Matthew 27:1-10 · Judas Hangs Himself
Pilate's Ruse
Matthew 27:1-16 · Luke 22:66--23:25 · John 18:28-40; 19:1-16 · Mark 15:1-15
Sermon
by Lori Wagner
Loading...

Optional Prop: Youtube: 3-year-old Mateo Makes His Case for Cupcakes: "Linda, honey, just listen."

[Optional beginning: Three-year old Mateo has just tied an end around his “No Cupcakes” with his Gramma, and is making his case as to why he should have his cupcakes. Normally, he calls his mother “Momma.” But when he’s arguing, his mother is “Linda, honey.” Wonder where he got that from? This video got so many hits in such a short time that Ellen DeGeneres brought Linda and Mateo to her show and sat down with them.

Am I the only one who sees him or herself in little Mateo: “No, no, listen to me God... you don’t let me do anything...” “God, listen. You’re not listening to me, God. You give my brother cupcakes. You gave my sister cupcakes. What about me! Where are my cupcakes? I’ll do anything for those cupcakes. I’ve earned those cupcakes….Haven’t I?”

All disciples of Jesus are different, but we all are alike in some ways. We all want those cupcakes.]

And oh the promises we make!

We go to church regularly. We practice the required rituals mostly in the church –baptism, communion, marriage, funerals. We show up on Easter and Christmas….

We go through the liturgies, recite the Apostles’ Creed, memorize the Lord’s Prayer and say it every week. We do those things that pertain to “coming to church.” But when it comes to going not coming --when it comes to going out into the world and proclaiming Jesus’ name wherever we go, we all pretty much do exactly what Jesus’ disciples did before and during his arrest. We hide. We flee.

It’s too big an “ask,” we say. How could Jesus “ask” so much?

We spend the entire church year pretty much following Jesus and his disciples around, watching them learn from him, admiring their faith, wondering at their sacrifices, nodding as they get it. But we don’t talk much about their failures, do we? We don’t like to feature their faults.

Yet even after Jesus raised Lazarus; even after Jesus performed all those healings and miracles; even after he told his disciples what he’d have to do, at the end of Jesus’ days, the disciples are still squabbling and quarreling. They sit at dinner with Lazarus and his family, and they grumble when Mary pours nard over Jesus’ feet. After their last supper together in the upper room, they follow Jesus to Gethsemane, and during the worst night of his life, when he’s so upset and distressed that he’s literally sweating blood, his disciples can be found doing what? They are tired. They’re bored. And they fall asleep.

He begs them three times. Please sit with me. Be near me. Stay with me tonight. I’m in turmoil. I really need you. I need your prayers. And what do they do? They are too tired. None of them sit with him. None of them pray with him. None of them hold his hand or put a hand on his back, letting him know they are there. None.

And when the soldiers arrive to arrest him, what do they do? After an initial stand by Peter, they all flee.

It’s easy to say we believe in Jesus. It’s not hard to go through the motions of being a Jesus follower. But when the rubber hits the road, when it starts to get hard, when our own lives must change, when we are facing peer pressure, when we are influenced by popular agendas, when we’re challenged by our neighbors, and hushed by people who live by secular standards, what do we do? We balk at upsetting the status quo. We’re embarrassed to proclaim Jesus’ power to those who don’t believe in him. We don’t like people thinking we’re odd and old school, because we follow Jesus. So we become afraid, and we back away.

It’s hard to follow Jesus in a world of nones and dones. It can get you into trouble with a lot of people.

We like to be good people, but we don’t want trouble.

But Jesus? He’s definitely trouble . . . trouble with a Capital “T.” He was then and still can be now, depending on whom you’re talking to.

Now Pontius Pilate (the Roman Governor at the time Jesus ministry was in full swing) had a particularly interesting way of averting trouble, and of pleading innocent even as he sentenced Jesus to death. He had been approached by the High Priests in the early morning hours. They had a favor to ask. It was more a demand than an ask in fact. And he was in no mood.

Jesus’ ended his time with his beloved disciples with a foot washing. Pilate ended his time with those annoying priests with a hand washing.

That hand-washing ritual? What did it mean? We’ve seen it each year. We’ve talked about it many times. But what was really going on in Pilate’s mind?

Was he employing the Jewish custom of purity? Washing away his responsibility? Pilate? Doubtful. Pilate is a much shrewder politician than that.

What he was doing is placating the religious establishment even as he made sure Jesus would never threaten the political status quo.

Sometimes we try to make Pilate seem to feel guilty, or at least to feel saddened and reticent to sentence Jesus to death. But Pilate was not that kind of guy. Known for being ruthless, and stubborn, and downright deadly, Pilate was your worst nightmare if you threatened Rome in any way. Or threatened what he wanted. Or even if he just didn’t like you.

