Matthew 6:1-4 · Giving to the Needy
Beware: Hypocrites on Premises
Matthew 6:1-6, 16-21
Sermon
by David T. Ball
Loading...

Whenever I happen to be in a conversation with someone about why they don't go to church, it seems like the reason that they almost always give is that they can't stand all the hypocrites. I don't take this personally -- they aren't saying that all churchgoers are hypocrites -- just that there are usually too many hypocrites for their liking.

I guess their reaction is understandable. Who would want to go to a church filled with people who don't practice what they preach? That would, at the very least, be disconcerting. Maybe they've been frustrated by the discrepancy between friendly relations on Sunday mornings and the kinds of tensions and outbursts that can happen at church board meetings. Or maybe they simply think there isn't enough of a match between how people behave in church and how they behave during the rest of the week in their daily lives.

When I began to hear these comments, my first instinct was to come to the defense of the church. "Hey, it's not really like that, at least not where I worship!" But as time passed, and I heard the complaint again and again, my attitude began to change. I began to think that even if the complaint is true, maybe we shouldn't be so surprised if not everyone's a saint around here! After all, isn't the whole point that we all fall short of the glory of God, yet we gather to seek forgiveness for those shortcomings and inspiration to push us on toward greater faithfulness? In other words, of course the church is full of hypocrites -- none of us fully practice what we preach. But wouldn't you rather be in a place where people acknowledge that than in a place where self-righteousness goes on unchallenged, unprocessed?

Maybe it's just that the people who don't go to church because they've had it with all the hypocrites have been influenced by today's scripture passage from the Gospel of Matthew. As well they should -- this passage is to be found right about in the middle of Jesus' Sermon on the Mount.

The passage presents a very clear, unmistakable message against hypocrisy. To paraphrase Jesus' words, he says that hypocrites go to church to "see and be seen," and that they draw attention to themselves when they pray. Instead, Jesus says, we should pray in secret, where only God can see us. Hypocrites slather their foreheads with oil so that everyone will know that they are fasting. Instead, Jesus says, when we fast we should put the oil on and then wash it right off, so that only God will be able to tell that we are fasting. Hypocrites give to the needy to get their picture in the paper. Instead, Jesus says, we should give without our right hand even telling our left hand what we are doing.

I'm struck by Jesus' use of the phrase about the right hand not telling the left hand what it's doing. As familiar as this phrase is to me, I'm actually more familiar with the way that this idea about right hands and left hands gets used in everyday conversations. "Gee, that place is so disorganized, their right hand doesn't even know what their left hand is doing!" An expression that is intended to lead to shared negative conclusions about how incompetent the target of this remark is. It's not a compliment. "So-and-so told me one thing, just yesterday, but today someone else tells me just the opposite! Clearly, the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing around here!" At which point we stomp away.

Funny that for Jesus that's how things are supposed to be, at least when it comes to making donations to the needy: "But when you give alms, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your alms may be done in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you." We're not supposed to let our left hands know what our right hands are doing, at least when it comes to this. Otherwise, I'm sure, when it comes to running a business, or a school, or a church, or whatever else, the left hand should know what the right hand is doing! Of all the things that Jesus asks of us, surely he wouldn't expect us to put up with incompetent management! That really would be too much to ask, wouldn't it?

In the middle of all of the fun we're having with this, there is a very important point not to be missed. What Jesus is after is not just an increase in the doing of good things, but an increase in the good things that are done for the right reasons. Praying not in a vain attempt to get others to think of us as faithful, but prayer for the sake of seeking to connect with God. Charity not for the accolades, but rather for the sake of helping those in need. Fasting not to show off, but rather for the sake of sharpening our spiritual sensitivities.

It took philosophy 1,800 years to catch up to what Jesus is after, which is nothing less than a revolution in thinking about human behavior. It was not until the moral theory of the great German philosopher Immanuel Kant that this kind of clarity about the importance not just of doing the right things but also of doing them for the right reasons emerged in Western philosophy.

But we also know about the catastrophes that can result from even the best of intentions. We know all too many cases of "good intentions gone awry." Think, for example, of British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, who sought peace through appeasement of Hitler's desire for territorial expansion in the years leading up to World War II. A good intention -- to avoid all-out world war. But gone awry -- all-out war came anyway, and only after giving Hitler more time to perpetrate his atrocities without the need to give heed to the allied armies.

This revolution in thinking about human behavior, emphasized so strongly by Jesus in the Sermon on the Mount, embraced centuries later by Western philosophy, this focus on the importance of good intentions, must be kept in balance -- good intentions alone are not enough.

This Ash Wednesday, we embark on the journey that is Lent, toward the inner journey within ourselves, which we can only reach by disciplined reflection. This is a time for a fuller appreciation of the inner, of our intentions, of what it is that motivates us to follow Jesus Christ on the Christian journey.

The common complaint about hypocrites in the church directs our attention to the challenge of making our Christian journey a part of our daily way of being. This challenge is an especially appropriate one for us to work on during Lent, when we seek to make changes in our daily living to sharpen our spiritual awareness. I can't think of any better idea than for all of us to carve out some time every day during Lent to spend in prayerful reading and reflection. You might use the Upper Room's daily devotional guide -- it's tried and true. You might want to try the spiritual discipline of lectio divina, a specific approach to reading the Bible that I can tell you more about. The musicians among us might like to use the book, Forty Days with the Messiah: Day-by-Day Reflections on the Words of Handel's Oratorio.1

What will we discover as we proceed on our Lenten inner journey? Treasures such as a profound appreciation for the very gift of life, and a deeper sense of God's tender, yet powerful love for each one of us, but probably not our own personal perfection. My own best moments of spiritual openness to God don't last long, which usually reveals how reluctant I am to place God rather than my own selfish interests at the center of my life.

The great Indian spiritual and political leader, Mahatma Gandhi, was well aware of this. He observed, "The only devils in this world are those running around in our own hearts, and that is where all our battles should be fought." Sobering, but not discouraging. At least we have the proper focus.

In view of this, doesn't it seem appropriate to give the hypocrites in the church the benefit of the doubt? None of us are saints, and it just may be that what looks like hypocrisy on the outside may actually be some Christian reconstruction on the inside. You never know.

We don't want people to get disillusioned about church life in the process. To keep people from getting disillusioned about all the hypocrites in the church and breaking away, maybe we'd better proclaim at every opportunity, "Beware: hypocrites on premises." Because Jesus is here, too.
____________

1. The Upper Room's daily devotional guide can be found at ; Thelma Hall, Too Deep For Words: Rediscovering Lectio-Divina (Mahwah, New Jersey: Paulist Press, 1988) [lectio divina is an ancient practice involving slow, contemplative praying of the scriptures]; David Winter, Forty Days with the Messiah: Day-by-Day Reflections on the Words of Handel's Oratorio (Nashville: Abingdon, 1997).

CSS Publishing Company, Inc., Sermons on the Gospel Readings: Sermons for Sundays in Lent, Momentous Moment, by David T. Ball