1 Kings 18:16-46 · Elijah on Mount Carmel
Make Up Your Mind!
1 Kings 18:16-46
Sermon
by Robert Leslie Holmes
Loading...

Why hasn’t Hollywood made this into a major motion picture epic? 1 Kings 18 is surely one of the most dramatic accounts in all literature and one of the most significant historical records in the Bible. Its message and natural application are timeless.

William Penn said, “Men must be governed by God or they will be ruled by tyrants.” In our Scripture reading for today the people of Israel came together to decide no less a question than who would govern their personal and national lives, who would be their God and the God of their nation.

I. What Kind Of God Do You Believe In?

“What kind of God do you believe in?” It was not that the people of Israel had no god. They were, in truth, very spiritual. They had many gods, called Baals. The Baals were alluring gods who could be worshiped according to the momentary dictates of the flesh and lustful imagination. They included Baals of power, sex, money, popularity, and prestige. No wonder they were popular! The Israelites also paid homage to the true God. After all, he was the One who had delivered their ancestors out of bondage. To give up on him completely would be a mark of disrespect to their forebears. They could never fully give up on the God of their national heritage, and so they politely included him with quick nod-of-the-head acknowledgments as they went about their own business. As a result, the religion of the true God and the Baals became entangled in their national mindset through the process of time. They failed to remember that “I the Lord your God am a jealous God, punishing children for the iniquity of parents, to the third and the fourth generation” (Exodus 20:5). Elijah confronted them with this truth in the name of Jehovah and forced them to answer the question of national and personal loyalty. It could not be God and the Baals. It had to be God or the Baals.

A fellow attending a major league baseball game caused a bit of a stir in the stands. No matter which team made a hit or a run, he cheered. Finally, curiosity caught someone behind him. Leaning forward, the second man asked, “Why are you rooting for both teams? Don’t you understand this game?” By way of response the first one replied, “I live too far away to get to a ballgame like this more than once every couple of years, so I pull for both teams. That way, no matter who wins, I go home happy.” You don’t have to be a sports fan to know that if you have any sense of loyalty to the home team, you will not root for both sides. “No one can serve two masters” (Matthew 6:24) is a principle that has application for sports as well as for religion.

Yet, that is exactly what we seem to be attempting in our current quest for pluralism pushed to extremes. Today America has moved from the “one nation under God” commitment described in our Pledge of Allegiance to a nation of multi-faceted deities who present themselves in a plethora of variations on a theme. We are not, as is sometimes said of us, a godless nation. We are, rather, a nation of many gods. You can hear the hymns and confessions of our pluralistic deities, often sung at the same time, in all the trendy places from university campuses to the media and even in the church sometimes. We have no fixed standards. We have lived through a subtle theological gearshift from believing in God to believing in spirituality. No longer is the God of the Bible central to our understanding of deity and worship. Instead, we have become devotees of a faith that sets personal experience above God’s truth revealed in the Bible. Doctrine and dogma have given way to something called “cosmic consciousness” or the “true self.” America being what it is, a place where consumerism and popular opinion polls determine what matters, it should not surprise us to know that millions of dollars are spent to promote this trendy phenomenon. At this dawning of the new millennium, religion and spirituality have gotten all mixed up like the ingredients in a cement mixer, except nothing solid or lasting will come of this hybrid thing we call religion.

I believe that America today faces the same choice that Israel did when Elijah called the people to meet on Mount Carmel. There is perhaps no more telling evidence of it than the response of many to the ugly crisis in the White House and Congress just two years or so ago. Attempts to replace the Constitution with the latest popular opinion polls were telling evidence of how our nation is spiritually adrift. We saw that many of our leaders have, in Stephen Vincent Benet’s words, “no fixed stars.” God’s standards of morality and truth possess little relevance or authority for many people in our time and place. Sociologists and historians say that America has entered a post-Christian era, and it is fair to ask if we are even a Constitutional nation. More’s the pity for, “Where there is no prophecy, the people cast off restraint” (Proverbs 29:18). When anything goes, one of the first things a nation loses is God’s sure hand of mercy, guidance, and blessing.

In their book, The Fourth Turning: An American Prophecy,1 historical sociologists William Strauss and Neil Howe have done some intriguing research with America’s history, viewing events through the lens of each generation and making some projections about the future. To be short, their picture is not promising. They predict that within a few years there will be an American crisis on the scale of the American Revolution, the Civil War, or the Crash of ’29. So how do we prepare for it, just in case they are right? Do we stockpile food, water, and guns, and store our money in jelly jars in the backyard? Or, do we ask ourselves what really matters? Who is my God? What rules and principles shall guide the way I live this life entrusted to me?

