where he had previously worked as a janitor. He was an illustrious member of the Philadelphia Conference. He wrote numerous hymns and doubtless had his early life in mind when he wrote, "Stand By Me." Only he knows how many times he must have recited to himself the lines, "When my faith is tossed about like a ship upon the sea, thou who rulest winds and waters, stand by me."

It would have been easy to look at the young orphan boy and categorically underestimate the potential. But God appraised the available resources, blessed them, and shaped them into a doctor of divinity, hymn writer, loving pastor, and powerful preacher who led many to Christ.

The disciples saw only five hard loaves and two fish, long out of the water. Saul had seen only a shepherd boy with a hand-full of stones and a home-made slingshot. And many were they who looked at a little barefoot orphan boy and saw only a field hand. None of the estimations were accurate because everything had not been taken into account. God's blessing of the resources, using what was available - such as it was - made the difference. It always does.

III. Mistaken Impressions

Don't you see, just being close to a situation doesn't necessarily mean we have gathered it all in! Recently, my wife and I were driving down one of the highways leading into Little Rock. As we approached the city limits, we were passed from behind by a white van with writing on the windows. Written in large letters on the passenger side was the word, "Poison." An arrow pointing straight ahead underlined the word. As the van moved in front of us, we could see another word on the rear window, "Tesla." At first, I thought it was "Tulsa," ... you know, one of those "Tulsa or Bust" signs, but the spelling was all wrong and Tulsa was in the opposite direction. "Tesla ... Poison?" In a moment, I asked my wife, "Does any of that make any sense to you?" The words did not compute with her either. I reasoned to myself that one word was probably an acrostic or code name for something and the other was possibly the work of a dedicated environmentalist trying to make a statement about the atmosphere. The following morning, I read in the Arkansas Gazette that two heavy-metal rock groups, Tesla and Poison, had played to 10,000 fans in Barton Coliseum the night before. Now, we live in Little Rock, listen to the radio, read the newspaper, and our parsonage is located relatively close to Barton Coliseum. We were, let us say, close to a situation, the meaning of which simply out-distanced us.

It has happened before - this business of "mistaken impressions." It has happened to you, hasn't it? We are in good company. The disciples were of the mind that the multitude would not be fed. Saul, impressed with little David's bravery but sad for the odds, judged in Goliath's favor. Elisha's servant asked, "How am I to set 20 loaves of barley and a sack of grain before a hundred hungry men?" Premature conclusions, inaccurate estimations, mistaken impressions - they jump out at us like sparks from a well-kindled fire.

Christian friends, allow for the possibility that, although we have received the sacrament of holy communion many times, there is still more. More to ponder, more to experience.

We partake of the sacrament:

(1) in response to Christ's command. "... And when he had given thanks, he broke it (bread), and said, 'This is my body which is for you. Do this in remembrance of me.' In the same way also the cup, after supper, saying, 'This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me' (1 Corinthians 11:24, 25)."

(2) in the knowledge that God blesses our lives and can transform circumstances. Paul said, "Do not be conformed to this world but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that you may prove what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect (Romans 12:2)."

(3) remembering that God is able to use what is available and use it abundantly. Jesus said, "I have come that you may have life and have it more abundantly (John 10:10)."

(4) to experience Christ's presence, Jesus said, "Where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them (Matthew 18:20)."

(5) to receive spiritual food for our journeys and cleansing for our souls. Paul said, "Since we have these promises, beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit, and make holiness perfect in the fear of God (2 Corinthians 7:1)."

May we not only be "close" now to this sacrament, but genuinely experience it.

C.S.S Publishing Co., BLOW THE SILVER TRUMPETS, by Larry Powell