Luke 13:1-9 · Repent or Perish
The 5 Worst Things Christians Say After A Tragedy
Luke 13:1-9
Sermon
by Leonard Sweet
Loading...

In the immediate aftermath of the Super Bowl, a reporter asked Ray Lewis, star player of the Baltimore Ravens, "How does it feel to be a Super Bowl Champion?" He responded "When God is for you, who can be against you?"

Excuse me? God had a favorite team? You mean God liked one Harbaugh brother over the other?

Candidate Richard Mourdock in his losing attempt to win a Senate seat in Indiana, said this: “Even when life begins in that horrible situation of rape, that is something that God intended to happen."

Excuse me? If something happens, then God intends it to happen? Sandy Hook Elementary? Hurricane Sandy? God willed these things to happen?

Where do these professed Christians get this stuff? Where do they learn their theology? Learn their bad theology? If there is any greater evidence of the failure of Sunday school, it is the theology that gets expressed in the wake of a tragedy. What Christians say right after a disaster is disastrous and downright embarrassing.

The most horrible things are said about God when people try to say the nicest things about Him. Here are some of the worst offenders.

1) “They didn’t deserve this.”

Especially said after a murder. Does anyone ever deserve suffering, pain, evil, rape, much less murder?

2) “It’s part of God’s plan.”

Evil and suffering are a part of God’s plan? Hello!?! Madness, mayhem and murder are NEVER part of God’s “plan.”

3) “They’re in a better place.”

God values this life, and expects us to value and not take this life for granted. How dare we insult the Giver by not enjoying the gifts we’ve been given here?

4) “It’s punishment for the sins of our nation” or “it’s a reflection of how far we’ve fallen away from God.”

Do you really think that a good, beautiful, true God would raise up a shooter to kill children to make us repent, or to condemn a specific sin (you pick your favorite offense)?

It’s not just lay people mouthing such bad, ugly, false theology. You can hear pastors sometimes saying these horrors. Even insurance companies use the term "act of God" to describe a natural disaster. Acts of God are not hurricanes and rapes and murders and disasters. Acts of God are love, and compassion and mercy.

This is what Jesus was communicating in our Scripture reading for today, which shows that Jesus knows what’s on the front page of the paper (so to speak) and that people engage him in conversation about the hottest news and most current events.

To be sure, a “current event” in Jesus’ day could have been a month old. Unlike today, when a “current event” is real time “breaking news.”

Modern marathons originated from the legend of one messenger’s massive run. Pheidippides, a Greek soldier around 490 BCE, was dispatched from the field of the battle of Marathon to Athens in order to announce the Greek victory over the Persians. The legend holds that Pheidippides ran the entire distance without stopping, but that when he burst into the assembly he only managed to breath out, “We won,” before he collapsed and breathed his last. It was the first “instant messaging” system.

Until 1937, the inauguration of a new American President did not happen until sometime in March. The actual voting happened in November, after the crops were in and carefully planned for a Tuesday so folks could go to church on Sunday but still have time to travel to the local polling place on Monday, and then after the voting on Tuesday could head out for a shopping trip on the traditional Wednesday “market day.”

But not until mid-March were all the votes gathered and tallied. That’s why it took months for a presidential winner to be declared, and then for that victor to travel to the capitol and set up residence so that he could begin administrating the government. It’s hard for a 24/7, round-the-clock news-cycle world to understand just how difficult it was for our ancestors to just get ideas, information, and people from point A to point B.

Now we fuss and fume when it takes more than five second to connect to an on-line database that plugs us into a constantly updated stream of current events. Nothing happens without it being instantly accessible to everybody, everywhere. Any place can be every place.

There are no more secret corners of the world. As long as you have a web address, the actions of militia in Mumbai or kindergarten teachers in Kentucky are all instantly accessible. We have grown used to living off of headlines. The front page stories that broke ten minutes ago are tweeted and instagramed across the world within seconds. We forget that it has only been possible to live his way for the past two decades.

