2 Corinthians 4:1-18 · Treasures in Jars of Clay
Bothered and Bewildered
2 Corinthians 4:5-12
Sermon
by Gibson “Nibs” Stroupe
Loading...

Whatever one wants to say about the apostle Paul, we must at least say this: He took Christianity out of the rural roads and countryside and spread it into the urban experiences in places like Rome, Ephesus, Antioch, and Corinth. We have two of his letters to the church at Corinth, and it was a church that bothered and bewildered him. The city of Corinth had a rough reputation. Prior to its fall to Rome 140 years before the birth of Jesus, its nature as an urban seaport had given rise to a temple to Aphrodite, where over 1,000 prostitutes hooked up the pilgrims with the goddess of love. After Rome took it over, the city was cleaned up a bit, but its reputation remained.

Chapter 18 of Acts tells us that Paul came to Corinth after his sojourn in Athens. We are also told in Acts 18 that it is in Corinth that Paul solidifies in his mind the idea that God is calling him to preach the gospel to the Gentiles. As usual, trouble follows Paul to Corinth - his opponents bring charges against him before proconsul Gallio. The charges are dismissed and Paul heads back to Ephesus. The church at Corinth was a great trial for Paul. Scholars believe that he wrote at least four letters to the Corinthians, and some believe that Second Corinthians is a combination of at least two of those letters.

Paul's second letter to the Corinthians is perhaps the most personal letter of his that we have. He is clearly bothered and bewildered by the Corinthians, and in 2 Corinthians, we see him struggling in ways that no other letter reveals. He has a painful second visit with them, as we see in chapter 2. It is not clear where the "letter of tears" is (2:4), but it is clear that Paul is hurting in his relationship with the Corinthians and that he wants to change the conversation and the relationship. He feels foolish and conflicted in this letter: "I have been a fool!" (12:11). Yet, he wants the Corinthians to know of his love for them, of Christ's love for them, and of the necessity of their receiving and believing and living the gracious love of Jesus Christ.

In today's lectionary passage, Paul emphasizes to the Corinthians that the purpose of his visits with them is not about him. The purpose is rather about the God he knows in Jesus Christ: "For we do not proclaim ourselves; we proclaim Jesus Christ as Lord." Paul emphasizes as strongly as possible in this passage - and indeed in this entire letter - that the theme of his engagement with the Corinthians is not Paul and his personality but the power of the gospel of Jesus Christ. This distinction between himself and the proclamation of the gospel helps to focus on what is important, and it is a reminder to believers and preachers in every age of our own limits. We need one another for edification, for comfort, and for caring. When we begin to see the gospel as confined to our point of view, we are proclaiming ourselves, not Christ.

These words from Paul are both astonishing words of grace - God's work is not confined to us or totally dependent on us - and careful words of caution to us - don't try to capture God. He reinforces this with his famous phrase in verse 7: "We have this treasure in earthen vessels." It is a continuation of a powerful theme in his letters to Corinth: "God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise" (1 Corinthians 1:27). There is again a clear distinction between the messenger and the message, between the vessel and its contents. He uses the metaphor of an ordinary clay jar carrying something of great value, and he perhaps draws on the Leviticus image of ordinary containers that the priests use to carry certain offerings.

There is an emphasis on the distinction between the ordinary nature of the vessel and the extraordinary nature of the treasure that it carries. At the same time, there is also the hint of the enhanced dignity of the vessel because of the great privilege of being the baggage handler of such a treasure. God is bold to entrust this valuable and important message to ordinary folks like the Corinthians and like us. When Paul speaks here of earthen vessels, he is asking us to remember who we are: children of God, adopted and called by God to be bearers and messengers of this great treasure. He asks the Corinthians to listen, to have hope, and to keep working in their "ordinary" journeys, for they are now rooted in the reign of God through Jesus Christ. Like the Corinthians, we are asked to remember our "ordinary" status, that we are not the treasure. Yet, we are also asked to be defined not by our ordinary status but by the precious cargo that we have been asked to carry and to share: the grace of Jesus Christ.

Just as he shares, Paul asks us to share that treasure - weak and ordinary as we sometimes are, tired as we sometimes are, hopeless as we sometimes are. Bothered and bewildered as we sometimes are, Paul asks us to keep heart in a world filled with brokenness and chaos. He asks us to speak up for justice and mercy when the world tells us to settle for injustice and harshness. He asks us to remember our definition as children of God when the world tells us that we belong to this category or to that category. He asks us to remember the treasure that we have been given to share.

From this high calling as treasure-bearers, Paul then speaks of the cost of this journey with four phrases in verses 8 and 9: "afflicted in every way, but not crushed; perplexed but not driven to despair; persecuted but not forsaken; struck down but not destroyed." Here he begins a list of struggles and hardships that will flow throughout this letter. It is a reminder that the description of the Christian life is not exactly a chapter titled "How to Succeed with Christ." As Paul stresses throughout this letter, he is no great success in the eyes of the world. Though he is a Roman citizen, he is not a person who ate and fraternized with the powerful - no presidential dinners at the White House for him. More often than not in his journey as a follower of Jesus Christ, he was in jail as a political prisoner.

