Hosea 5:1-15 · Judgment Against Israel
Returning: Real or Ruse?
Hosea 5:1-15
Sermon
by Barbara Brokhoff
Loading...

"I will return again to my place, until they acknowledge their guilt and seek my face, and in their distress they see me, saying, ‘Come, let us return to the Lord; for he has torn, that he may heal us; he has stricken, and he will bind us up.’ "

A woman was filling out an employment application. When she came to the line marked "age," she hesitated a long time. Finally, the personnel manager leaned across his desk and whispered to her, "The longer you wait, the worse it gets!"

That’s true of repentance and returning to God, too. The longer you put it off, the harder it is to do it.

Hosea, in the context and in this text, uses bold images of God - he pictures God as a ravaging lion and even as a man who absents himself from his disobedient people. He withdraws from those worshipers who thought he could be used for their own selfish purposes, thinking that they could treat God however expediency dictated.

The point is, of course, not that God is really absent, but because they had rejected him and his claims upon them, he let them suffer the fate of their own choosing. So, the Lord will withdraw himself from them until they recognize their guilt, return to him, seek his presence, and turn honestly and sincerely to him in their distress. They must realize that the power of God is not available to them for selfish exploitation.

The words in the next verse, then, (Hosea 6:1) indicate the response that God longs for: "Come, let us return to the Lord." With bold faith, the people turn for healing to the very One who wounded them! God the Chastiser is also God the Healer. There is only one God. There is no chance, then, of their making an appeal to a second deity against the righteous claims of the one, nor is there need for such an appeal. There is also a clear recognition of guilt here, and an awareness of God’s judgment - but also a sight of the love and healing power of the Lord! But it all hinges on their "Returning" - it’s a good decision they are making.

But there are two ways of returning. There can be a

Returning Without Repentance

Was their ready returning an easy hope that God would immediately restore them to their former prosperity? Were they hoping they could wallow in their selfish excesses again? Were they truly sorry for their sins, or only sorry because they had been caught? Was their repentance a result of reaping the pain and wrath their actions had brought down upon their heads, or because they deplored having injured a holy God? Was it all just a "wordy" ruse to escape judgment for their sins, and hopefully they could still live as they jolly well pleased?

The aim of Israel was not really to return to the Lord, but to remove the inconvenience that God’s anger had caused them. Their concern was to "get what they could" from a rich and powerful God.

A man went to an old friend to ask for a loan of some money. He didn’t have any collateral, and he didn’t want to be charged any interest. The friend said he didn’t think their friendship was close and binding enough to justify such a claim upon it, and so he refused to make the loan. "But, John," the man said, "how can you say that, how can you refuse me? We grew up together. I helped you make it through school. I even saved you from drowning once. I helped you get started in business. I persuaded my cousin to marry your sister. I can’t believe you’d say we were not close enough for you to make me a loan!" "Oh," replied John, "I remember you did all of those things for me. What bothers me is, what have you done for me lately?" Such is the ingratitude of those who only make a ruse of repentance. The kind of repentance that is only wily subterfuge won’t do! God won’t accept it. God’s love, mercy, and grace are unlimited, but our desire for his grace must at least be honest and sincere.

We can’t pass over our sinning so lightly. This attitude is reminiscent of St. Augustine who prayed, "Lord, forgive my sins - but not yet!" It is said that another time he prayed, "Lord, forgive my sins" - and after a pause - "except one." The anguish in St. Augustine’s soul is revealed in his confession, "How often have I lashed at my will and cried, ‘Leap now! Leap now!’ - and even as I said it, crouched for the leap, and all but leaped - and yet I did not leap - and the life to which I was accustomed held me more than the life for which I truly yearned."

Our desperate need, in our returning to the Lord, is for a heart that, without deceit, calls for forgiveness. The media reported some months ago that a Park Avenue plastic surgeon, Dr. Peter Fodor, had offered a new face to Jean Harris, who is serving a fifteen-year-sentence for killing Scarsdale Diet Developer, Dr. Herman Tarnower. Fodor said a new visage would help Ms. Harris face her prison term with a better outlook. I do not discount the value of the "lift" that physical rejuvenation may bring, but for the most part, our need is not external, but internal. A new heart would help us more than a new face!

We, today, are not too different, in our coming to God, from the people of Hosea’s day. True, we are uncomfortable when we sin, but we pass over it very casually, lightly, and flippantly, with a bored, "Whoops! Sorry about that, God!" We give God not a full repentance but our "almost."

Tragically, this is true with us as individuals and as the body of Christ when we meet for corporate worship. We are far more taken with celebration than with confession. A survey reported that eighty-seven percent of the Sunday morning services in the United Methodist Church have no confession of sins. In the Lutheran Church in America, which for centuries has made confession a mandatory and vital part of the service, the confession is now "optional."

It is frightening when our sins, done to a holy God, no longer disturb, worry, or frighten us. The St. Petersburg Times reported that a man was on trial for the murder of an elderly woman. The attorney was pleading for his life, and the accused was fighting to stay awake. His actions were described: "The eyes closed, opened, closed again. Every time the lids came down, they stayed shut a little longer!" How can you possibly be charged with killing an eighty-one-year-old woman and doze off at your murder trial? But, the devil infects you and me with the same slumbering insensitivity to the wrongs that we do, and we figure we don’t "need" to be troubled with a guilty conscience. It takes the "joy out of life," so why don’t we just get on with celebration?