“According to Philo ("De Legatione ad Caium," ed. Mangey, ii. 590), [Pilate’s] administration was characterized by corruption, violence, robberies, ill treatment of the people, and continuous executions without even the form of a trial. His very first act nearly caused a general insurrection. While his predecessors, respecting the religious feelings of the Jews, removed from their standards all the effigies and images when entering Jerusalem, Pilate allowed his soldiers to bring them into the city by night. As soon as this became known crowds of Jews hastened to Cæsarea, where the procurator was residing, and besought him to remove the images. After five days of discussion he ordered his soldiers to surround the petitioners and to put them to death unless they ceased to trouble him. He yielded only when he saw that the Jews would rather die than bear this affront. At a later date Pilate appropriated funds from the sacred treasury in order to provide for the construction of an aqueduct for supplying the city of Jerusalem with water from the Pools of Solomon; and he suppressed the riots provoked by this spoliation of the Temple by sending among the crowds disguised soldiers carrying concealed daggers, who massacred a great number, not only of the rioters, but of casual spectators. In spite of his former experience of the sensitiveness of the Jews with regard to images and emblems, Pilate hung up in Herod's palace gilt shields dedicated to Tiberius, and again nearly provoked an insurrection. The shields were removed by a special order of Tiberius, to whom the Jews had protested. Pilate's last deed of cruelty, and the one which brought about his downfall, was the massacre of a number of Samaritans who had assembled on Mount Gerizim to dig for some sacred vessels which an impostor had led them to believe Moses had buried there. Concerning this massacre the Samaritans lodged a complaint with Vitellius, legate of Syria, who ordered Pilate to repair to Rome to defend himself.”

No, Pilate was not your nice guy. He didn’t “wash his hands” because he didn’t want to execute an innocent man. Pilate couldn’t care less about “innocence.” In fact, when he does hand over Jesus to his soldiers, they beat him viciously. Pilate is playing a much more sinister kind of game. He’s playing with the Jewish authorities, whom he utterly despises. And he’s playing too with Jesus. And also with his wife. They dared to try to “play” him? He’d play them back. And he’d placate his wife in the process.

Pilate’s wife, named as Claudia Procula in the apocryphal book, the Gospel of Nicodemus, was said to be a Jewish proselyte. As a woman of high class, Claudia would have had considerable influence within the Jewish faith. She may in fact have objected to the high priest’s corruption, and the apparent mock trial of Jesus, who she knew had been speaking God’s truth and healing many of the people. When Pilate is in his Praetorium questioning Jesus, Claudia sends her husband an urgent message not to condemn the prisoner he held before him. Jesus is a just man, she says. She had been visited by a dream, she says, in which God told her not to condemn Jesus, and she saw dire consequences ahead over the death of this man.

What does Pilate do? Pilate is a cunning politician. He’s clever and crafty. His wife is the granddaughter of Caesar Augustus. He’ll need to appease her in some way. So, he pulls off a clever ruse. Needing to appease the anger and insistence of the Jewish authorities who obviously for their own reasons want this Jesus dead, wanting to satisfy his wife, who had been influenced by the Jews, whom he hated more than anything, he would need to appear “just.” He would need to play “the game” of “discussing” Jesus’ fate. And he’d do away with the potential threat in the process.

Did Pilate care if Jesus lived or died? Absolutely not. But he definitely would have leaned toward death no matter what, especially when the word “king” resounded in his head and when he was clued into the masses of people following Jesus. It wouldn’t have mattered what Jesus said. He wasn’t having anyone live who even possibly could incite an uprising of the Jewish people, who hated Rome’s oversight. Jesus was expendable. He would have to go.

But Pilate also didn’t want to give in to the priests either. Or give them the pleasure of telling him what to do. They had arrived at his palace in the wee hours of the morning, disturbing him, wanting him to dispose of their problem. On top of it, they wouldn’t even come inside, for fear of “degrading themselves” before the Passover by allowing their feet to touch his “desecrated” palace. No, Pilate held no sympathy, only sneers for this group of “officials.” But he held no sympathy for Jesus either. He did however have to pacify his wife.

Asking the Jewish authorities therefore if they wanted Barabbas or Jesus was a clever game. Both, Pilate knew, were threats. But Barabbas was small time, an annoyance for sure, but if he let Barabbas go, he knew, the man was not too smart, and he would do the same old thing, and he could be caught again. Perhaps PIlate could snare two mice with one trap.

Barabbas was an insurrectionist (a rabble rouser, a riot inciter, and he had murdered a man). He got a few people riled up. But he had no great following. No great power. He was a petty criminal in a way. Just another one of the little guys who occasionally would try to cause trouble in the city.

This Jesus on the other hand was smart, had a huge following among the common people, and his steely silence was infuriating. He was not like the others. This one could possibly be a real threat. And Pilate would have seen him as such. No wonder Herod and Pilate (former enemies) became friends after Jesus’ trial. Pilate surely saved Herod’s kingly butt. At least he would have told him so. “Jesus may have been your usurper, Herod,” he would have reasoned.

So, to appease his wife and bait the Jewish authorities, Pilate plays a clever game. He asks the high priests who they want to send to death. This “innocent” man? Or Barabbas? He already knows exactly what they’ll say. They hate the man. Otherwise, they wouldn’t be asking him for the favor. Annoying little men. “Choose” he says, dangling the Jesus carrot. By majority voice, they choose to sentence Jesus.

