Big Idea: Jesus provides a Christian form of the Jewish Shema (Deut. 6:4–9), labeled by some the “Jesus Creed,”1 which sums up the Ten Commandments: the relationship of the Christian with God (the vertical aspect of life) and with others (the horizontal aspect).
Understanding the Text
The four sections in 12:27–44 form a conclusion to Jesus’s public interaction with the leaders. The next time he sees them will be at his arrest in the garden (14:43–52). The first two sections are part of the controversies of 11:27–12:37, with (1) verses 28–34 ending on a note of victory and clarification of Jesus as the ultimate rabbi/teacher of Torah, and (2) verses 35–37, which may originally have been a controversy narrative2and clarify Jesus even more as the royal Messiah and cosmic Lord.
Interpretive Insights
12:28 One of the teachers of the law . . . Noticing that Jesus had given them a good answer. Mark is decidedly different from Matthew. In Matthew the “testing” of Jesus continues as a group of Pharisees, taking over from the Sadducees (22:34–35a), try to catch Jesus in a legal error and expose him to the people. Mark has a positive tone, with a single scribe recognizing Jesus’s “good answer” against the Sadducees in the previous section.3Matthew makes this the final attempt to entrap Jesus, while Mark centers on the single member of that group who correctly acknowledges Jesus as a superior rabbi.
Of all of the commandments, which is the most important? William Lane explains, “A distinction between lighter and weightier, smaller and greater commandments was an inevitable feature of Palestinian piety, since it was traditional to speak of the 613 individual statutes of the Law.”4He was trying to get Jesus’s opinion of what summed up the Torah in the best way.5He was both trying again to trip Jesus up (the Matt. 22:35 version: “tested him with this question”) and honestly seeking an answer, having recognized Jesus’s wisdom (Mark here). Matthew and Mark do not contradict each other but rather bring out two aspects of the same scene.
12:29 Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God, the Lord is one. This is the first part of the Jewish Shema (from the first Hebrew word of the creed, meaning “hear”), consisting of Deuteronomy 6:4–9; 11:13–21; Numbers 15:37–41 and recited by pious Jews each morning and evening (Deut. 6:7). It formed the basic creedal affirmation of Judaism, and the essential part is here, the monotheistic confession that Yahweh (the Lord) is the one and only God. This was the core affirmation of Judaism and Christianity and was the core command that made idolatry (the worship of other gods) an ultimate sin against God.
12:30 Love the Lord your God with all your heart . . . soul . . . mind . . . strength. The two commands in verses 30–31 sum up the two tables of the Decalogue, the first four encompassing love of God, and the last six love of neighbor. This command is from Deuteronomy 6:5, which has three elements, with Mark adding “mind” for a fourth. The purpose in all the lists (Matt. 22:37 omits “strength”) is to call for loving God with one’s whole being, totally and in every facet of one’s life. Rabbis stressed each aspect, loving the Lord with understanding, feeling, and spirit (heart), with one’s entire life (soul), with thinking and volition (mind), and with all one’s energy, might, and power (strength). There is a great deal of overlap between the terms, and Jesus likely intended them to be taken together to depict all that one has and is being focused on love for God.
12:31 Love your neighbor as yourself. This is the “second” summary command, meaning that love of others is based on and grows out of love for God. It comes from Leviticus 19:18, which for the Jews meant primarily a love for the people of Israel (though 19:34 adds the resident aliens, the Gentiles in their midst). Jesus extends the “neighbor” to encompass all fellow humans (e.g., enemies [Matt. 5:43–48]). “As yourself” means to love others just as much as you love yourself. All of us by nature are concerned for our own well-being and needs. This does not mean a self-centered attitude, for Jesus has demanded that we serve and put ourselves last (Mark 9:35; 10:43–44); rather, it means to care for others with the same consideration that we extend to ourselves.
12:32 Well said, teacher . . . You are right . . . God is one and there is no other but him. The scribe is acknowledging Jesus as a true “teacher” (rabbi) or interpreter of Torah, and with this the controversy narratives of 11:27–12:33 end on a note of victory for Jesus. The fact that Mark depicts the scribe centering on Jesus’s recitation of monotheism in the Shema shows that this is central for Christianity as well as Judaism.
