Luke 18:9-14 · The Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector
Who Is Right
Luke 18:9-14
Sermon
by James Merritt
Loading...

Two homes in one city, but in two totally different areas with two totally different residents. One home was situated in a very comfortable, gated neighborhood with a well-kept yard with flowers around the mailbox and a mat at the front of the door that said, “Welcome” in soft navy letters. Inside that home lives a minister with his family. At the front of the house are bay windows where the pastor kneels to pray every morning hoping that his neighbors will see him, because he wants to be a witness.

The minister says, “Dear God, I am so grateful for who I am and what I have. I am so grateful that I get to work at a great church and that I don’t have the problems that other people have. I am so grateful that like so many people I have never had a drink. I’ve never smoked. I’ve never used profanity. I have been faithful to my wife and a good father to my children. I always go to church and faithfully pay my tithes. I am just thankful I am not like so many people out there who live such terrible lifestyles. I am so grateful I have never been like them and never will be.”

On the other side of town, in the rough urban neighborhood a second home sat. Half of the homes were empty, dilapidated, and boarded up. The neighborhood was very unsafe. The home itself was dark, because there was no electricity and it had the smell of sweat, urine and vomit. Used syringes were scattered across the floor. In the upstairs room, there is a lone chair sitting against the wall and a man sits in front of the coffee table where a line of cocaine has been sprinkled and scraped. He can feel the addiction gripping his heart as he drops to his knees to begin another ritual of snorting that line of cocaine into his nostrils, when all of a sudden a flood of conviction broke through the dam of his heart. Instead of reaching for the syringe, he looks up to heaven and says, “Oh God, there is no other person on this planet more worthless and less worthy to talk to you than I am. I have made terrible choices and I am suffering the consequences for them. I am getting what I deserve. God, I am asking you now, ‘Would you please have mercy on me?’”

Two houses. Two cities. Two men. Two prayers. One question - “In God’s eyes, who do you think got up justified?”

We are in a series called “Snapshots.” We know that a picture is worth a thousand words, but in the hands of Jesus words became pictures. These pictures we call “parables” are little stories that answer big questions. These parables give us snapshots of the Kingdom of God and of the God of the kingdom and it tells us how we are to relate to both.

Frankly, no snapshot that Jesus ever took makes me more uncomfortable, more convicted, and more introspective than this one, because honestly the pastor in the home I just described has been me. No, I have never prayed in front of a window to try and impress people with my witness, but as someone who has never had a drink, or taken a smoke, or used profanity, or been through a divorce, or used drugs, it is so easy to have the attitude, “I thank God I am not like people who do.”

[Turn to Luke 18]. The story I told you is based on an older version of a story that Jesus told about two men in a very similar situation, but with a very shocking conclusion. One man was convinced that he was in the Kingdom of God, but he didn’t get in. One man realized he didn’t deserve to be in the Kingdom of God, but he did get in. One man was convinced for the wrong reason he was right with God, but he was wrong. One man was convinced for the right reason he was wrong with God and he got right.

We need to understand to whom Jesus told this parable, because there are a lot of us in this room, and a lot of us watching by television, or listening via the Internet that Jesus is directly talking to today.

“He also told this parable to some who trusted in themselves that they were righteous, and treated others with contempt.” (Luke 18:9, ESV)

Jeff Foxworthy has become famous for identifying rednecks. To go into Foxworthy mode, you just might be in this parable if any of the following things are true about you.

Do you ever look at people who don’t go to church and think you are better than they are, because you do go to church?

If so, Jesus is talking to you.

Do you ever look at people in prison and think you are better than they are, because you are not?

If so, Jesus is talking to you.

Do you ever look at people who drink and think that you are better than they are, because you don’t?

If so, Jesus is talking to you.

Do you ever look at someone who may be truly living in sexual sin or has made terrible financial choices or lives on the side of the street and thank God, because you haven’t and you don’t?

If so, Jesus is talking to you.

We are going to find out today from this snapshot who really is right before God. Key Take Away: When you look up to God, you will never look down on others. One man was rejected by God, and one man was accepted by God, and it was all because of where they looked and how they looked at themselves. There are two ways you can look at yourself and these ways will determine how God looks at you.

I. You Can See Yourself Comparatively

“Two men went up into the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector.” (Luke 18:10, ESV)

Church back in that day was different from church today. When we think about people praying, we normally think about people praying in private. There were two services every day in the temple when lambs were sacrificed and an atonement was made for sin. They had an early service and a late service. The early service started at sunup and the late service started at three o’clock. The senior adults went at sunup and the students went at 3 o’clock (just kidding!). Each service started outside the sanctuary, at the altar, where the sacrifice for sins would take place. There would be the sound of trumpets, the clanging of cymbals, and someone would read a psalm. The priest would then enter the outer part of the sanctuary where he would offer incense and trim the lamps. Then, he would leave and anybody there could offer their prayers to God.

“The Pharisee, standing by himself, prayed thus: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax collector.’” (Luke 18:11, ESV)

First, we are introduced to the Pharisee. The Pharisee was the Eagle Scout of Judaism. If anybody was in with God, if anybody was cool with God, if anybody had a hotline to heaven, people thought it was the Pharisee.