The gospel text for this week is unique in its “ripped from the headlines” feel. In the first century citing “current events” typically meant referring back a century or two and recalling some historical battle or decisive prophetic deliverance. But Luke records both the crowd’s listening to Jesus and Jesus himself using events “ripped from the headlines” to inform and form faithfulness.

It was not just the message of repentance that these “current events” curried. Jesus used these up-to-the-minute examples to show his listeners that all human beings were trapped in the same leaking, listing boat. All are doomed for disaster. All need the merciful hand of God.

It is Lent, and that means a season, or at least a few minutes, of introspective soul searching. It is a time to re-evaluate our life. It is a time to consider new possibilities. It is a time to consider the life-altering options Christ has offered to us. It is a time for repentance.

We tend to think of “repentance” as some sort of “boo-hoo, I’m sorry” moment that will hopefully result in an individual change, a “metanoia,” a “turn-about” or “about-face” to a new life with new possibilities. We tend to forget that the option for repentance is wholly dependent upon God’s imploring invitation to take that action. Repentance is not something human beings undertake. Repentance is a grace and mercy that God extends towards all of us.

The real “current event” Jesus was communicating to his audience was not about any Galileans who had been massacred or any worshipers at the tumbling wall by the pool of Siloam. Rather, it was about the greatest and most eternally ongoing “current event” ever revealed. God loves us and wants us to be in a safe, saving, sanctified relationship with the Divine. The greatest current event is the currency of God’s love.

In the words of Rev. Emily Heath, whose Vermont church was destroyed in hurricane Irene: “I know God will be there tomorrow, because I know that wherever there is hope, there is God. And while the flood ‘was,’ God ‘is’ and God will be.”

Jesus, the “new Adam,” the new tender of the garden, argues to save the barren fig tree, to give our barren lives, our fruitless existences, one more chance — the chance he offers through his own sacrifice. One more chance at repentance. One more chance for truth. One more chance for beauty. One more chance for goodness. One more chance to experience the acceptance and love God the Father.

The “current event” Jesus preached was not “ripped” from any headline; it was reaped from God’s creative love. God loves us. Jesus loves us. Jesus, and all of God’s prophets through the ages, have called upon men and women to “repent.” Not to emphasize human sinfulness, but as a means of all of us celebrating our acknowledgment of divine love.

There is a common phrase, “Stuff happens.” The phrase is a recognition that bad things happen to people for no particular reason, that life isn’t fair. But with Christ, when “stuff happens,” eternal life happens. God happens. No matter what happens, or how many times it happens, no matter how many towers fall and hurricanes hit or mass-murderers strike, God love is greater still. God’s love unlocked the door to eternal life. All that we need to do is turn the knob and enter in.

That takes an act of repentance — a turning towards God’s love and away from all that stands against that love.

Let me end this morning where we began: with a 5th disaster theology phrase and comfort. It’s a variation of #2:

5) “God has a plan for your life.”

Really? Only one? Do I get a say? Do I find it by trial and error? Is finding that “plan” like hunting for a needle in the haystack?

Want to know “God’s Plan?” God’s “Perfect Plan” has a name: Jesus, who came to show us how much God loves us and wants to share the divine life with us.

This is God’s plan for you. This is God’s plan for your life.

Got any rivers you think are uncrossable?

Got any mountains you can’t tunnel through?

God specializes in things thought impossible

God does things that others cannot do.


COMMENTARY

At the end of every good action movie the big time bad guy finally gets what is coming to him. When the good guy hero dispatches the evil-doer, the audience cheers. Obviously this final judgment was well deserved and proved that the wicked will be punished — hopefully in some dramatic and dreadful way. We all like to believe in cosmic come-uppance.