12:33 more important than all burnt offerings and sacrifices. Mark stresses the scribe summing up both of Jesus’s points to make them all the more emphatic for the readers. Love of God and the resultant love of neighbor are key elements of what it means to be a member of God’s community. The addition of “more important than” by the scribe is startling. R. T. France calls it a “sweeping demotion of the whole system of temple sacrifice on the part of the scribe.”6Still, we should note 1 Samuel 15:22 (“to obey is better than sacrifice”) and Hosea 6:6 (“I desire mercy, not sacrifice”). The actual point is this: Sacrifices are essential, but the sacrifices of the heart are even more so (see the “spiritual sacrifices” of 1 Pet. 2:5).
12:34 You are not far from the kingdom of God. Several have noted the contrast between the rich young man in 10:17–22, who likewise centered on the commandments but failed to enter the kingdom because of his possessions, and this scribe, who is “not far from the kingdom.” Jesus means that because of his understanding and recognition of Jesus, this scribe is on the verge of becoming part of the kingdom community. Yet we are not told if the man took the final step; we do not know if this led to repentance and belief (1:15). Probably Mark wants his readers to ask this of themselves: “How far am I from the kingdom?”7
No one dared ask him any more questions. The leaders are forced to acknowledge Jesus’s absolute victory over them. In the last two parts of this section (vv. 35–37), Jesus will ask the question and answer it himself. Once again Jesus silences his critics (3:4; 11:33; 12:17). In the very center of their authority, the temple courts, Jesus has demolished their arguments.
Theological Insights
Here as well the central insight is Jesus’s ultimate wisdom as the true interpreter of Torah; all of the word of God draws its meaning from him. The essential truth with which Jesus begins affirms how all persons must relate to God: we are to love him with every fiber of our being. God created this world out of love, and love is the only proper response. Love of God then becomes the basis for all proper human relationships, as the love that we experience from and with God results in a loving response to those around us.
Teaching the Text
1. God is one God and exists in three persons. The major distinction between Judaism and the other ancient religions was the monotheistic cast of every aspect of Jewish religion. Theirs was a transcendent God, not the animistic identity of gods with forces of nature that characterized other religions. For Israel, God is distinct from natural forces; indeed, he created them. So to represent God in any other created form is idolatry (Exod. 20:4–5). Indeed, the core of the Old Testament is the oneness of God. The Creator must transcend his world and be one (as in the Shema, quoted here). “The Lord is God; there is no other” (1 Kings 8:60 [cf. Isa. 45:5, 21]). The New Testament also affirms that God is one (Rom. 3:30; 1 Cor. 8:6; Gal. 3:20; 1 Tim. 2:5; James 2:19). However, for all Christians, monotheism must be understood within Trinity: God is one, and that means three-in-one. We must first note pretrinitarian theology in the Old Testament. The “word” of God becomes a creative force (Gen. 1:3; Ps. 33:6; Isa. 55:11), and the “Spirit of God” is the divine presence (Isa. 42:1; 63:10; Ezek. 36:26–27; Joel 2:28). Finally, the Messiah is more than a man (Ps. 110:1; Isa. 9:6; Dan. 7:13–14). This was not clarified until the teaching of Jesus and the New Testament writers. Jesus identified himself as the Danielic Son of Man (Mark 2:10, 28; 8:38; 13:26) and as the “I am” of Exodus 3:14 (John 8:24, 28, 58; 13:19), and he was recognized as creator and sustainer of the world (John 1:3–4; Col. 1:16–17; Heb. 1:2). The rest of the New Testament often calls him “God” (e.g., Rom. 9:5; Titus 2:13; Heb. 1:8; 2 Pet. 1:1; 1 John 5:20). The Holy Spirit functioned as God in giving salvation (John 3:5, 8), pouring out God’s love (Rom. 5:5), and indwelling the church as the Shekinah, making it a temple (1 Cor. 3:16; 6:19). The New Testament is replete with trinitarian passages that equate the Son and the Spirit with the Father as one God (Matt. 28:19; 1 Cor. 12:4–6; 2 Cor. 13:14; Eph. 4:4–6; 1 Pet. 1:2; Jude 20–21; Rev. 1:4–5). The Triune Godhead is one God, and this truth defines New Testament Christianity.
