Big Idea: Ethics and eschatology go hand in hand. Because the age to come has dawned, Christians participate in the new covenant; but because the present age continues, Christians must love others and not cater to the flesh. Indeed, the dawning of the age to come in Christ empowers believers to love others in the present age. The Old Testament law could not accomplish this.
Understanding the Text
Romans 13:8–14 resumes Paul’s discussion about Christian love in 12:9–21. At the same time, 13:8–14 anticipates Paul’s challenge to the Roman Christians to love one another in 14:1–15:13.
Romans 13:8–14 divides into two sections: the ethic of love (vv. 8–10) and the dawning of the eschaton (vv. 11–14). The two paragraphs are closely related: love is the power of the age to come, the stipulation of the new covenant; only it, not the law, can overcome the flesh of this present evil age.
I outline these two sections in this way:
1. The ethic of love (13:8–10)
a. The fulfillment of the law and the presence of the new covenant (13:8, 10)
b. Love is the fulfillment of the law in the way it treats one’s neighbor (13:8–10)
2. The dawning of the age to come (13:11–14)
a. The indicative of the age to come (13:11–12a)
b. The imperative needed for the present evil age (13:12b–14)
Historical and Cultural Background
Several traditions inform Paul’s ethic and eschatology in 13:8–14.
1. Jesus’ reduction of the law to loving God and loving one’s neighbor informs Paul’s command to love others (see Lev. 19:18; Mark 12:29–31; Matt. 22:37–39; Luke 10:27–28).
2. Paul’s language about taking off and putting on clothing is thought by many to allude to early Christian baptism.[1]
3. Romans 13:11–14 is thoroughly immersed in Jewish apocalypticism. Evald Lövestam points to a number of Jewish eschatological texts that undergird the passage.[2] I would add to Lövestam’s discussion that the texts he lists are informed by an apocalyptic reading of the Deuteronomic tradition, especially the pattern of sin, exile, and restoration that composes the story of Israel (see “The Theme of Romans” in the introduction). Thus, for example, Amos 5:18, 20 reverses the meaning of the day of the Lord for Israel, ascribing to it darkness and exile (Deuteronomic curses) because of their sin, not light and deliverance. One day, however, Israel will repent and obey the Lord, resulting in restoration and salvation (Deuteronomic blessings [Amos 9:13–15]). Similarly, Isaiah 60:19–20 envisions the lifting of God’s judgment upon Israel (Deuteronomic curses) and the subsequent restoration to the land, along with newfound obedience to God. It does so by employing the imagery of light and glory (Deuteronomic blessings [see Isa. 60:21–22]).3
I suggest that the preceding background sheds significant light on the Jewish underpinning of Romans 13:8–14: it is consonant with the hope that obedience to the Torah in this age (13:8–10) will bring about the age to come and the Deuteronomic blessings (13:11–14). Paul, however, reverses that tradition: only those whose faith is in Christ, not the law, and who thereby live a life of love (13:8–10) are participants in the Deuteronomic blessings of the age to come. This is what it means to put on Christ (13:14a). In doing so, Christians provide no opportunity for the flesh (13:14b). It is possible that because of the polemical nature of 13:8–13 (Paul extricates his gospel from the charge of libertinism), and because elsewhere in Romans Paul states that the law is no match for the flesh since it actually stirs up sin (3:20; 4:15; 7:7–11; 8:3), we are to understand Paul as saying in 13:14b that following the Torah is not the way to overcome the sinful nature (against the Judaizers). In reality, attempts to follow the Torah bring about disobedience and the Deuteronomic curses. If so, Paul’s reversal motif in 13:8–14 becomes clear: faith in Christ (who already obeyed and thereby terminated the Torah) brings the Deuteronomic blessings; but efforts to pursue the law in one’s own power do not lift the Deuteronomic curses.
Interpretive Insights
13:8–10 whoever loves others has fulfilled the law . . . love is the fulfillment of the law. Verses 8–10 present the ethic of love. The key concept in this paragraph, that love is the fulfillment of the law, forms an inclusio (13:8, 10). Douglas Moo rightly points out that “fulfill” means for Paul the eschatological completion of the law, which was accomplished in Christ (as I argued above).[4] Christians, therefore, because they are in Christ and disseminate his love, need not worry about any other commandment. Romans 13:10b forms an inclusio with 13:8b and should be read in the same light: the Christian who loves, and who therefore does what the law requires (8:9–10a), has brought the Torah to its culmination. In other words, the new covenant has arrived, and its ethic is love.
