John 12:1-11 · Jesus Anointed at Bethany
You Will Always Have The Poor With You…
John 12:1-8
Sermon
by Schuyler Rhodes
Loading...

Have you ever been in a situation where you have said something that got totally misunderstood? I remember once some years ago there was a horrible fire in a church in the community where I was serving. This fire burned the centuries old church to the ground. It was a beautiful example of older architecture and the people of the congregation loved the place. The truth, though, was that the congregation was in decline and it seemed like closure of the church was imminent. However, the fire did something. Suddenly, people emerged from everywhere, as the worship services moved across town to the high school gym. The choir grew, attendance surged and this church suddenly, inexplicably, took on a fresh spirit and new life.

One day a year or so after the fire, the chair of the church council was heard to say that maybe the fire was a good thing. Well, the rumor mill took about three hours to spread the story that the church council chairperson was glad that there was a fire. There was high drama all around and it took the pastor months to calm the situation created by a completely misunderstood comment.

Of course, we should all take care in what we say and how we say it, but the truth is that people will always have their interpretations. The same is certainly true with holy scripture. Let’s look at two places in the Bible where popular interpretations get spun out of Jesus’ teachings with the resultant understandings landing far from the core of the gospel. One of these is in Mark 12:13-17 when the Pharisees try to trap Jesus, asking him if it’s lawful to pay taxes. Jesus’ famous response is: “Give to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s and to God the things that are God’s.” For many, the popular interpretation of this passage is that it’s proof positive that good Christians should pay their taxes. How many of you have heard this? However, if you take a closer look at the context of the passage, we discover that Jesus is not saying that at all. Any good Jew of Jesus’ day knew that everything belongs to God — everything. “The earth is the Lord’s and everything in it…”(Psalm 24:1). So Jesus, rather than approving the payment of taxes was making a very shrewd response with which the Pharisee’s could not argue. From Jesus’ point of view, nothing belongs to the emperor. It all belongs to God. This is why scripture says that the people were “utterly amazed” (Mark 12:17b).

We find a similar kind spin on our passage for today. Jesus is at a dinner party at the home of Lazarus, “whom he raised from the dead.” (John 12:1b) Consider this setting! Everyone there knew the power of the master. He had raised Lazarus, after all! And now they are together at the table, knowing full well the power of the one who is sitting with them. It must have been an incredible moment. So Mary takes the expensive perfume and anoints Jesus’ feet. The exchange is familiar to us. Judas challenges this, claiming that the money could have been given to the poor. Jesus responds. “Leave her alone. She bought it that she might have it for the day of my burial. You always have the poor with you, but you do not always have me.”

A common and oft heard interpretation of this passage is that Jesus said there would always be poor among us, so why should we waste our time on a problem that will always be with us? After all, Jesus said so. Friends, rest assured that Jesus was not justifying poverty or relieving us of our responsibility for ending it. The passage draws attention to Jesus’ impending death and the perfume is a symbolic enactment of a funeral ritual. In this passage, the call comes in love and abundant compassion to receive the giver of life and to embrace the gift of the resurrection, even as Lazarus himself is embraced in table fellowship. To put it more simply, our call is not to take our eyes off the ball. In this case, the ball is Jesus, whose teaching, life, death, and rising call us to lives of holiness and hope. So if we are trying to focus on Jesus and the cynical distractions of Judas come at us, hear the words of the master. “Leave her alone.”

The question of focus and clarity arises in all this. Let us ask ourselves. Do we have our eyes on the ball? Are we truly focused on living out the gospel of Jesus? Or are we distracted by culturally moderated interpretations of scripture designed to support secular culture rather than lead us to faithful living? Let us think together about our lives as Christian community. Are we focused on ministry? Or do we use our faith to support our particular ideology or world-view?

In many places, our churches are fighting the so-called culture wars between liberals and conservatives. I know this because I have witnessed it across our nation. Yet think a moment. When we allow ourselves to be divided by such categories are we keeping our eye on the ball? When scriptures tell us we are “one in Christ” (Romans 12:5, Galatians 3:28), yet we separate ourselves along the lines of our allegedly important issues, are we not being distracted? No one ever said that we would or should be in agreement on everything. But scripture is clear that we are to be one body in Christ. Our unity, sisters and brothers, does not emerge from things upon which we find agreement, but upon our common membership in Christ’s body.

Fully aware of this, the powers of this world attempt to divide us into camps (Ephesians 6:12f). Everyone who agrees with this goes on one side. Everyone who disagrees with it goes on the other. The truth is life isn’t that simple. My wife always tells me that I was a great liberal until our daughter was born. Then things changed a bit. We are all complex and wonderfully made beings and to split us into narrowly defined adversarial groups who bicker and whine at one another does not advance the gospel of love…does it?

We are taught to conduct our lives by connecting only with those things and people who agree with us, and this toxic rending of community hurts not only us, but everyone on every side of our self-important concerns. I remember selecting a particular book for a church book study I was leading. The author of this book had a wide reputation as a conservative. At the first meeting a number of people in the group objected loudly saying, “We can’t read this book!” I assembled a strategically puzzled look on my face and said, “Why?” The somewhat aggressive, angry leader of this group looked sternly at me and said, “We don’t agree with it.” My puzzled look deepened. “Then you have read this?” The response was quick. “No! He is a conservative! We don’t agree with him so we won’t read this book!”

Friends, we must learn to experience points of view beyond our own if we are to keep our eye upon the Christ who calls us, not to division, but into relationship with one another. The temptation to sequester ourselves in the cloistered room of our own opinions turns us into that Judas who jumped on Mary with a quick accusation. “That money could have been given to the poor!” And one must admit that there is some credence to this, until we look deeper into the story and reality of the resurrection live. Jesus says, “Leave her alone. You always have the poor among you, but you do not have me.” He rebuts Judas, trying to get him to keep his eyes on the ball.

As we move toward Jerusalem and Palm Sunday, it’s important that we come together as a people of Christ to build a community that can maintain its focus on love, compassion, and hope. It’s important that we keep our eyes on the ball. And as we keep our eyes on the prize, let us remember our call is not to agreement on issues, but to unity in Christ. Let us remember to rise above the forces that would divide us. Let us take a seat at the table with Lazarus who has been raised from the dead and with Jesus as Mary prepares him for what must come. Let us clasp hands and hearts as we rise above cynicism and walk toward Jerusalem together.

Amen.

CSS Publishing Company, Inc., Shout Joy to the Storm: Cycle C sermons for Lent and Easter based on the Gospel texts, by Schuyler Rhodes