2. Love God with all you have. Loving God (the natural response to God’s depth of love for us) is the key to both Judaism (the Shema [Deut. 6:4–5]) and to Christianity (the Christian Shema [Mark 12:30]). All worship in the end boils down to this essential reaction of love. The desire to live the Christian life flows out of it. Some wrongly see the God of the Old Testament as a “God of wrath” and the God of the New Testament as a “God of love.” But Exodus 34:6 says that God is “compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in love” (cf. Num. 14:18; Deut. 4:31; Neh. 9:17; Ps. 86:5, 15—in all these passages God’s love for us results in our devotion, trust, and praise for him). In Deuteronomy 4:29 (also 11:1, 22) God’s people are to seek him “with all [their] heart and soul,” and in Joshua 22:5 love for God leads to obedience and service with fullness of “heart” and “soul.” In the New Testament this continues, as love for God is connected with drawing near to him (Heb. 10:22; James 4:8), our oneness with God (1 John 4:16), and experiencing his goodness in our lives (Rom. 8:28). Love for God and for Christ defines the essence of being a Christian and is the basis for every aspect of the Christian life.
3. Loving our neighbor is part of loving God. Loving our neighbor is completely connected with loving God (1 John 4:20). Truly, we cannot do the one without the other. To “praise God” at the same time we vilify his people is a contradiction that negates love for God (James 3:9–10). This is true inside and outside the church. Galatians 6:10 defines it well: “Do good to all people, especially to those who belong to the family of believers.” So we have responsibility for all around us but especially for fellow followers of Christ. The goal of the early church was simple: “no needy persons among them” (Acts 4:34). This depth of love is exemplified in Jesus’s reaction to the scribe here (his opponents throughout Mark) as he receives the man in love and acceptance, even saying that he is “not far from the kingdom.” So our neighbor is not just a fellow believer or one from the same socioeconomic or ethnic group. A neighbor is anyone we encounter, anyone who needs help. There is no room for favoritism (James 2:1–7), no room for refusal to help (James 2:14–15).
Illustrating the Text
God as the one and only God
Theological Book: The Faith: What Christians Believe, Why They Believe It, and Why It Matters, by Charles Colson and Harold Fickett. The authors argue that Christians should not shy away from teaching the truth about the Trinity, identifying this as a key evangelistic tool. There are religions (for example, Mormonism, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Islam) for which the doctrine of the Trinity forms a key point of contrast with Christianity. In fact, Muslims maintain that belief in the Trinity leads Christians to practice polytheism. To illustrate the power of the biblical teaching on the Trinity, the book tells the story of Farid, a nominal Muslim who came to the United States in 1993. He became involved with a group of Muslims who were debating Christians. But in those debates Farid found his own position weak. He began to study the Christian faith and eventually embraced the biblical Jesus. Farid said that far from rejecting the Trinity, he concluded that it was logical and not contradictory. He compared understanding the Trinity to “a wave-particle duality principle in physics [which is] the only plausible yet unbelievable and seemingly contradictory way to explain the world.”8 We must understand what we believe and not shy away from boldly proclaiming biblical truth.
Loving God with all your heart
History: The name “Benedict Arnold” is synonymous with “traitor.” What many people do not realize is that Arnold was an important member of George Washington’s Continental Army and was critical to the success at Valley Forge. He was even wounded in the leg as he fought against the British army. But in May 1779 Arnold began to bargain with the British and eventually switched sides and fought against the colonists. There is much speculation about why Arnold chose treason, mostly focusing on a divided heart. His pride had been hurt when he felt overlooked by his commanding officers and the Continental Congress. Money also played a part, as he was given a large commission to join the British. To love God with all your heart means that your heart is not divided but belongs wholly to God. You cannot love God with all your heart and selfishly love money or seek status at the same time. A divided heart leads to treason. Is your heart divided?
Loving your neighbor as yourself
Personal Stories: You probably have experienced a time when someone loved you sacrificially, when a person was willing to sacrifice to give you what you needed. It does not need to be a dramatic story. But share your story from your perspective, explaining what happened and what it meant to you. Then consider the story from the other person’s perspective. If possible, ask that person to share (through a letter, a video, or in person) the reason for serving you and what it meant to him or her. Looking at loving our neighbor from both sides of the equation is a powerful way to motivate your congregation to truly love their neighbor.