Big Idea: In Jesus the new age has come, and this new reality cannot be immersed into the old ways. Jesus the Son of Man has authority over the Torah and is Lord over the Sabbath.
Understanding the Text
The opposition to Jesus intensifies with each of the episodes in this section. The central story among the five in 2:1–3:6 tells why the conflict is occurring (2:18–22): in Jesus a new era has arrived, one in which he must challenge the old traditions. Those who cling to the old (symbolized by the issue of fasting) have been superseded, and this new kingdom reality cannot be subsumed under the old ways. This then leads to the final two episodes, which are controversies over Sabbath observance (the first two, 2:1–12, 13–17, center on forgiveness of sins and acceptance into the new community).
Interpretive Insights
2:18 John’s disciples and the disciples of the Pharisees were fasting. These two groups of disciples represent the old order, still observing traditional practices. The only required fast was on the Day of Atonement (Lev. 16:29–34 [most agree that Jesus and his disciples probably observed this but not the weekly fasting]), but there were other times of fasting connected to traumatic experiences in the life of Israel (Zech. 7:5; 8:19, both linked to the exile). The Pharisees fasted twice a week (Luke 18:12), on Monday and Thursday, and John’s disciples likely followed this practice. Fasting generally signified repentance for sin or grief over death or illness.
2:19 How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while he is with them? These persons (literally, “sons of the wedding hall”) could be the groomsmen or the guests, but Jesus likely means it more widely of all the guests attending (his followers). The question is formulated to expect a negative answer: “The guests cannot fast, can they?” Jesus’s analogy is very apt. Fasting expresses mourning and sorrow, while weddings center on intense joy. Weddings lasted seven days, with an abundance of good food and wine.1As Yahweh is the bridegroom of Israel, Jesus is the groom of the new kingdom community, the church.2
2:20 on that day they will fast. The two metaphors centering on the time when the groom is “with them” and when he “will be taken from them” clearly refer to Jesus’s time on earth and to his crucifixion, resurrection, and ascension. Jesus’s followers experience the joy of the kingdom that he has brought with him, so it is time for celebration. There may be double meaning in “taken”: taken from this world through death and taken up into glory by God. But the former is central, and Jesus certainly is referring to his coming violent death (“on that day” = his crucifixion). The later church took this literally and fasted on Wednesdays and Fridays.
2:21 a patch of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. The two parables of 2:21–22 state the same thing through separate pictures: placing something new in something old. The message is the incompatibility of the new covenant with the old covenant. The old garment has already shrunk and is inflexible. The new patch sewed on will shrink when washed, and the thread will tear both the old cloak and the new cloth. Both will be destroyed. The same is true with Jesus’s new kingdom message.
2:22 new wine into new wineskins. Joel Marcus says it well: “The necessity of preserving, undiluted by compromise with the structures of the old age, the eschatological power that has broken into the world in Jesus’s advent, is summed up by the battle cry that ends the passage: ‘New wine into new wineskins!’”3Leather wineskins were soft and flexible when new, but over time they became dry and brittle. New wine is unfermented, and as the wine expands while fermenting, it produces cracks in the dry skin, so that the wine leaks out and the wineskin is of no more use. Both are lost. The new wine of Jesus’s kingdom teaching must be encased in the new covenant reality, the new community and ways that Jesus is establishing.
2:24 what is unlawful on the Sabbath. The fourth of the Ten Commandments (Exod. 20:8–11; cf. Lev. 23:3) said that the Sabbath (sunset Friday to sunset Saturday) was to be a day of rest, with no work whatsoever done. However, the question of what constitutes work vexed the Pharisees, so they developed the oral Torah to give specific examples of what was prohibited; these included harvesting grain on the Sabbath.4Here the disciples are walking through a field plucking some wheat for a snack (this was allowed as long as one did not use a sickle). But for the Pharisees, Jesus’s disciples broke their law, since it was harvesting on the Sabbath.
2:25–26 David . . . ate the consecrated bread. This occurred in 1 Samuel 21:1–6, as David, future king and messianic forerunner, was fleeing from Saul.5He and his men ate the sacred loaves reserved for the priests (Exod. 25:30; Lev. 24:5–9). The priest freely gave him the bread, and God never judged David, so Jesus uses this as an example of the law being set aside due to the need of David, who as future king and forebear of the Messiah had the authority to demand the holy bread. If this is true, even more may an oral tradition be set aside for the Messiah himself, the Son of God.