Now I know the Pharisees have fallen out of favor today and the term has a negative connotation, but not so 2000 years ago. You could have taken a vote and any Pharisee would have overwhelmingly been chosen as the one who would have been most likely to know God, meet God, and be right with God. We are clued in immediately to his attitude, because we are told he is “standing by himself.” That is, he looked around at all the other people that were there, because he wanted everyone to know they did not belong in his company and he certainly did not want to be a part of theirs. Then, he looks in the mirror and begins to sing, “How Great Thou Art.”

“God, I thank you that I am not like other men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax collector.I fast twice a week; I give tithes of all that I get.” (Luke 18:11-12 ESV)

You immediately see what he is doing. He is comparing himself with others, but he specifically picked out someone that he thinks is beneath him. They are easy to spot – extortioners, adulterers, and of course tax collectors. Remember, Jesus said he is looking with the eyes of contempt.

Let’s get honest. Is there anyone you have contempt for deep down in your heart? Some kind of person, maybe it is a body type, a race, a gender, a socio-economic background, a lifestyle choice?

Yes, there are racial Pharisees who say, “Thank God I am not like these lazy, shiftless, no good minorities.” There are social Pharisees that say, “Thank God I am not like those chiseling Welfare freeloaders.” There are intellectual Pharisees who say, “Thank God I have an education and I’m not like these uneducated, hourly wage workers.” There are even pagan Pharisees who say, “Thank God I am not like the hypocritical Christians who go to church.” First of all, the man tells what he hasn’t done and then he brags on what he has done.

“I fast twice a week; I give tithes of all that I get.” (Luke 18:12, ESV)

Now there were three special days in the life of Judaism. The written law only required fasting on the Day of Atonement. Pharisees would usually fast two days before and two days after all three of the major days so they would fast 12 days a year. But this man, he is fasting two days every week – 104 days a year!

Then, he said he tithed everything he possessed. Now, you are only commanded to tithe your grain, your oil and your wine. This man tithed anything that he earned and anything that he possessed. He was proud and he was loud. He thought he was right with God, because of what he hadn’t done, what he had done, who he wasn’t, and who he was. You see, the problem was when he looked in the mirror he shouldn’t have been singing “How Great Thou Art”. He should have been singing, “You’re So Vain.” This man thought that you could look in two directions at the same time, but nobody can. He thought he could look up to God and look down on others. He didn’t understand when you look up to God, you can’t look down on others.

He reminds me of the 5th grade girl that came home from school and she was so excited. She had been voted, “Prettiest girl in the class.” The next day, she was more excited when she came home. She had been voted the “Most likely to succeed.” The next day she came home and told her mother she had won the third contest being voted the “Smartest girl in the class.”

The next day she came home crying. The mother said, “What happened? Did you lose this time? She said, “No. I won again.” She said, “What were you voted this time?” She said, “Most stuck-up.” When you meet anyone that is stuck up, just remember they are stuck on themselves.

These kinds of people have an “I” problem. Five times this Pharisee uses the pronoun “I”. He suffered from two problems: inflation and deflation. He had an inflated view of who he was and a deflated view of who God was. C.S. Lewis wisely said, “A proud man is always looking down on things and people; but as long as you are looking down you can’t see anything that is above you.”

Every one of us needs to hear this clearly. We should never under any circumstances compare ourselves with anybody else. People we think are worse than we are - that will lead to pride or people that we think are better than we are - that will lead to despair. Plus, it always leads to an incorrect view of who you are. There is a second way you can look at yourself.

II. You Can See Yourself Correctly

“But the tax collector, standing far off, would not even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’” (Luke 18:13, ESV)

Immediately you notice these two men could not be more different. People looked upon a Pharisee as being as different from a tax collector as the Pope would be from a pimp. In reality, everything the Pharisee was the tax collector was not. Not only did he not give any money to the temple, but he stole from the people that went there. We are told that he “stood far off.” He was expected to. No one would have anything to do with him. Where the Pharisee would stand in the very center of the court (that is on the front row out in the daylight) the tax collector slipped in on the back row standing in the shadows.

Where the Pharisee was too proud to look up, the tax collector was too ashamed to look up. Where the Pharisee was puffing his chest out, the tax collector was beating his chest saying in effect, “I know I have a filthy heart.” In response to this man’s request, we are going to learn a tremendous lesson today about the mercy of God. God will not give mercy to those who don’t think they need it, but God will give mercy to those who do.

This man is seeing himself correctly. Do you know why? You will only see yourself correctly when you see God correctly. When you see God correctly you will understand that only God is good and no one else is. Only God is perfect, no one else is. Only God is sinless, no one else is. Only God is Holy, no one else is. Where the Pharisee said, “I thank God I am not like you.” The tax collector said, “I thank God you are not like me either.”

There is only one person who receives mercy and that is the person who asks for it. There is only one person who asks for it and that is the person who recognizes he needs it. There is only one person who recognizes he needs it and that is the person who sees God the way He is and understands that God sees us the way we are.