But how does this relate to those commandments that Paul mentions in 13:9? There are three views. First, there is the traditional, or Lutheran, view stated above with reference to Moo. The law is finished in Christ. The Christian therefore is not obligated to any part of the law, certainly not the civil and ceremonial aspects, and not even the moral aspect—the Ten Commandments. Rather, the love of Christ flowing through the believer fulfills all that the law ever intended (though Moo perhaps allows for the continuing role of the law in the Christian life in light of human sinfulness). Second, there is the Calvinist view, which says that the Ten Commandments should function as a gauge of the Christian’s behavior. This is often called the “third use” of the law.[5] Third, James Dunn approaches 13:8–10 from the New Perspective on Paul. The curse of the law has been lifted in Christ so that now believers can obey the law in the power of the Spirit and guided by love.[6] The last two views seem to miss the eschatological significance of Paul’s statements in 13:8, 10 (love fulfills the law): Christ is the end of the law.
Verses 9–10 state Leviticus 19:18 positively, “love your neighbor as yourself,” and negatively, “love does no harm to its neighbor.” The latter reminds one of the negative Golden Rule in Judaism (see Tob. 4:15; Sir. 10:6; Let. Aris. 168, 207).
13:11–14 The hour has already come . . . clothe yourselves with the Lord Jesus Christ. These verses attest to the overlapping of the two ages in Paul’s theology. Verses 11–12a emphasize the indicative aspect of salvation: by virtue of the Christ event, the age to come has drawn near and, with it, the salvation of believers. Three temporal clues in 13:11 confirm this to be the case: (1) the word “time” (kairos) is one of Paul’s choice terms for referring to the dawning of the eschaton (cf. Rom. 3:26; 5:6; 1 Cor. 7:29); (2) the words “already the hour” (h?ra ?d?) convey a definite eschatological overtone, drawing their inspiration from Daniel’s idea that God has appointed a time for fulfilling his promise of the arrival of his kingdom (Dan. 8:17, 19; cf. 1 John 2:18; Rev. 3:3, 10); (3) the words “our salvation is nearer now than when we first believed” are full of eschatological language. “Now” (nyn) refers to the presence of the age to come (cf. Rom 3:21; 5:9; 2 Cor. 6:2), and “salvation” (s?t?ria) refers to the Christian’s redemptive wholeness and spiritual deliverance, a process begun by faith and soon to be culminated at the parousia. This salvation has drawn “nearer” (engyteron), a term recalling Jesus’ proclamation of the arrival of the kingdom of God, the age to come (Mark 1:15; 13:28–29; cf. James 5:8; 1 Pet. 4:7).
These temporal terms, then, indicate that salvation and the end time have already dawned for the believer. However, the salvific message of 13:11–12a occurs in the context of this present age; hence Paul’s emphasis in 13:12b–14 on the necessity for Christians to live holy lives. It is clear that, for the apostle, eschatology forms the basis for Christian ethics. Accordingly, two general commands are issued: Christians are to put off the deeds of darkness and put on the weapons of light. This respective shedding of unrighteousness and donning of righteousness reflect the ongoing struggle that believers experience because they live in between the two epochs. The metaphor of the conflict between darkness and light brings to mind the eschatological battle between the unrighteous and the righteous envisioned in the Qumran literature (1QM 1.1, 8–14; 13.5–16; see also 1QS 1.9–10; 3.24–25; 4.7–13), as well as 1 Thessalonians 5:1–9.7
Moreover, 13:11–14 should not be isolated from the earlier discussion of 13:8–10, for the former refers back to the love command in the latter: do this (fulfill the law by love), knowing that the eschaton has dawned (13:11–14). That connection is important because it provides the overarching logic of 13:8–14, which is that Paul is answering the polemics of his Judaizing opponents. Freedom from the law does not lead to licentious living; rather, Christian love alone provides victory over the flesh (11:14). This understanding accentuates the fact that, as far as the Christian is concerned, the law is terminated and now is replaced by love. The Torah, therefore, does not govern the Christian experience; rather, it is the new-covenant stipulation of love that does so.