Those of us who emphasize that life in Christ will bring us worldly success, recognition, and prosperity need to reread this second letter to the Corinthians. If we see Christians praised often at the seats of power and culture, we should be wary. That doesn't mean that respectability is a bad thing or that those on the margins should be commended. However, it does mean that we should be cautious about lifting up worldly success as a sign of God's blessing and reward. Paul and the rest of the biblical witness seem to suggest otherwise.

Why? Why is this skepticism about worldly success necessary? Paul answers in the next verse: "always carrying the death of Jesus in the body." As Christians, we are always carrying the death of Jesus in our bodies and in our histories. Jesus was not a great conflict manager. He chose to go to the margins of society and seemed to invite conflict and troubles. It ultimately cost him his life. He was willing to go into the valley of the shadow of death in order to engage others, to challenge others, to ask others to consider the nature of our lives, to help others know the presence of God. We are asked to go on that same journey, to carry the death of Jesus in our bodies. One of the elders at the church my wife and I are privileged to serve is an attorney who once held a job in state government. His sole duty was to go to day care centers and nursing homes to investigate and adjudicate complaints about abuse in those institutions. As he put it: "No one is ever glad to see me coming to their facility." And I added: "But I'm glad that you do it - it is vital to all of us." His willingness to carry the death of Jesus in his body helped to ensure compassion and care for our most vulnerable citizens.

In the closing verses of this lectionary passage, Paul moves us into the concrete nature of the Christian life. It is not primarily a belief about what happens to us when we die. It is rather what one of my friends calls "foot theology." Many of us talk the talk, but it is much more difficult to walk the walk, because such walking will surely test our beliefs and take us into places where we will be bothered and bewildered, where we will experience affliction, confusion, and even persecution and battering. Paul understands the strange relationship between life and death, between health and suffering. When he emphasizes that we carry the death of Jesus, he is speaking about the cost of discipleship and the great love demonstrated in the cross. To carry the death of Jesus is to demonstrate God's love and caring in the life of the world. To carry the death of Jesus signifies our willingness to proclaim that same caring in our lives. To carry the death of Jesus means to engage others so that we share in their suffering and their wounds, and they share in ours. To carry the death of Jesus means that the life of Jesus is also made manifest. In engaging with one another as sisters and brothers, we reveal the life and the death of Jesus. One African translation of verse 12 reads: "We have agreed to struggle with death so that you might find life."1

I grew up in the former Presbyterian church in the United States, commonly known as "the Southern Presbyterian Church." We split off from the national Presbyterian church in 1861 at the beginning of the Civil War. We were the last major Christian denomination in the country to reunite after the Civil War - it took us 122 years to get back together in 1983. One of the former pastors at Oakhurst Presbyterian, where my wife and I are pastors, was an African American named Dr. Lawrence Bottoms. He was the only African American ever elected to be moderator of the former Southern church, and when he was called to be pastor of Oakhurst in 1972, it was one of the rare occasions when an African American was pastor of a mostly white church. Sadly, it continues to be a rare occasion even today, over 35 years later.

At the constituting convention of Greater Atlanta Presbytery following the reunion, a tribute to Dr. Bottoms was given by Dr. Clinton Marsh, another African American who was former moderator of the national Presbyterian church, the United Presbyterian Church. I was privileged to be in that meeting as Dr. Marsh talked about Lawrence Bottoms' dignity and leadership in the old Southern church, enduring segregation and threats and indifference. He told stories about Dr. Bottoms being on the national staff of the Southern church and of his having to eat in the kitchen at the PCUS Montreat Conference Center in North Carolina because of the laws of the state and because the customs of the church required it. As I listened to the tribute and to the stories, I thought of these verses in 2 Corinthians. In the midst of legalized racism, in the midst of the racism in the church, Dr. Bottoms would not let them define him or the gospel. The world bothered him and bewildered him, but he would not lose his focus. He would not let the world tell him that he was inferior - he knew that he was claimed by God in the blood of Jesus. He did not believe that all white people were evil, even though they sought to crush him. He believed that white people, too, were children of God, also redeemed by the blood of Jesus. Even though the world around him told him that race was the final dividing wall, he knew better. He knew that the dividing walls had been broken down in Jesus Christ, and he proclaimed that gospel. He was willing to do foot theology, always carrying the death of Jesus in his being and in his body. He was living testimony to Paul's words in this lectionary text.

He knew about the treasure in earthen vessels. He knew racism and discrimination, not only in the world but in the church itself. Yet, he refused to let it define who he was, or how he saw the world. He held out against the affliction and persecution because he knew the grace and power and mercy and peace of Jesus Christ. Neither was his dignity stripped from him, nor was his heart filled with hate.

Paul asked the Corinthians to hear about this possibility and to make it their own. We, too, are asked to step in to this journey, to carry the death of Jesus in our histories and in our witness. In a world filled with idols and divisions and separations, in a world where we are often bothered and bewildered, we are asked to step into this legacy, to join in the proclamation of the gospel of Jesus Christ, to proclaim the treasure that we have been given, the treasure that is ours to share: Jesus Christ is Lord. Amen.


1. Roger Omanson and John Ellington, Paul's Second Letter to the Corinthians (New York: United Bible Societies, 1993), p. 82.

CSS Publishing Company, Inc., Sermons for Sundays after Pentecost (First Third): Eyes on The Prize, by Gibson “Nibs” Stroupe