Do you know how that happens? If you want to see God the way He really is and see you the way you really are, you must look at the cross of Jesus Christ. There is something in the English translation that is missed. When this man says, “be merciful to me” he doesn’t use the normal word for “mercy.” The word here goes back to the Hebrew word “kippur” which literally means “atonement.” Yom Kippur literally means “the Day of Atonement.” The word “atonement” means “to cover.” Remember, this man is standing not far from where a lamb has just been sacrificed for his sins. What this man was really saying was, “I know why that lamb had to be killed. Because of my sins, because of my transgressions, because of my shortcomings.” What this man really said was this, “God, I am admitting what you already know is true about me. I am a sinful man with a sinful heart – God, will you cover for me?” You are going to see that is all that God needed and wanted to hear from either one of these men. Now, Jesus is about to give another one of those amazing conclusions that just blew people away.

III. You Can See Yourself Clearly

“I tell you, this man went down to his house justified, rather than the other. For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but the one who humbles himself will be exalted.’” (Luke 18:14, ESV)

Remember, everybody thought the Pharisee was the good guy and the tax collector was the bad guy. The Pharisees wore the white hats and the tax collectors wore the black hats. If you had taken a vote that day on who was most likely to get into the Kingdom of God the Pharisee would have won by a unanimous landslide, but there is only one vote that counts and that is God’s. If you want to know who is right, it is who God says is right.

The most important word in this story is that word “justified.” To repeat, God is right and we are not. God is righteous and we are not. Somehow, we’ve got to be made righteous before God or we can never have a relationship with Him. He is the only one that can make us right and declare us to be right. That is exactly what it means to be justified when God declares those of us who are unrighteous to be righteous.

I have some dear friends that went through a terribly trying ordeal. They went to trial over an injustice that had been done to them by another person. They were presented with the option of either having a trial by jury or a trial by judge. They were advised to go simply before a judge because the case was so complicated.

It was a fateful decision for one simple reason. When that trial was over, only one opinion mattered. It didn’t matter if they thought they were right. It didn’t matter if their attorney thought they were right. It didn’t matter how many witnesses they presented that thought they were right. It didn’t even matter if the facts showed that they were right. The only thing that mattered was, “Would the judge think they were right?”

Many of you may remember one of the most famous plays in the history of the Atlanta Braves. It was when they won the pennant to go to their very first World Series. You may remember Sid Bream was the first baseman for the Braves. He is on second base, a single is hit to left field and here is the play. [Alfred – show video clip and freeze at moment when he slides into home and is looking up at the umpire].

Do you notice where Sid Bream is looking? He is not looking at the catcher, because it doesn’t matter what the catcher thinks. He is not looking at his teammates, because it doesn’t matter what his teammates think. He is not looking at himself. It doesn’t matter what he thinks. The only opinion at that moment that mattered was the umpire’s.

One man was right that day and one man was wrong. One man went home in the kingdom and one man went home out of the kingdom. One man said he was innocent, but he went home guilty. One man said he was guilty, but he went home innocent. The reason was because one man saw himself clearly, as a sinner, before a Holy God, who had forgiven him, because He had covered his sins with blood.

What you see in these two men represent the only two groups of people there are in this world. There are people who are unrighteous, but they think they are not. Then there are people who are unrighteous, but know that they are and both of them need the mercy of God. This is the conversation that should have taken place in that temple court that day. That Pharisee should have walked over to with the tax collector and said something like this, “What are you doing here? I’ve not seen you before.” “You know I am a tax collector and I rip people off for a living. God has finally shown me what I am and who I am and I am really embarrassed to be here, but I’ve realized I need God to have mercy on me. That is why I am here.”

The Pharisee replies, “Really? That is why I am here too!” The tax collector amazingly says, “Wait a minute! You are religious. You are spiritual. You are a Pharisee. You’ve never done any of the things that I have done. You are not the person that I am.” The Pharisee replies, “Yeah, but that is my problem. I am proud, arrogant, judgmental, and self-righteous and I need the mercy of God. Let’s make a deal. You don’t think you are good enough for God and I think I am too good for God. Let’s pray for each other.”

This story never fails to prick me. I bet you’ve done something I’ve done many times when I’ve read this story. I bet you did it today. I’ve read this story and I’ve said to myself, “Man – I thank God I am not like that Pharisee.” I just demonstrated that I was! Let’s remember what this story tells us.

It is not how you see you, but how God sees you that matters.

When you see God the way He is you will see you the way you are.

Mercy is not what God pays you because you tell Him you have earned it. It is what God gives you when you admit to Him that you need it.

There was a rich man who invited many guests to a feast he was having. When they got there, they saw his own chair richly decorated and place at one end of this long table. They didn’t know where to sit. He told them all to seat themselves according to how important they thought they were in his sight and he left the room.

Each guest did exactly what they asked them to do. They seated themselves according to how highly they thought of themselves and of how much they thought he thought of them. When they were all seated, the rich man came back into the room and moved his chair to the other end of the table.

When you look up to God, you can’t look down on others. When you look up to God, you will find a God who mercifully doesn’t look down on you either.

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., Collected Sermons, by James Merritt