In this week’s gospel text some of those listening to Jesus speak ask him to comment on some “current events” of the day. The tragedies reported by those in the crowd and those noted by Jesus here in Luke’s text are not recorded in any other surviving literature/historical first century documents. But the events sound sadly familiar. The unexpected and untimely deaths of both the “Galileans” slaughtered by Pilate and of those crushed by the “tower of Siloam” had been positively interpreted by Jesus’ listeners as demonstration of well-deserved divine judgment.

The particular incident cited by the crowd to Jesus involved Pilate slaying an unspecified number of Galileans while they were performing a ritual sacrifice of their own. Unfortunately, that kind of violent act, disregarding both Jewish life and Jewish law, was typical behavior for the prefect (see Josephus, “Antiquities” 18:35-89). Those questioning Jesus hope to hear him affirm that there was a reason for these particular Galileans to be cut down. It was an act of divine judgment, they theologized, and those slain must have somehow been “worse sinners” than all others. The crowd is voicing the theology of Deuteronomy 28-30, where those who obey God’s commandments are rewarded, while those who turn away from God suffer divine judgment and reap despair, illness, imprisonment, hunger, poverty, and death (see also Job 4:17; Ezekiel 18:26).

Jesus will have none of it. Jesus refuses to make such a straight-line assessment of the Galilean tragedy. Jesus even refuses to divide the world into “good guys” and “bad guys,” into “us” vs. “them.” Instead, Jesus declares the need for universal repentance. All of “us” are “them,” he says, and without the act of repentance this world of “worse sinners” will perish. The death of those Galileans did not single them out as ones who were specifically evil. Their death only served as a stark example of the need for all people to repent of their sins and realign their lives in a right relationship with God.

Likewise Jesus offers his own example to the crowd the “eighteen who were killed when the tower of Siloam fell on them.” Again, this is an event unknown outside of this text, although Josephus does mention that towers studded the Temple walls that rose above the ancient “fountain of Siloam” (Josephus, “Jewish War” 5:145). Unfortunately in the twenty-first century we are all too familiar with the tragic consequences of toppling towers. While Jesus does not absolve any of those who perished, neither does he find them any different than the whole population of Jerusalem. All Galileans, all Jerusalemites, all the people of this world stand on common ground, on broken ground, in a broken relationship with God. It is from this common place of brokenness that all need to offer repentance and seek out God’s mercy.

It is hardly by happenstance that Luke here specifically records an incident involving Pilate murdering “Galileans” or that Jerusalem itself is the scene of disaster and death. Jesus, a Galilean, is headed towards Jerusalem, and has already described his destruction at the hands of the religious and political leaders in that city (Luke 9:21-22). Those who do not repent and believe in the gospel would certainly see Jesus simply as the executed criminal he was judged to be by those leaders. Jesus himself must have been one of those “worse sinners” who “got what he deserved.” But for those who “repent and believe,” the story has a very different ending.

The parable of the fig tree — found in a narrative format in Mark 11:12-14 and Matthew 21:18-19 — offers a final, hopeful note on this theme of repentance. While in Mark and Matthew the fruitless fig tree is soundly cursed by Jesus, here the puny producer earns a reprieve. The master of the vineyard where the tree is planted has patiently waited for three years for some fruitfulness, with no results. The frustrated fig tree owner decides the time has come to cut his losses — and cut down the tree.

But the servant tending the vineyard and all the plants growing within it offers an alternative to this immediate destruction. The gardener suggests he extended special care, special nutrients, and a year’s reprieve — giving the fig tree one more season to prove its fruit-bearing ability. In the context of Jesus’ message to “repent,” this is the fig tree’s opportunity to “repent” of its barrenness. It now has an opportunity to fulfill its true nature as a fructifying, life-producing creation. Instead of being soundly cursed for its bare branches, in Luke’s version of the fig tree the puny plant is granted a second change — a chance to “repent” and a chance to demonstrate its change of “heart” with quantifiable fruitfulness.

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., Leonard Sweet Sermons.com, by Leonard Sweet