Romans 6:1-14 · Dead to Sin, Alive in Christ
Fido’s Dilemma
Romans 6:1-11
Sermon
by Steven E. Albertin
Loading...

Fido is in the dirt gnawing on a bone. It is dry, brittle, depleted of marrow and moisture. It is dead and useless except for stimulating the gums of Fido and giving his jaws some exercise. You approach Fido with your hands behind your back. Fido eyes you and is suspicious. You speak kindly to your canine friend. He wags his tail. He smiles his doggy smile keeping his paw firmly planted on the bone. Fido continues to sniff and chew on his bone. You slowly bring a hand out from behind your back revealing a half pound of USDA prime cut choice ground sirloin beef. This catches Fido's attention with his tail wagging appreciatively still covering his bone with his paw. You smile and extend your hand closer to Fido showing him more of the meat. Fido smiles back again this time smacking his lips. You extend your hand closer with the meat clearly offering it to Fido. Now Fido gets on his feet still with the bone in his mouth never taking his eyes off you. You take a few more steps toward Fido, still smiling, still offering the meat, now speaking his name.

This is the Fido who sleeps in your bed at night, who licks your face in the morning, and licks the chicken grease off your fingers. This is the Fido who drinks from the toilet in your bathroom. So, you expect Fido to accept your offer. But he hesitates and begins to back off as if he felt cornered and had to map an escape route and you were going to do something terrible to him which, of course, you were not. You don't understand Fido's reaction. You have only good intentions toward Fido. That is why you are offering him a half pound of this choice meat. (So what if there is doggy medicine mixed in with the meat?) This is all for his good. Fido ought to know that.

But Fido is still not sure, backing up with that nasty bone still in his mouth. You want to tell Fido, "Just drop the bone! This meat is my gift for you. I love you, so drop the bone. Please take the meat."

Now you are almost touching his nose. His tail stops wagging. You want to give him the meat, but he's got that nasty bone in his mouth. Fido has a choice to make. What will he do? The bone is a sure thing. It is already in his mouth. Then there is your offer of that top ground sirloin. But that is not yet in his mouth like that bone that already is. What is he to do? Take the sure thing or trust the promise of what might be? That is Fido's dilemma!

Fido's dilemma, a dog struggling to make a choice between a sure thing and a promise of what might be, is also behind what Paul has to say in today's reading from Romans 6. Paul had not yet visited the Christians in Rome to whom he was writing this letter. So, it lacks much of the specificity and concrete detail that marks many of his other New Testament letters. Nevertheless, in it he makes a most eloquent case for the gospel of Jesus Christ. In the chapters prior to chapter 6, Paul makes his case for the good news of justification by faith for the sake of Christ apart from the works of the law. We become righteous before God not by what we do but by our simple trust in what God has done for us in Jesus Christ.

In today's reading, Paul anticipates some of the criticism that is probably going to get aimed at him and this message. There will surely be those in the congregation in Rome, as there have been in every Christian congregation through history, who will distort Paul's message into what we often call "cheap grace." Paul asks a question for them: "Should we continue in sin in order that grace may abound?" In other words, does it matter how you live your life or how much you sin because God is going to forgive you anyway? Perhaps you have heard this same point of view in the words of the streetwise corner newsboy who upon hearing the good news of Jesus Christ exclaims, "God loves to forgive sins. I love to commit them. Isn't the world admirably arranged?" In other words, the gospel of the forgiveness of sins simply becomes permission for sinners to remain the same old sinners.

Seldom in congregations do we see "cheap grace" expressed this blatantly and defiantly. Usually it shows up in some form of lackadaisical indifference or sloth. You have heard the excuses: "I can't change. I'm just human, a victim of circumstances. That's just the way things are." And nothing changes. God's mercy becomes an excuse to remain the same old jerk. Nothing changes.

Throughout my years in the ministry, wherever I have served I have always been afraid that the gospel I proclaimed would be misheard as nothing more than "cheap grace." When I announce that you don't have to do anything to be saved because God has done it all for you in Jesus Christ, I fear that this is exactly what will happen: nothing! Every year, when I joyously announce this good news to the youth about to be confirmed, I fear that more often than not it is simply misunderstood. It becomes a license to do nothing. "I don't have to do my assignments. It doesn't matter that I don't do the work. Jesus forgives me anyway." Nothing ever changes. God's forgiveness becomes an excuse to maintain the status quo.

When faced with this kind of distortion of the gospel, the temptation is to clamp down on the bad behavior. We think that we have got to start lecturing people on what they are supposed to do and not do. We think that the solution is ethics. If we would only tell people what they are supposed to do, if we would only promise rewards for good behavior and punishment for bad behavior, then all would be well. That is not what Paul does. For Paul the problem is not just bad behavior. The problem is identity. The problem is who we think we are and what we trust. What we believe ourselves to be and in whom we put our trust are ultimately what determines our behavior. If you are going to change the behavior of people in any lasting manner, you have got to change their self-understanding, what they believe themselves to be and what they believe will give their lives meaning and direction.

That was also Fido's dilemma. Fido's difficult choice between the old, dry bone and the fresh, ground meat was not so much about his behavior but about what he believed himself to be and in whom he trusted. Does Fido believe that he is on his own and has to manage and control his own life? Does Fido believe that he must hold on to the old, dry bone no matter what or does he believe that he can afford to let go of the bone in order to take hold of the meat? Does Fido believe that he belongs to his master who always cares for him no matter what or does he believe that he is on his own and must be the master of his own fate?