Whatever else we do, we should know where our commitment lies. It is my responsibility to tell you this! You have already decided. Whether or not Strauss and Howe are right in their estimation of our future, I cannot say. Of this, however, I can be sure: I have an obligation to my God to warn you that any life where he is not given his proper place, whether it is national or personal, is a life lived on the edge of destruction. “If the sentinel sees the sword coming and does not blow the trumpet, so that the people are not warned, and the sword comes and takes any of them, they are taken away in their iniquity, but their blood I will require at the sentinel’s hand” (Ezekiel 33:6). “Now if you are unwilling to serve the Lord, choose this day whom you will serve ... but as for me and my household, we will serve the Lord” (Joshua 24:15).

I am also certain of this: There is no neutral ground. If you think you can delay making a choice, you have already chosen, whether you realize it or not. When we, as a nation, try to root for two teams in the spiritual realm, when we pass on no settled values of right and wrong, our children will do what the Baal followers did. They will try to create a cocktail of deities, a god-blend. In the process, they will become unwitting slaves to the passions of each moment, much like the dogs in the street. Instead of being a beacon of hope, light, and leadership to the world, America will drift off as Rome, Greece, and old Israel did before us.

British school children a generation or so ago were taught a phrase designed to heighten their national pride. That phrase was, “The sun never sets on the British Empire.” Watching the lowering of the flag over Hong Kong a couple of years ago, a friend of mine, who grew up in Britain remembered East African Church and business leaders in Nairobi, to whom he had traveled to speak, jeering in response to that phrase. You see, they too once were taught that phrase. From their own experiences and those of other former colonies, they knew that the sun had long ago set on the British Empire. In fact, they were living proof that it had, for they were, that very year, commemorating the twenty-fifth anniversary of independence as a church and nation. Their gathering itself was evidence that a once-great empire had fallen, in the space of little more than one generation, to become a second-rate power. What happened to the British Empire can happen to America. It is, in fact, already happening. We do well to remember Ezekiel’s words when he cried out, “Turn back, turn back from your evil ways; for why will you die, O [America]?” (cf. Ezekiel 33:11).

II. The God Who Is There

Elijah called Israel to recognize that the true God has plans and standards that do not change and that will not be compromised. Behind them all stands His never failing love. Let it be said very clearly that true love is not demonstrated by permissiveness. A loving parent does not permit a child to do anything the child wants. A loving parent sets standards for the child’s own good. That child, in turn, passes them along to the next generation. God, in love, has set standards for us and for America. “By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God and obey his commandments. For the love of God is this, that we obey his commandments” (1 John 5:2-3). God loves us enough to set safe limits on us. We should do no less for our leaders and fellow citizens. To do less is to sin against this God who sends fire from heaven.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer became a World War II Christian martyr for refusing to join other church “leaders” in turning a blind-eye to Nazi terrorism. He said, “Only those who obey truly believe and those who believe truly obey.” He knew that belief and obedience go together like the two sides of a coin. One side is worthless without the other. The Bible’s God is not a by-product of momentary passions or fanciful imaginations. He is the Creator of all things good and they were called into being by his mighty power. “Popular” opinion, no matter how popular, cannot change his nature and laws.

The Baal followers forgot that as, it seems, have many in our day. Elijah challenged them: “How long will you go limping with two different opinions? If the Lord is God, follow him; but if Baal, then follow him” (1 Kings 18:21). You will note that they had no answer to Elijah’s question. Nor, do the pseudo-intellectuals of our generation.

III. The God Who Calls Us To Choose

Today, in this service, we also come to the moment of choice. It is not a choice about whether we will serve, but about whom we will serve for we are already in service to someone. “I call heaven and earth to witness against you today that I have set before you life and death, blessings and curses. Choose life so that you and your descendants may live” (Deuteronomy 30:19).

In the Amazon there is a slave-making ant that illustrates our predicament. Hundreds of these little creatures periodically swarm out of their nest to capture neighboring colonies of weaker ants. They attack with no warning and kill off any defenders before carrying off cocoons containing the larvae of worker ants. When these slave children hatch, they assume they are part of the family around them and launch into the work they were captured to do. They never realize that they are, in fact, forced-labor victims of the enemy. Just as these little ants are bound from the time of birth, so we also enter this world as slaves to sin and Satan. For us, however, there is a solution, and it is to decide resolutely now for Jesus Christ, the Son of God who took away our sins on Calvary’s cross. Make your decision for Christ and ask him in the Holy Spirit’s power to help you to serve the true God alone for this day and forever more.

What kind of God will you believe in? Which one will you serve? In the name Almighty God, I urge you today to meet the only God who died for you and who alone can make you promises that are good for you and will never be broken. Let this be your day to commit yourself anew to God and to his Son, Jesus, the Lord of the cross.


1. Strauss, William and Neil Howe, The Fourth Turning: An American Prophecy (New York: Broadway Books, 1998).

CSS Publishing Company, Two Kings and Three Prophets for Less than a Quarter, by Robert Leslie Holmes