2:27 The Sabbath was made for man. God’s rest, the Sabbath, was meant to benefit and strengthen God’s people. The ordaining of the Sabbath was never intended for the purpose of people keeping Sabbath regulations and precepts. It was a gift from God and so was to serve humankind, not to become the master over humankind. For us, it is meant to be a day of rest and worship, not a source of rules.
2:28 the Son of Man is Lord even of the Sabbath. This concludes all the miracle stories thus far. The result (“So [h?ste] the Son of Man . . .”) of Jesus’s actions is absolute proof that as the glorified “Son of Man” (see the sidebar in the unit on 2:1–12; the major theme of Dan. 7:13–14 is universal dominion), he is cosmic Lord of all, specifically here “over the Sabbath” and its regulations. He is the final interpreter of Torah (one of the emphases of the Sermon on the Mount [Matt. 5–7]) and offers a Sabbath-like rest for the soul (Matt. 11:28–30). What Christ has brought is “greater than the temple” (Matt. 12:6 [in the same story as here in Mark]), and if Christ supersedes the temple, he also has authority over the Sabbath observance. This is an apex of Mark’s Christology and shows that, for Mark, there is a divine authority that rests on Jesus.
3:2 looking for a reason to accuse Jesus. They are back in the Capernaum synagogue (indicated by “another time”), and another compelling act of Jesus’s authority is about to take place. There are three sections to this story: setting (vv. 1–2), confrontation (vv. 3–4), and miracle (vv. 5–6). Each begins with an act of Jesus and ends with a negative reaction on the part of the leaders. They obviously rejected Jesus as “Lord over the Sabbath” and so were hoping that he would discredit himself by breaking the regulations about healing (= work) on the Sabbath.
3:4 Which is lawful . . . to save life or to kill? Similar to 2:9 (cf. Deut. 30:15–19), this is a question of halakah, the rabbinic rules for daily life. Their rigid legal demands would leave the man’s “shriveled hand” unhealed rather than restoring his health. Thus it would be an act of “evil” rather than “good.” Jesus thus poses the dilemma of a system that, ironically, stands in the way of God’s good and obviates his true purposes.
But they remained silent. The Pharisees had a ready answer (“This is not life-threatening [their law allowed healing if a life was at stake], so heal the man tomorrow rather than today”), so their silence seems strange. Perhaps they just did not want to be drawn into another debate, and perhaps they realized that however they answered they would be in trouble. But Mark uses silence five times (four total in the other Gospels); here and in 1:25 and 4:39 it is a reference to Jesus’s authority and power. They had no response in light of Jesus’s God-given authority.
3:5 in anger and, deeply distressed at their stubborn hearts. Jesus’s deep emotions come to the surface, reflecting the justice and love of God that here are displayed by Jesus—God’s anger at sin yet grief at the dilemma of fallen humankind. This is, literally, “the hardness of their hearts” and will be descriptive of the disciples as well in 6:52; 8:17. Their callous and stubborn refusal to submit to God’s truths typified the leaders.
3:6 how they might kill Jesus. Clearly the religious (Pharisees) and political (Herodians—Herod’s partisans who are always opposed to Jesus in the Gospels) leaders are convinced that Jesus has become such a threat that only his death will suffice. So they enter a plot to kill him. The anti-Jesus campaign of 2:1–3:6 has reached its apex already.
Theological Insights
Two insights dominate. (1) In Jesus God’s kingdom—God’s reign over this world—has arrived in a new way, and God’s people must embrace this newness and respond properly. A new age with new principles has entered among God’s people, and they are called to emulate this new kingdom reality in their lives and worship. This is illustrated by the new Sabbath principle: rules of ritual have been replaced by its purpose from the beginning—rest and worship. (2) Jesus is Lord of all, and those who reject his authority will answer to God. All characterized by “stubborn hearts” must submit to God in Jesus or face the consequences.
Teaching the Text
1. Fasting is a spiritual discipline for the present age. It is critical to help people understand the meaning and purpose of fasting. Many in Jesus’s time connected it with mourning for sin, sorrow in time of tragedy, but also with gaining favor with God to manipulate him into doing things. In the new era inaugurated by Jesus, fasting is practiced (Acts 13:2–3; 14:23), but it is always part of worship and deep prayer. It must never constitute manipulation of God. When believers fast, they should never do so in an attempt to get God to say yes to their requests. Rather, fasting is the surrender of major needs (food usually, but also sexual relations within marriage in 1 Cor. 7:5) in order to realize that God is our primary need. In other words, its goal is to make God our absolute priority, not to get things from God. Still, fasting is a major aspect of worship and of the spiritual disciplines.
