Luke 14:1-14 · Jesus at a Pharisee’s House
Divine Dinner Party Decorum
Luke 14:1-14
Sermon
by R. Robert Cueni
Loading...

Luke opens the fourteenth chapter by telling us that Jesus "was going to the house of a leader of the Pharisees to eat a meal on the sabbath," and that "they were watching him closely." Notice four important details in this one verse. 

First, notice that Jesus is a guest at a dinner party. Important things happen when people gather for dinner. Table talk provides a forum for friends and families to catch up on the events in the lives of one another. At the dinner table, we teach our children manners. At the table we hear the stories that bind us together as immediate family, larger community, even as a nation. We are told what is expected of us. We learn the family secrets that are to be shared with no one outside our circle. Table conversation has a long history laden with religious, social, and psychological meaning.1 Is it any wonder that as the family of God we gather for worship around the table?

Second, notice that the meal mentioned in Luke 14 takes place at the home of a Pharisee. This was a very important religious group in Jesus' time. Phariseeism began as a religious movement among Jews living outside of Palestine. As sojourners in foreign lands the Hebrew people needed a way to maintain their religious identity. They could not regularly attend worship at the great Temple in Jerusalem. They rubbed elbows daily with those who did not know Yahweh, their God. They had to find a way to keep themselves together as the Chosen People of God. The Pharisee response to the threat of cultural dilution was to say, "We will maintain our Jewish identity by keeping Torah, the Hebrew Law. Even when we live among non-believers, we will keep our religion and ourselves pure. Even when the military powers of this world enslave us, we remain God's people." By faithfulness to the Torah, the observant Jew could say, "I know who I am and the world knows who we are. We are the ones who keep God's Law." At a time when most other cultures were being lost to Roman ways of thinking and doing, the Pharisees offered a method for maintaining Jewish identity. 

Third, this dinner party at the house of the Pharisee takes place on the Sabbath. Keeping this holy day for rest and worship was central to Jewish differentiation from the surrounding Roman culture. Jewish law developed 270 different regulations for keeping the Sabbath. These rules governed the minutest details of what one was permitted and not permitted to do from sunset Friday to sunset Saturday. To the Pharisees these rules were essential. Jewish identity as the chosen people of God was bound up in keeping the Sabbath rules. 

Fourth, Luke tells us that the Pharisees kept a suspicious eye on Jesus at this dinner party. We should expect that. Jesus was an unknown quantity to the Pharisees. They needed to know "Is he one of us? Is he going to harm or help our efforts to keep our identity pure?" The Pharisees are the ones in charge of this sort of thing. If Jesus did anything to degrade the purity of their religious practice, they had a duty to stop him. They were the religious elite and they took their job very seriously. 

"On one occasion when Jesus was going to the house of a leader of the Pharisees to eat a meal on the sabbath, they were watching him closely" (v. 1). Do not think of this dinner party as a casual gathering of old friends.2 This is one of the social occasions of the year. The party is being held at the home of the "host and hostess with the most-est." This gathering will be featured in next week's New York Times society page with pictures showing fortunate attendees holding glasses of champagne. The accompanying article will say things like: "Guests included Isaac Gold, whose father, the late Simon Gold, cornered the market on the precious metal that bears the family name. Sophie Stein, Nobel Prize winner in chemistry, wore a simple dress with a string of pearls purchased from Cartier last spring. Chief Justice of the Supreme Court for Religious Issues, Rabbi Israel Caiphas, was accompanied by his wife and daughter."
 This is the crème de la crème of the town. If attendees are not already there, an invitation to this party will slingshot them to the top of the social ladder. 

Of course, Jesus does not usually share a foothold on the top rung of that ladder. He has been invited because he has been in the news lately. The Pharisees want to see if he is as good as his reputation. If for no other reason, his name on the guest list shows that the Pharisees are open to new people and new ideas. Most of all, however, the local blue bloods want to check him out. "Is he one of us? Could he be the replacement when Rabbi Caiphas retires? Is Jesus sufficiently prominent that his name needs added to the list of regular guests?" No wonder Luke says that the other guests were "watching him closely." 

The dining room is magnificent. The crystal chandelier came from Paris. It has so many baubles three servants needed four days to clean it. The buffet is opulent: beluga caviar, smoked salmon with the heads still attached, sterling silver serving platters, and an orchid centerpiece.  Deciding the seating arrangement has taken hours. In fact, the hostess used a dinner party consultant to be certain that the right people got seated in the right order. In spite of that, Jesus notices that when he thought no one was watching, young Joe Cohen moved his name tag from near the bottom of the table to up near the host. 

