Matthew 5:38-42 · An Eye for an Eye
God’s Weather Report
Matthew 5:38-48
Sermon
by Charles L. Aaron
Loading...

In the 1985 movie, Witness, Harrison Ford plays a tough Philadelphia detective who uncovers corruption within his department. To protect himself and a young boy who has witnessed a murder, Ford's character, John Book, hides out among the Pennsylvania Amish, the community from which the little boy comes. In one scene of the movie, Book and several of the Amish go into town for a day of shopping. While they are in town, the buggies driven by the Amish are involved in a traffic jam with a car. The occupants of the car emerge to confront the Amish in the buggies. With unwarranted hostility, they taunt one young Amish man. One of the men from the car, a young tough, smears ice cream in the Amish man's face. Ignoring the protests of an older Amish man, Book goes over to beat up the ruffians who have bullied the young Amish man. The older Amish man insists to Book that, "it's not our way." To which Book responds, "Yeah, but it's my way."

The scene from the movie helps us focus on the content of our passage of scripture for this morning. The Amish, a community in the Anabaptist tradition, sees the Sermon on the Mount as part of their core scripture. The reason the young man in the scene doesn't fight back against the bullies is that he is turning the other cheek, as Jesus said to do. In order to avoid violence, in order to avoid anyone getting hurt, he willingly accepts humiliation. When Jesus tells us to turn the other cheek in this passage, he almost certainly refers to how to respond to an insult, not to a situation of self-defense. The image is of someone giving the backhand to another person on the right cheek, as a putdown. The bullies insult the Amish man, but didn't threaten to physically hurt him.

The progression of the scene in the movie, from the taunting to the ice cream in the face to Book punching out two of the bullies was designed to create in the viewers a sense of catharsis, a release of emotions. Watching the bullies pick on the Amish man creates a building anger inside of us. Something inside of us doesn't want them to get away with what they did. Something inside of us resists hearing and acting out what Jesus calls us to do in this passage. Something in us wants to be John Book, not the young Amish man. We don't want to turn the other cheek. We don't want to love our enemies.

In May of 2006, the whole country had to confront an enemy. His cold angry eyes stared at us from our newspapers and television sets. Zacarias Moussaoui was sentenced to life in prison. He was the only person tried in American courts for the terrorist attack on 9/11. Many people in our country, including many family members of the victims of 9/11, had hoped that the courts would sentence Moussaoui to death. Some people see a life sentence as an act of mercy. One juror kept Moussaoui from a death sentence. Technically, one of the issues was just how involved Moussaoui was in the 9/11 plot. Nevertheless, many people interpreted the jury's decision as a declaration that we in the United States are not ruled by vengeance. We can step back from our rage at 9/11 and make careful distinctions. We are angry over 9/11, but our anger doesn't control us.

We should be gratified that our system of justice is able to understand that Moussaoui is still a human being. Nevertheless, even though we in the church can affirm the mercy that our courts showed to Moussaoui, a situation like this always feels unfinished. Often when we show mercy, the person we show mercy to doesn't respond the way we hope they will. We like situations in which, when we show mercy, the other person has pangs of conscience, feels sorry, and becomes changed by our mercy. That doesn't always happen. Moussaoui is a good example. After the verdict, in which his life was spared, he gloated. He shouted out that he had won and America had lost. Not only does such an outburst increase our anger, but we may feel as though our mercy has been wasted. He didn't learn anything from our mercy. We might begin to wonder whether we can follow Jesus' teachings here. How can we let the bad guys gloat? How can we allow ourselves to appear weak?

We may need to go back to the beginning of the Sermon on the Mount. As you recall the Sermon begins with a series of blessings. These blessings sound strange to our ears. Blessed are the poor in spirit, blessed are those who mourn. The blessings are for those we do not at all see as blessed. They are blessed because of the dominion of God. When the dominion of God comes in it fullness, that's when the blessing will be fully realized. We have to wait for it. We have to resist our impulses, our emotions, and our urges for the sake of the dominion of God.

The church has two legitimate stances toward war: pacifism and just war theory. We cannot give a full account of both positions today. In the simplest terms, a pacifist believes that no situation justifies violence or war. A just war theorist believes that some use of violence and some acts of war are justified. The violence must be defensive, proportional, and a last resort, among other qualifications. A believer in just war thinks that sometimes countries need to use their military. Sometimes we have to defend ourselves, or our loved ones. We do need to resist the urge for vengeance. It is difficult to determine what exactly we should do in each situation. As best we can, we should resist violence. In the movie, Witness, many in the audience felt a catharsis when Harrison's Ford's character beat up the two bullies. Maybe, because of Christ, sometimes we must wait for that sense of catharsis, that release of emotions. At times, we must resist what we feel. Maybe all of our desire for justice, for people to learn their lesson, for things to be set right may have to wait for the dominion of God. We can work for change now, but peacefully.

Throughout the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus has taught us to resist what we feel. Jesus has taught us to resist our lust, our greed, our anger, our desire for security. We resist these things because we wait for God's blessings to come, for the dominion of God. Now Jesus teaches us maybe the hardest thing of all: to love our enemies, to turn the other cheek. Jesus calls us to this teaching because of who God is. God makes the sun to rise on the evil and the good. God sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. Sun and rain are concrete. They bring life to our world. They provide our food. Sun and rain are also reminders of God's grace. God's grace is available to all. God's grace is available to bullies, to Zacarias Moussaoui, to the people who have hurt us. God offering grace to people who have hurt us does not mean God doesn't care about our pain. God offers us healing. Part of that healing is forgiveness.

Immaculee Ilibagiza was a 22-year-old university student in the 1990s when terrible violence broke out in her home country of Rwanda. Hutus killed her parents, her brothers, and hundreds of her Tutsi friends. A Hutu pastor, who risked his life to save her, hid her and six other women. They lived in a small bathroom, a wooden wardrobe covering the door. For three months, they endured hunger, fear, and the sounds of soldiers in the house unsuccessfully searching for Tutsis. In those cramped quarters, she began to pray the Rosary. Always she stumbled over the Lord's Prayer: "Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us." She knew that the prayer called her to forgive those who had killed her family and endangered her. She didn't think she could do it, but she realized she was consumed by hate. She was afraid she would become like the people who had killed her family. Nevertheless, in her mind, forgiving her family's killers was like forgiving the devil. Finally, afraid that her hate would crush her heart, she asked God to forgive those who had done her so much harm. Slowly, with God's help, she was able to let go and forgive her family's killers. Eventually, she even visited one of her brother's killers in prison, taking his hand and offering forgiveness. She says that forgiveness saved her life. "It's a new life, almost like a resurrection."1

Our passage ends with Jesus calling us to be prefect as God is perfect. That is not perfection as in not making mistakes. It is perfect as in being whole. We live in a broken, imperfect world. We will not all face the situation that Immaculee Ilibagiza faced. We will face challenges in showing love and offering forgiveness. We bear witness to the character of God, who causes the sun to shine on the good and the bad. We are the salt of the earth and the light of the world. We in the church show the world what it means to love, to forgive, to resist our feelings and our anger. We show the world that even with all of the brokenness, because of God, we can be whole. Amen.


1. Bob Smietana, "Woman Challenged to Forgive Massacre of Family in Rwanda," United Methodist Reporter, 152.51, April 28, 2006, p. 3A.

CSS Publishing Company, Inc., Becoming The Salt and The Light, by Charles L. Aaron