Theological Insights
Several truths based on Romans 13:8–14 impact the Christian. First, the only debt that the believer owes is to love God and others. Paul’s command in 13:8–10 cannot be understood to prohibit, in our time, the (prudent) use of credit cards, mortgage, and so forth. Rather, it makes the point that loving others is an ongoing obligation for believers. Second, the Christian is under love, not law. But, as the Sermon on the Mount shows, loving others is more demanding and radical than the Torah itself. Only the power of the Holy Spirit can accomplish such behavior. Third, the power to love is available to the Christian because the age to come, the new covenant, and the kingdom of God (all similar concepts) have dawned. Thus, Christians love others (13:8–10) and God by pleasing him with holy lives (13:11–14).
Teaching the Text
I would use the title of this unit, “Ethics and Eschatology,” and the accompanying outline to teach or preach Romans 13:8–14. The basic point to be made is that eschatology—the dawning of the age to come—gives Christians the power to love God and others and thus the strength not to embrace an escapist mentality relative to this age. Regarding ethics, I noted above that 13:8–10 indicates that living a life of love for God and others fulfills the Old Testament law and even exceeds its requirements. So there is no room for licentiousness in the Christian life or for a cavalier attitude toward sin. And the power to live such a supernatural life of love has dawned in the person of Christ, who by his Spirit indwells his people (13:11–14). Yet we might also look again at Paul’s comments about ethics and eschatology from a slightly different perspective. Ethics obviously focuses on the here and now, while eschatology finds its ultimate fulfillment at the return of Christ. Assuming that to be the case, we can also detect that 13:8–14 offers a healthy balance toward life and eternity in the following ways.
If we as Christians focus only on ethics—the here and now—by trying to bring utopia to earth only through voting, social justice, transforming the structures of society with the gospel, and so forth, then probably we are in for a big disappointment. Theologians have tried to do that for centuries, from those who first legalized Christianity, to the Crusaders of the Middle Ages, to the theonomists of the twentieth century, to liberation theologians past and present. And all of them without exception have failed in their laudable attempts to usher in the kingdom of God through human effort. What is needed here is the humble recognition that only God himself will bring his kingdom to this planet.
But, on the other hand, if the church loses sight of its divine calling to be the salt and light of the earth by becoming obsessed with the date of the second coming or other eschatological phenomena, it will become so heavenly minded that it will be no earthly good. Therefore, Paul offers precisely the right balance to the church in 13:8–14: it should concentrate on preaching the gospel and loving others (ethics), all the while knowing that the final resolution awaits the return of Jesus Christ (eschatology).
Illustrating the Text
Our continuing debt is to love others.
Literature: Les Misérables, by Victor Hugo. In a well-known scene from this novel (1862), which has been made into a Broadway play and adapted for film, the escaped convict Jean Valjean is taken in by Bishop Myriel and given dignity and shelter. Nevertheless, Valjean steals the bishop’s silverware and escapes. When he is captured, the bishop protects Valjean, saying he had given the silverware to him and in fact wondered why Valjean had left the candlesticks. This act of love profoundly changes Valjean’s life forever, and he becomes a great force of love and generosity for the rest of his life.
Understanding eschatology, we must stop sinning and behave decently.
History: In his masterful book on New Testament eschatology, Christ and Time, Oscar Cullmann compared the first and second comings of Christ to D-Day and V-E Day of World War II. Just as D-Day marked the beginning of the end for the Axis armies, so too the death and resurrection of Jesus signaled the victorious invasion of the age by the kingdom of God. Even after D-Day, however, there was another year of war and death before the final victory. So too, even after the triumph of Jesus’ resurrection, spiritual warfare will continue to be the lot of God’s people until the parousia. The outcome of the battle, however, is not in doubt; the Christian is on the victor’s side.
Church Fathers: Augustine, in his Confessions (AD 397–98), reveals how he experienced his conversion to Christ by meditating on Romans 13:13–14 (Conf. 8.12.29). The challenge of Paul to put on the Lord Jesus Christ and make no provision for the flesh (the sinful nature) empowered Augustine to break with his past immorality and commit his life to Christ and his kingdom.