Luke 13:1-9 · Repent or Perish
Headlines and Holiness
Luke 13:1-9
Sermon
by Frank G. Honeycutt
Loading...

Imagine for a moment that Jesus is watching television with his twelve disciples. They're on furlough from teaching and healing, taking it easy in the living room of Peter's mother-in-law, doing a little mindless channel surfing. Maybe they catch a little of an NCAA Tournament game, March Madness. These are guys, you know, just relaxing from a demanding schedule. 

But eventually the evening news comes on. They put down the popcorn and listen intently to the day's tragedies. One disciple says, "Hey, Jesus, that horrible bombing over on the West Bank where that guy drove a bus into a crowd of people. Do you think that because these Palestinians suffered in this way they were worse sinners than the rest?" It was a popular question in Jesus' day. Still is. If something bad happened, it must have been for a reason. Jesus scratches his beard for a moment. "No, they didn't die because of anything they did. It was a purely random thing. But let me tell you something. Unless you guys clean up your acts, you'll die just as tragically." 

There is a low murmur in the room. The disciples look at each other like Jesus has missed his morning medication. As two begin to leave to find a bathroom, the newscaster reports another catastrophe, this one halfway across the world. Jesus pipes up this time. "Hey, guys," he says, "those people over in El Salvador. What about them? The earthquake that hit there killed hundreds of people. Does that mean that these Salvadorans were worse sinners than their neighbors in Guatemala?" Jesus waits for his question to sink in. "No, the tragedy had nothing to do with their morals. Those people just got in the way." The disciples breathe a sigh of relief, gladdened to know that God doesn't work that way. But then Jesus looks at them all. "Let me tell you something, though. Unless you people start going in the right direction, you will share a similar fate as those Salvadorans and it will seem like a building falling on your head to crush the life out of you." I believe somebody got up and changed the channel after that. 

Am I getting these details right? For my money, this story of Jesus and the day's headlines is as strange and befuddling as any in the Gospels. What was Jesus thinking? His followers were clearly concerned about the news events of the day. Both reports are about atrocities visited upon innocents. One news story describes a case of evil devised by intentional malice. Pilate gruesomely kills some Galileans as they knelt at worship. The other story describes suffering by random chance. Eighteen people over near the pool of Siloam are crushed because they happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time. These two headlines pretty much cover the waterfront of any modern headline that deals with suffering. Any sad news report. A bad person caused it or someone was in the wrong place at the wrong time -- malice or chance, take your pick. 

Whichever you choose, the followers of Jesus want to try to make sense of suffering. A popular response was to try to find purpose, some reason, for the events of the day. "Were these worse sinners, Jesus?" Behind that question was an underlying assumption: these people must have done something really, horribly bad to cause God to abandon them in this way. 

Such assumptions are still very much with us. Many well-meaning Christians, uncomfortable with saying, "I don't know," need to produce a reason for everything that happens. For example, people get AIDS only because they are sexually promiscuous. Little children die because it was time for God to call them home. This catastrophe is happening to you now because of what you did thirty years ago. Christians are often uncomfortable with ambiguity, so we often concoct a preposterous reason to explain things. Certainty is a false god that brings comfort to many. Thankfully, Jesus parts ways with these assumptions. "Were these worse sinners, Jesus?" Twice, he says, "No." 

But watch what Jesus does. He does indeed part ways with those who want to say bad things happen only to bad people. "No, I tell you, it doesn't work that way," he says. But neither will Jesus spend much time with the faith-shaking, all-time favorite question of "enlightened" Christians. Why do bad things happen to good people? I get asked that all the time. In fact, I ask it all the time myself. We pick up the newspaper, listen to the evening news, and ask, Where is God? Could God not have prevented this tragedy? Was God asleep or something? And our real unspoken question is perhaps this: Does God even act in the world today at all? Is this whole life simply an exercise in randomness? Theologians today say that the number one question facing young people in this country is not atheism, whether or not God exists, but rather the question of meaninglessness,1 whether there's any real purpose to anything at all. 