We affirm that we "feel good about ourselves" and about God - and claim we feel "close to Jesus." All of this is fine, but, nevertheless, the measure of authentic repentance, returning, and revival is always manifest in our godly sorrow for sin and in the resultant change in the quality of one’s life. It is certainly true that the church is the place for sinners, but not for sinners who are determined to remain sinners, and not for obstinate sinners who have no regrets over their sins and no intention other than to remain in them. One could almost say, "Unless we change, we have not really returned!"

Returning for Radical Change

Bishop Dana Dawson was once called to a church to receive a group of young people into the church. It was time for the confirmation, and the bishop asked the question: "Will you renounce the devil and all his works?" The young lad standing in front of Dawson was so over-awed he just looked at him. The bishop repeated the question, but still no response from the child. Finally, Dawson said once more: "Will you renounce the devil and all his works?" Then he whispered, "Say, ‘I will,’ if you will." The boy then in a loud voice exclaimed, "I will if you will!" That’s what real repentance and returning is; it is going for "broke" if one truly returns to God.

I preached a revival at the Wilmington Island United Methodist Church in Savannah, Georgia, recently. The meeting closed the day before St. Patrick’s Day. It is a memorable experience to be in Savannah for the Big Day of the Irish! They go as "all out" in Savannah as they do on the "old sod." They’ve been known to paint the dome of the City Hall green. The Savannah River is colored green. "Honorary Irish" buttons are handed out to the poor souls who can claim no kin nor blood with the Irish. Grits are green, and even beer is green! No matter what the uninitiated and the non-Irish think of the day and its customs, you cannot help but be impressed with their radical allegiance to their Irish blood. I reveled in my own Irish ancestry and fought the smugness that comes of the knowledge that the heritage was mine! Returning to God should be just that same kind of "all out" determination! It should be born of an extreme and urgent awareness of need of his pardon.

Human hearts are fickle, and we are capable of turning again and again away from God - and to a disregarding of his laws. How marvelous to know that the mercy of God is always available! But healing and renewal have lasting effects only when they are sustained by solid commitment. Then, and perhaps only then, do we begin to live as "changed" persons. A dear friend, Dr. John Strohman, told of a new Christian who went back to work for the first time after he had been converted. One of the workers, who had heard of his confession, decided to test him and try out his newfound faith. He said: "I hear you got religion?" "Yes, I did," the new convert responded. "So now you are a Christian?" the trouble-maker persisted. "That’s right," the new Christian affirmed. "I suppose you now believe the Bible?" "Yes, sir, I do." The man continued to test the new convert by asking, "That means you believe all that stuff about Jesus walking on water, healing sick people, and what about turning all that water into wine? Can you believe that?" The man said, "Yes, sir, I believe all that. I don’t find it too hard to believe when I found that God has changed an alcoholic like me into a sober man, a liar into an honest man, and my wife and children into a family that’s no longer afraid of me when I come home. Yes, if Jesus can do all that, then I think I can handle the story of water into wine!"

Returning, of course, is always an individual decision, but evidence of our returning is manifested in our relationships. We come to see that in the wider sense, our lives are bound up with all the people of God. There are no limits to this bond. We can never disassociate ourselves in our relationship with God from our relationships with others. Hence, in our corporate worship, we sense the fellowship of all of God’s family. In Holy Communion, we partake with a world-wide, heaven-included community of saints. In our prayers, we pray not only for our own needs, but the needs of the community of faith, the nation, and the world. The clearer our vision of God, the wider our vision of his world! The more genuine our reason for "returning," the larger the scope of our loving. Love is never static and mechanical, but dynamic and personal. Devotion to Christ is normally inseparable from devotion to people, for Christ is a people-lover and a people-carer!

God, in his love, requires us to love others. God is willing to forgive us, but EXPECTS us to live in mutual love and caring with others. Ritual repentance is easy, superficial sorrow is simple, but radical change is hard, and loving and obeying is tough and vital!

God’s Nearness in Repentance

There are those who would presume upon a good God by saying he is "ALL LOVE" - and that he is! But God is also "ALL JUSTICE," as the Prophet Hosea (and Amos and Isaiah and others) reminds us. God let the nation and his people decide as to what their fate would be. He still does the same for us. God NEVER sends anyone to hell. His eternally extended love would not allow that - but, if we "choose" that destiny, though it breaks his heart, he will still let us decide.

An American Indian was converted to Christianity and went back to his reservation to share his faith. In explaining salvation by grace alone, he found an earthworm and put it in the middle of a circle of dried leaves. Then he set the leaves afire all around the edge. The worm tried to escape but ran into fire whatever way he went. Finally, maybe instinctively knowing the situation was hopeless, he crawled back to the center, went limp, resigned to die. At this point, the Indian convert reached down and plucked the worm from the flame and said to the people: "This is what it means to be saved. When we abandon all efforts to save ourselves, God comes to save us." This is exactly what God’s great and wondrous grace, vividly portrayed in Lent’s cross, does for us. It is the super-Divine attempt of God to entice us to choose to return in radical repentance to him and live! And that cross on Golgotha’s brow reminds us that God can never again be absent from our world. He comes so close to each of us in the atoning death of his Son that in touching us with that precious blood, we are made clean and whole. A ruse at repentance is to be lost. Real repentance and faith is to realize God is nearer to us than hands and feet and breathing!

CSS Publishing Co., Inc., Bitter-sweet Recollections, by Barbara Brokhoff