The high priests are frustrated and angry. But they are determined. Not Barabbas, no! Jesus! They need to get their way. After all, they just arranged his secret arrest, and rushed through an illegal trial. Soon it would be dawn, and the people would start to get wind of what was going on. They need Pilate to hurry. They need to finish this …now!

Pilate is taunting them. He knows they want Jesus dead….and now he is hesitating…just enough to make them mad, make them shout. The high priests insist louder.

Finally, Pilate relents. But he goes through a long motion of deliberately “washing his hands,” proclaiming to the Jews that Jesus’ death is “on them.”

He should have been an actor, his charade was so good. He watches the priests take it upon themselves as he mimics their purification ritual. He signals to his wife that he has heard her plea, but acts as though the decision is “out of his hands.” Yet at the same time ….. in the custom of Rome (for Pilate is in no way bound to the Jewish custom of hand washing) …. Pilate “washes his hands” in Roman style --in preparation for a victory, in preparation for the destruction of a dangerous opponent. For Pilate, sentencing Jesus is now one more notch in his political doorpost. For in a crafty and cunning political move, through this “hand-washing” tactic, Pilate has won. He gives the command!

Pilate has won.

With this age-old ritual, Pilate has pulled the wool over the Jewish authorities and placated them into thinking he is doing what they want. He’s placated his wife, to whom he will claim he was put into a difficult position and had no choice. He’s silenced a possible enemy of the state, this Jesus, who claims to be “king of the Jews.” He’s even gained a friend in Herod, whom he will make sure feels he owes him a favor.

“We have no King but Caesar,” the Chief Priests boasted. Indeed….you don’t, Pilate must have thought. Indeed you won’t.

Is this how it went? Or was Pilate as afraid as his wife? Did his superstitions overcome him? Did he merely want to get rid of this problem called Jesus? Make him someone else’s issue. Pass the buck. Get him out of his realm of responsibility. That doesn’t sound much like the Pilate described in the history books. But then again, no one met anyone quite like Jesus.

While Jesus’ disciples fled the Romans and the Priests, it seems, everyone else is fleeing Jesus. He’s a little too spooky after all. Judas goes back and tries to pass the buck to the High Priests for betraying Jesus. Too spooked to deal, he ends up committing suicide. The High Priests pass the buck on the silver and use it to buy a Potter’s Field. Then they pass Jesus onto Pilate. Pilate tries to pass Jesus onto Herod, who passes him back to Pilate. Pilate then passes the final buck onto the High Priests again by washing his hands. Perhaps he shudders, part victory, part fear. He just wants done with this strange man.

Was Pilate’s hand washing a ritual of passing the buck of responsibility, a petition of innocence? Or was it a decision of power and victory? We can’t be entirely sure.

But we do know that hand-washing and foot-washing were two rituals that would have profound meaning in the day before Jesus’ death. One signified humility and service, the other, both a symbol of atonement (Hebrew) and the cunning of power (Roman).

The early church would choose foot-washing as its symbol, the symbol of the disciple’s servanthood. In fact, foot-washing was so popular in the early church that it competed for a while with the Last Supper as one of the two definitive “markers” of a body of Christ (the other being baptism, of course).

Jesus’ disciples realized later, when they discovered what had happened after they had fled, when they discovered that Jesus was truly sentenced to death, what their defection would mean. Only later, they would need to get over that fear, that reticence, that reluctance to go into a hostile culture, even if as “wise as a serpent, innocent as a dove,” if they wanted to be true disciples of Jesus. But they wouldn’t realize the importance of that mission until the day of resurrection.

It’s easy to be afraid in a hostile culture. It’s easy to think we’ve done enough. It’s perhaps sometimes even necessary to hide in the face of danger, especially when you don’t know how to proceed in a world of political savvy and religious extremism. But Lent is that time when we prepare for the day of resurrection, when we come “out of hiding” and face our accusers –Jesus’ accusers. And tell it like it is. For Jesus is the true atonement, the At-One-ment with God for all of us.

Soon the day will come when we must proclaim Jesus as Lord, proclaim Jesus as victor. For Jesus IS victor. Not the High Priests, not Pilate, not Herod, but Jesus.

“Suffering may endure for a day, but joy comes in the morning,” says the psalmist (Psalm 30:5).

It’s time for Jesus’ followers, all of us, to come out of the shadows and into the Light, to proclaim Jesus alive and powerful in our world and in the next, to offer hope to the dying, and joy to the living, to prove that nothing, not politics, not religion, not hate, not sorrow can prevent God from realizing God’s kingdom here and in heaven.

Get ready to proclaim Jesus! Get ready to proclaim Jesus as Christus Victor. Get ready to bless others with the words Christus Victor----May Christ be victorious in your life. For he may be sentenced to death. But soon he will be risen. And nothing will ever be the same again.

Something “spooky” is coming your way. Will you stand firm in your faith? Or will you flee?

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., by Lori Wagner