The butler signals "Dinner is served." The rabbi offers a much too long invocation. People find their places and the meal begins. Most of the polite table talk concerns the new director of the symphony, the recently announced leverage buy-out of the local matzo ball factory, and how the neighborhood took a nose dive when the Roman governor bought the house down the street. During dinner's third course, Jesus says in a voice loud enough for everyone to hear. "Folks, I have been talking with my new friend Amos here and he tells me that he has a serious problem with swollen ankles. He's just miserable and so I am going to see if I can heal him."
 At that point, the hostess nearly swallows her tongue. She gasps, "Well, I never!" 

"Clear off the table so Amos can stretch out," Jesus says. "Careful with the creamed asparagus. Amos, crawl up there and elevate your feet over your head. That is important with swollen ankles." Amos crawls on the table. Rests his head on the bread tray and his wife's face turns as red as her glass of Cabernet. This is definitely not the dignified behavior one expects at a party for Pharisees. Mr. Stein turns to his wife and says, "What will people think when word of this hits the streets?" Jesus makes matters even worse when he leaps into the middle of the dining table. He grabs Amos' swollen ankles and begins to massage them and pray over them.
 At this point, Rabbi Caiphas goes ballistic. He begins to lecture Jesus on his inappropriate behavior. "Is it not enough that you behave boorishly? Now you heal on the Sabbath. Romans, Greeks, and assorted other pagans work on the Sabbath, not faithful Jews. You are undermining what it means to be identified as God's chosen people." 

Jesus responds to the effect, "Hold on a minute now. Amos' feet hurt. I wanted to give him some relief. The religious law permits rescuing a donkey from a well on the Sabbath. Certainly it should permit the rescue of one of God's children on the Sabbath. You folks are fussing about being decent and following the rules, but should not the needs of people take precedence?"
 Then Jesus brings up the issue of the order of seating at the table. He talks about how embarrassing it is to take one of the preferred seats at the table only to have a more important person come along and "bump" you into less prestigious seating. Joe Cohen, the young man Jesus saw switching nametags before the dinner started, drops his eyes and looks like a child caught with a hand in the cookie jar.

Then Jesus launches into a discourse about who should be invited to a dinner party. Don't just invite your relatives, business associates, and rich friends, he tells them. All of those people will turn around and invite you to their next party. Instead of calculated reciprocity, invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, and the blind. "They cannot repay you, for you will be repaid at the resurrection of the righteous" (v. 14). 

The Hebrew people of Jesus' time were not unlike people of every generation. They wanted to know, "What gives my life meaning?" The Pharisees in Jesus' time answered that question by saying, "Our lives have meaning because God has a covenant with us. We are the chosen people of God. We stay faithful to God by the careful observance of the Hebrew Law. When we keep the religious law, God is pleased with us and the world knows we are the chosen people of God." 

Jesus answered that question in a different way. He took his relationship to God very seriously, but he did not observe all the rules and regulations. Jesus understood that the Jews had a special relationship to God. Just as the scripture taught, they were God's chosen people. However, Jesus expands on that to insist that God has a special relationship with all of creation. We are all in the same family -- God's family. We are all the chosen people of God. Our identity, our "worthwhileness" comes from the fact that we are God's children. We keep faith with the family membership, not by observing the law, but by loving one another. For Jesus to be faithful to God, he had to set a higher priority on healing Amos' swollen ankles than he put on keeping the Sabbath or maintaining the dignified ethos of the dinner party. By doing so, he demonstrated his faithfulness to God. 

From this you can conclude that you are worthwhile simply because of whose you are. Your value as a person does not rely on having your name on the social register. You are the loved child of God. You cannot improve on that social standing. 

To be successful in life, you do not have to sneak your nametag a little higher up the table. Your worth comes from being a loved family member, not from having a better seat at the dinner party. You are a member of the family of God. 

A hundred years ago, Ralph Waldo Emerson noted three qualities he deemed marks of true "success": the ability to discern and appreciate beauty, the ability to see the best in others, and a commitment to leaving the world a better place.3 Notice that Emerson does not say that success comes in having the best seat at the table, acquiring more material possessions, or in belonging to the best clubs. Emerson contends that success comes with appreciating God's world, developing loving relationships with God's people, and with working to improve God's world. Jesus would agree heartily. 

In fact, our scripture lesson for today ends with a wonderful suggestion of how to work to make the world a better place. Invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, and the blind to dinner. They are all members of your family. Just think how much richer your table talk will be if you don't just associate with your business associates and closest relatives. Remember around the table such wonderful things happen. Invite everyone to the table. They are all members of the extended family.


1. Fred Craddock, Interpretation: Luke (Louisville: John Knox Press, 1990), p. 175.

2. I am indebted to Robert Capon, The Parables of Grace (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1988), pp. 117-128, for his delightful rendering of the dinner party at the home of the Pharisee. It inspired this interpretation.

3. Homiletics, Volume 7, Number 3, July-September, 1995, p. 40.

CSS Publishing Company, Sermons on the Gospel Readings, Series I, Cycle C, by R. Robert Cueni