Matthew 6:1-4 · Giving to the Needy
The Piety That Isn't
Matthew 6:1-6, 16-21
Sermon
by Carl Jech
Loading...

Beware of practicing your piety before men in order to be seen ... (Matthew 6:1a)

The well-known San Francisco newspaper columnist, Herb Caen, recently made a provocative observation when he wrote: "The miracle of Christmas is that it survives those who believe in it too loudly." The Christmas/Epiphany season is now over, and it might be good for us to ponder the significance of Mr. Caen's observation.

Lent is traditionally a time for self-examination. The most common form of such self-examination focuses on our failure to live up to "the high calling of God in Christ Jesus." We assume that we know what this calling is all about and that our only problem is failing to follow through on the obvious implications of our faith.

I think Herb Caen's comment should move us to undertake in this series of sermons an unusual, perhaps, but nonetheless valid form of lenten self-examination. Taking a warning cue from Matthew's line "Beware of practicing your piety," we are going to consider the possible errors and sins we commit precisely as the result of misguided efforts to live out our piety. To put it another way, we are going to examine some of our fundamental assumptions about the nature of the Christian Good News, the Gospel. Maybe the Gospel is less obvious than we tend to think it is.

We are going to ask whether some forms of "Christian commitment" might actually be a denial of the Gospel and a misrepresentation of what Christian evangelism is really supposed to be. Some would even go so far as to say that the word "evangelical" has been spoiled by those whose style of being Christian promotes the wrong kind of narrowness. They would say that the Christian faith is embarrassed when God is identified with a particular candidate or party, embarrassed by the stark polarization between "liberal" and "conservative" churches over the issues of (1) church doctrine and practice, (2) abortion, (3) church and state issues, (4) interpretation of the Bible, (5) life-styles, and (6) views on morality. In this video age of images, where the outward image is so strong that Michael J. Fox, Tina Turner and Michael Jackson don't even have to say the name Pepsi to sell the product in a commercial, must not we too pay attention to the Gospel's image?

Can we ignore these issues and simply practice our piety, simply focus on that which is spiritually uplifting and let the rest slide? Not if we heed the words of Matthew's Gospel! Practicing true piety, true spirituality, is a tricky, challenging thing, and Lent is not a time to look for an easy way out.

It could well be that polarizing or otherwise faulty expressions of our Christian piety have actually worked to drive people away from Christianity. It is likely that much of the popularity of psychics, astrology, certain "cult" phenomena, trance channeling and the like, is the result of mistakes that we Christians have made in the attempt to express our faith. To use a big word, some of our efforts to attract people may be sadly counterproductive. Was Shirley MacLaine pushed out on a limb because the Christianity she had known was too dogmatic, too arrogant, too intellectualized or formal - not paying enough attention to her hunger for religious experience? By virtually ignoring the other world religions do Christians unintentionally exaggerate the appeal of those religions?

This day, Ash Wednesday, is a day on which some mark their foreheads with ashes - symbolizing repentance, symbolizing the Cross, symbolizing our mortality (often with the words: "Remember that you are dust and to dust you shall return"). No doubt some people do not follow this custom because they have noticed that it seems to conflict with Matthew's words in the text for this day, his words about not making a show of your piety in public. It could be argued that since this form of piety emphasizes humility, it can't possibly be interpreted as "showing off." But in this sermon, Jesus is referring precisely to those who disfigure their faces as a way of showing how humble they are. Now most of us don't stand on street corners and many of us do not mark our foreheads with ashes, but in a variety of subtle ways we may well be guilty of "practicing our piety before men," contrary to the Spirit of Jesus.

We Christians have been given a difficult challenge. We have been challenged to witness to our faith without being "triumphalistic," without being boastful about our beliefs, our convictions, our morality. It's a tough challenge and it is not going to be easy to talk about it. But this is Lent. Let us really examine ourselves.

"Amazing Grace ... that saved a wretch like me." (John Newton) The point is not that we aren't to practice any piety at all. The point is that we need to be careful how we go about being pious. To say, for example that "God helps those who help themselves" may express an important truth about self-reliance; but if the phrase is quoted as an excuse for not helping those in need, then it is not a good thought. Likewise, the insight suggested by the question "Whoever said life is fair?" can help us face the hard realities of life; but if the same question is used as an excuse for not getting involved in the struggle to create social justice in the world, then the truth is being mishandled. The mystic, Bernard of Clairvaux, said that "only one who is poor should praise poverty." Economic poverty may help us keep our priorities straight - may make us more aware of the real treasures of life - but for an affluent person to praise poverty could be, again, to make an excuse for not being concerned about the plight of the poor.

Those who have experienced the "Amazing Grace" of God can reflect on how, without that grace, they felt like lost wretches: but they should not go around labeling other people as lost and wretched. It is one thing to say that I was lost or spiritually blind, but it is quite another thing, quite inappropriate, for me to call others lost, blind or wretched. To do so would be not evangelistic, but arrogant. Watching the "Church Lady" on Saturday Night Live reminds, us that the line between true evangelism and holier-than-thou self-righteousness is extremely thin, but oh so important. It may be easier to confess other people's sins, but we can only confess our own. (It's easier, but wrong, to confess the sins to which we are not tempted.) Just as a joke can be funny or offensive depending on the spirit in which it is told and taken, so an expression of our piety (like confession) can be true and lovely, or false and ugly, depending on the spirit in which it is conveyed. Ironically, to be preoccupied with other people's sins is itself the basic sin of self-righteous self-centeredness!

Christians are given the difficult challenge of expressing a piety that isn't pious in a self-righteous, self-important way! As we move through this lenten season we will be using the image of "channeling grace" to describe what a truly "evangelical mentality" is all about. As channels of God's grace we will learn how to have convictions without being bigoted or closed-minded, how to be angry at injustice without being self-righteous, how to share faith without "practicing our piety before men." This lenten season of penitence calls us not to wallow in sin-consciousness but to make a commitment to renewal and reform. The Greek word for repentance means "to change one's mind." Let us do some truly radical mind-changing. Let us rethink what it means to be evangelical!

We began by quoting Herb Caen's comment about "those who believe in Christmas too loudly." The great preacher Harry Emerson Fosdick similarly gave us a witty nudge toward the piety that isn't, when he said that vital faith is a treasure like good music ... "It needs no defense, only rendition. A wrangling controversy in support of religion," said Fosdick, "is as if the members of the orchestra should beat folks over the head with their violins to prove that the music is beautiful."

The amazing truth is that by going easy on the piety, by not beating folks over the head with the Bible, we become much more effective channels of God's grace. The piety that isn't pious is the true piety! Let us celebrate and, in the weeks to come, contemplate this amazing paradox of God's grace!

C.S.S. Publishing Company, Channeling Grace, by Carl Jech