Who are we? Who do we trust? Paul clearly lays out the dilemma. Are we under the control of our old self, the old Adam and Eve within us, whose favorite three last words are "me, myself, and I"? Or are we under the control of the new self, the "New You," who clings to God's word of mercy in Jesus? Paul reminds us of our new identity, of who we became in the waters of baptism. When we were baptized, we no longer were under the power of sin, death, and the power of the devil. We now are under the power of Christ. We are now under new ownership, God's ownership. In a sense, we have already died and rose again with Christ. In a sense, the worst thing that could ever happen to us, our death, has already happened. We have already died with Christ and we have already risen with Christ, already now. When the waters of baptism splashed on our bodies and the words of promise were spoken, God gave to us Jesus' fate and destiny. It was as if God offered us the USDA prime-cut ground sirloin, and to make this gift our own all we need do is to let go of the old, dead, dry lifeless bone of this world and its empty promises.

In the waters of baptism, God gave us a new last chapter. Jesus' death and resurrection are now ours. Because we now have that new last chapter and we know what it is, we can live the plot of our lives differently. We no longer have to live in fear of death and losing all. We no longer are in the grips of our sinful nature that always wants us to live in fear of death. We no longer are under the power of the evil one because we know that he has been defeated through Jesus' death and resurrection. Continuing to believe that this is indeed our last chapter will not be easy. Every day it will be a struggle. Every day we will need to be reminded and reassured. Every day we will need to "remember our baptism."

Fido's dilemma has been resolved. We can trust that prime cut USDA choice ground sirloin promise of our baptism. We can let go of that old, dry, lifeless bone of sin and death and instead take hold of the offer of that new life that is ours in Christ.

Jesus loved to tell stories about the end of Fido's dilemma. We call them parables. Perhaps you remember this one from Matthew 13. A man was walking down a road one day and just happens to come across a hidden treasure. He is so surprised and overwhelmed by this fortuitous discovery that it changes his life. He sells all that he has and goes and buys that field. He lets go and gives up everything else in his life, everything that he previously thought was so important but now no longer is, in order to take hold of the treasure.

That is a picture of what can happen to us when God offers us a new life in Christ. We are just like what happened to Fido when the offer of that half pound of choice USDA ground sirloin finally wins his faith and ends his dilemma. He is able to let go of the old, dry bone, as safe and secure as it seemed, in order to take hold of that fresh meat and the new life it promised.

Letting go of the old in order to take hold of the new can easily be misunderstood. So often we want to turn it into what the lawyers call quid pro quo, "this for that." It's called "let's make a deal!" If you do this, then I will do that.

"Fido, if you drop the bone, then I will give you the meat." But that is not the logic and grammar of the gospel. That may be the way the world works, but that is not what God is up to in Jesus Christ. The grammar of the gospel is quite different. It is not "if — then." It is not a conditional offer dependent upon you doing something first. Quite the contrary, it is an unconditional offer to which you "get to" respond. It is a "because — therefore." Because of the offer, therefore you let go in order to take hold. Because you first offer Fido that half pound of USDA prime cut choice ground sirloin, therefore he all too willingly chooses to let go of the old, dry, and lifeless bone and takes hold of your generous offer.

That dynamic is continually lived out in the course of the Christian life. Repeatedly in our freedom, we willingly choose to let go of one thing in order to take hold of another. Usually an organization wants to put its best foot forward and wants to make a positive impression on any visitors. It wants to create a healthy image. But why not try something different at your morning service? Why not drag out all the dirty underwear? Why not start out by exposing for all to see all that we did wrong this past week, our failures, our mistakes, our misdeeds, and our sins? And do not do this as some sort of "let's make a deal." This would not be a case of if we sincerely repent of our sins, then God will forgive us.

No. Rather, we need to start our service by remembering our baptism. We need to start by making the sign of the cross, the same cross that was traced on us when we were baptized, and repeat those same words that were said at our baptism. "In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen." God made a promise in our baptism that he would always be our God and we would always be his children and therefore there was no sin that would ever be too big for him to forgive. Now we are going to hold him to it. We come to church burdened with memories and shame and guilt of a week that did not go well. But we remember our baptism. We remember its promise. We are going to dare God to keep it. We test that promise every week by getting it off our chest, by acknowledging those sins, as terrible and dastardly as they are, and giving them to God. We need to let go of them like Fido finally letting go of his old, dry, dead, and lifeless bone in order to take hold of God's offer; the USDA prime cut choice ground sirloin forgiveness in Jesus Christ. We will never be disappointed. There has never been a day when you have not been offered the sweet promise of God's forgiveness.

Letting go to take hold of dying and rising with Christ and daily remembering our baptism becomes a way of life for us. A friend has wronged us. A spouse has hurt us. A colleague has betrayed us. We can let go of the old, dry, dead, and lifeless bone. We can let go of our pride and anger and always having to be right and instead take hold of the new life that Christ offers us, as we forgive, turn the other cheek and walk the extra mile. We can let go of the old, dry, dead, and lifeless bone of our greed and materialism and take hold of the new life by being charitable and generous and pouring out our lives in service to others.

It may have been a dilemma for Fido, but it is no longer a dilemma for us. We have already died and risen with Christ. We are certain of our baptism. We know who we are. We may have wanted to keep it under our paw or firmly clenched in our jaws, but now the promise of that half pound USDA prime cut choice ground sirloin has changed everything. We are going to let go of that old bone and its empty promise in order to take hold of the new life God has given us in Jesus Christ. Amen.

CSS Publishing, Inc., Sermons for Sundays after Pentecost (First Third): The Good News, The Bad News, and The Only News That Matters, by Steven E. Albertin