It's rather peculiar that Jesus doesn't really tackle our favorite questions in this story. He doesn't go there, even though he could have, even though we wish he would indulge us at least for a moment. Here's a perfect opportunity to talk about the very thing that troubles us: Where is God? Why doesn't God do something? Endlessly interesting questions for most of us. Instead, Jesus does a rather shocking thing. 

They are all sitting around watching the evening news, stories of malice, stories of chance, and Jesus says the unthinkable. "No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all perish just as they did." Jesus, Mr. Compassion, said that. The gentle man who frolicked with children and bunnies. "Turn yourself around or you can count on a building collapsing on you some day on the way to work." What is that, anyway? Wouldn't you love to have Jesus at your hospital bedside? Wouldn't Jesus make a great teacher of pastoral care? "Pastor, did I get this colon cancer because of anything I did in my past?" "Heavens, no," is Jesus' pastoral response. "Where'd you get that idea? Don't give it another thought. But before we pray, let me share this little tidbit with you. Unless you clean up your act, my friend, it's curtains for you." The gospel of the Lord. 

What is Jesus doing here? I'll tell you what he's doing. He is slyly shifting the conversation away from God's responsibility and toward us. We love the God question. Where was God when this happened? It may be our all-time favorite philosophical question. One of the real classics. Not only that, it is also quite easy to watch the evening news and point out examples of really evil people and really evil events. The nation breathed easier, for example, when Timothy McVeigh was finally executed. One less atrocious human being in the world. It's easy to spot people like him. We are far less comfortable, however, discussing our own role in the suffering and injustice of this world. 

And we may say to Jesus, "Look, I never slit anybody's throat. I never designed a shoddily constructed building that collapsed on anybody." And you would be right. But Jesus is saying today, at least in part, that the headlines that grab our attention and raise our moral revulsion are finally a smokescreen for the more subtle sin that is in each of us. And who is to say that such collective sin does not do more damage -- more damage to the ecosystem, more damage to the hope of eradicating global poverty, and more damage to the widening racial divisions in our country than a boatload of evil villains and a century's worth of natural disasters? 

It is far easier, you see, to locate evil in somebody or something else rather than in ourselves. Far easier to rant and rave at the evening news rather than ask what I'm going to do about that or consider how the way I now live may, in fact, be contributing to the problem. 

Today Jesus will not allow his followers to blame others or God. He turns their philosophical gymnastics squarely back on them.  Jim Wallis, one of the founding members of the "Sojourners" community in Washington, D.C., writes these pointed words:

Many think conversion is only for nonbelievers, but the Bible sees conversion as also necessary for the erring believer, the lukewarm community of faith, the people of God who have fallen into disobedience and idolatry ... [Our task] is not to make the gospel easy but to make it clear ... evangelism should call for (and expect) a radical change in behavior and lifestyle.2 

It is easy for Christianity to exist in a vacuum, shouting condemnations of what we are "against" in the world. It is quite easy to talk back to the evening news and rail about the world's problems. Exponentially more difficult is being honest about the sin in ourselves. 

Jesus knows something that we often forget. It isn't the headlines that define the world's problems. It's us. We're all the problem. "For three years I've come looking for fruit on this tree, and still I find none."  Ultimately, our obsession with headlines is just a diversion from the real territory Jesus wants to enter. There are bloody tragedies every day across our country and world. I don't deny that. But perhaps our focus should return to the spilt blood of the cross, sown into our lives at Lent. 

More fruit will be harvested there than from a lifetime of watching the evening news.


1. See, for example, Douglas John Hall's excellent book, Why Christian? For Those on the Edge of Faith (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1998), especially pages 35-62.

2. Jim Wallis, The Call To Conversion: Recovering the Gospel for These Times (Harper San Francisco, 1992), pp. 7, 17.

CSS Publishing, Sermons on the Gospel Reading, Cycle C, by Frank G. Honeycutt