2. A new community and ritual characterize the new wine of Christ. The “new wineskin” that must encase Jesus’s new kingdom reality almost certainly refers to the newness of ritual and community that defined the church in the New Testament. Jesus at his death and resurrection entered “the greater and more perfect tabernacle” (Heb. 9:11) and opened up the heavenly temple for us, giving us a new access to God and a “new covenant” (Jer. 31:31–34 = Heb. 8:8–12). The church is the new temple of God (1 Cor. 3:16; 1 Pet. 2:4–5), and each of us, indwelt by the Spirit, is a temple, a walking holy of holies! In John’s Gospel Jesus speaks often of the new prayer power that we possess (14:13–14, 26; 15:16; 16:23, 24, 26). In Christ the church is bathed in newness.
3. The true purpose of the Sabbath laws is worship and rest. The scribes and Pharisees developed a complex set of rules for keeping the Sabbath,6and this tendency to define the seventh day by strict adherence to regulations has dogged the church ever since. The problem with a legalistic approach to God and worship is the tendency to feel that rule keeping is sufficient in our relationship to God. We too easily forget compassion and good works. We forget the basic principle of Hosea 6:6: “I desire mercy, not sacrifice.” There are only two requirements for the Sabbath: worship and rest. It is a day set apart for God and family. It is not to be just another secular day, but we are not to look down on each other regarding Sabbath observance. As Paul says in Romans 14:1–15:13, we should respect each other’s religious convictions regarding such things as holy days and food laws.
4. Jesus is the Lord of all. All of 1:21–3:6 centers on the authority of Jesus over all creation. This will become even more evident in the miracle stories in 4:54–5:43, where Jesus is presented as Lord over nature, the demonic realm, sickness, and death. Mark’s Gospel has often been characterized as having a “low Christology,” but that is because the disciples never confess Jesus as more than the Messiah. In reality, Mark implicitly affirms John’s emphasis on Jesus as God. He is the Son of God, and as the Son of Man he fulfills the universal dominion set out in Daniel 7:13–14. Worship demands the realization that Jesus is more than our friend and guide; he is our Savior and Lord.
Illustrating the Text
The new community and ritual
Object Lesson: Apply a large, unwashed, wool patch to an old pair of pants (wool will shrink significantly when washed). Wash the pants in hot water and run them through the dryer. The patch may not tear, but it certainly will distort the look of the pants and render the pants, and the patch, unusable.
The problem of legalism
Business: In order to warn consumers of potential dangers, many products may include warning labels. But efforts to avoid potential liability can sometimes result in ridiculous-sounding warnings. Here are a few examples found on actual products or in the related manual:
• Ammoniated window cleaner: Do not spray in eyes.
• Electric woodworking drill: This product not intended for use as a dental drill.
• Hair coloring: Do not use as an ice cream topping.
• Sleeping pills: May cause drowsiness.
• Air conditioner: Avoid dropping air conditioners out of windows.
Though many are humorous, product warning labels reflect the impulse of caution in the face of potential danger. In an effort to ensure that behavior pleased God and avoid potential sanction for wrongdoing, the religious leaders developed an oral tradition of sometimes overly detailed religious laws to ensure that people obeyed God’s commands.
Observing the Sabbath
Human Experience: The point of the Sabbath is to give us time to rest and to focus our hearts on God. Research shows that we desperately need rest. Consider the following data reported by Key Organization Systems:7
• Nearly one-third of American working adults get less than six hours of sleep per night.
• Sleep deprivation is now costing U.S. companies $63.2 billion a year in lost productivity.
• One-third of employees maintain chronic stress.
The command for keeping the Sabbath is not meant to be a burden but rather is to be viewed as a great gift. When we understand the purpose of the Sabbath, we make it a priority for physical, emotional, and spiritual rest, a rest desperately needed by many in our culture.
The place of fasting in the Christian life
Testimony: Fasting is a biblical and historical Christian discipline that is largely ignored by Christians today. Ask someone in your church who has had a positive experience with fasting (not as an attempt to manipulate God but as an opportunity to surrender more fully to him) to share about their experience. Challenge your listeners to make a commitment to fast regularly; this could include fasting from pleasures suchas television, computers, and cell phones.