1 Samuel 28:1-25 · Saul and the Witch of Endor
A Spooky Kind of Love
1 Samuel 28:1-25, Matthew 28:11-15
Sermon
by Lori Wagner
Loading...

Last week we remembered that Jesus walks beside us even when we don’t notice He is there. This week we are reminded that God is in charge, even when we try to take matters into our own hands!

There’s an old saying, “Life is what happens when you’re busy making other plans.” The phrase was coined by Allen Saunders in a Reader’s Digest article in 1957, later appropriated by John Lennon in his song, “Beautiful Boy.” I think all of us can resonate with that line, as well as its companion wisdom, “Want to make God laugh? Tell Him your plans.” 

We try in vain to plan out our lives, but nothing ever really goes “according to plan.” Just as we love to control our destiny, as we saw in the disciples’ journey to Emmaus, we also love to figure out our own problems.  Or we get angry and annoyed when God doesn’t respond to our petitions in the ways we would like and expect.

In fact, our prayers are often not so much petitions as they are stipulations. “God, please fix this problem for me!” we please. But what we are really saying is: “God I expect you to fix this problem for me, if you want me to keep believing in you.”

This is what I like to call “The Job Fallacy.” Just like Job, we expect that if we have done all the right things, we expect God to come through for us whenever a problem is at hand. But as we all know, God is not interested merely in our deeds. God is interested in our hearts, in having us be in a loving and faithful relationship with Him. God is interested in how much we are willing to trust Him, and in His love, even when things don’t go our way!

Think of it this way! When you are a child, you don’t expect to always get your way, do you? Sometimes, especially as you get older, you discover that your parents may make decisions that feel at the time unfair, or that make you angry, or that seem to thwart your current desires, or that even feel destructive to your life. Only later do you find, their wisdom was greater than yours.

Faith is a matter of maturity. Discipleship maturity. Relationship maturity.

Most of us take a lifetime to reach that kind of maturity. In our scriptures today, so did Saul.

Saul was feeling impatient. The Philistines, the arch enemies of Israel who were continuously out to pillage and plunder the Hebrew people, were camped at Shunem. Saul’s army was camped across the way at Gilboa. But Saul was feeling afraid. Not just of the Philistines. He was feeling unsure how things would go, because God was not answering him. He had petitioned, and prayed, pleaded and pested. But God would give no definitive answer. Or rather, God would not assure his victory over the Philistines. So Saul was sweating arrows.

Saul desired to be a righteous and upright King. He wanted to rule a tight ship of a country in God’s name. To that end he expelled all of the mediums and spiritualists from the land of Israel. He was ferocious in his “righteousness.” And all those who practiced the arts of superstition and spiritualism had fled the area or had stopped practicing openly.

But when Saul found that God would not appear at his beck and call, he decided to take matters into his own hands. He ordered his men to find him a medium.

“There’s one living in a cave in Endor,” they told him. So Saul disguised himself and set out for Endor’s cave. After all, he could hardly let anyone see him contradicting his own edict. But that didn’t stop him from doing so himself if it suited his own ends. So Saul appeared in Endor and asked the woman there to “Bring up a spirit!”

Ironically, the woman at first refuses. She is obeying Saul’s own edict better than he, and so she says to the stranger: “Saul has cut the spiritualists from the land! Why are you trying to trap me?”  

But Saul promises she won’t be punished. So she asks whom he wants her to conjure up. 

“The prophet Samuel!” he replies.

Again, the woman protests. “Why are you doing this to me! You are deceiving me! You are Saul himself!”

But he says to her, “Don’t be afraid . . . Just tell me what you see.”

So she proceeds to tell him what she sees: a ghostly figure coming up from the earth whom she describes as an old man wearing a robe.

I don’t know about you, but that seems like a pretty flimsy description to me. But for whatever reason, Saul accepts her vision. It seems like Saul has more trust in the medium’s answers than faith in God’s provision, doesn’t it? But Saul continues on and lo and behold, Samuel speaks:

“Why have you disturbed my rest by bringing me up?” he cries!

Saul reveals, he wants his advice on how to deal with the Philistines. Saul tells Samuel: “God won’t answer me . . . God won’t help me!”

Here is Samuel’s reply: “And so why are you asking me? Anything I’ve said has been God’s voice. The Lord has worked through me.” In other words, I can’t tell you anything God doesn’t want to tell you already. I am not wise of my own wits. I’m a prophet, a loudspeaker for the Lord.

Samuel (or I should say the Lord through Samuel) then reveals that because of Saul’s lack of faith, he will be delivered into the hands of the Philistines.

Let’s be clear: God is not punishing or killing Saul. God is making Saul face the consequences of his own choices: “Your ‘lack of faith’ has destroyed you,” he says. Just as Jesus said to several people in His own ministry and mission: “Your faith has healed you.”

You see, it is our faith that assures us and keeps God close to us through our turmoils and troubles. It is our faith that protects us and carries us through the billows and waves of life.

That’s so hard for us to wrap our heads around sometimes, isn’t it?

We want definitive answers. We want outcomes and assurance, safety and closure. We want to know that we will be successful. We want to know.

But knowing is not faith. Faith is being sure of something or secure in something that you don’t know.

Saul is interested in knowing what will happen. God is interested in Saul “knowing” Him –relationally, personally, intimately, and trustingly.

In Samuel 31, we find out that Saul’s worst nightmare came to pass. He may have passed all the laws of the land. But he broke his own laws, and broke God’s heart, due to his own lack of faith.

Today, the author of Hebrews speaks to us, reminding us that “entering into God’s ‘rest’” means trusting in God to bring us through. The author is referencing the 40 days of wandering in the wilderness, complaining at Massah and Meribah. The people’s lack of faith could not allow them to pass into the promised land. Only the next generation, those who were not hindered by their frustration and fear, could be the ones to pass through the Jordan.

“Today, if you will hear his voice, don’t harden your hearts,” says the Hebrews speaker (4:7).

Faith allows us to enter into God’s rest and to find peace amidst turbulence. That place of rest and assurance is not something we STRIVE to enter into, but we follow Jesus in TRUST and He ushers us into it safely and soundly.

God will “rest” the Holy Spirit upon an open spirit of a faithful people. God sees into our hearts and minds, as we know from the story of Job. And God discerns our level of faith.

Some might say, women have a kind of spooky intuition. They often seem to know things and feel things that the rest of us somehow miss.

This is the kind of spooky thing about Jesus. Jesus knows what’s in our hearts and in our minds before we say it. Jesus knows the faith of the woman who touches the hem of His garment. Jesus knows the faith of the Centurion. Jesus knows the faith of Nathaniel. And Jesus also knows the lack of faith He sees in many others.

Jesus says to all of us, “Come all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28). What Jesus is really saying is “My peace, my dwelling place, a room in my eternal house, is the true calm for your spirit, healing for your soul.” When we rest in Him and He in us, our hearts are calm even in the most turbulent times.

“How lovely is your dwelling place,” reminds the psalmist in Psalm 84:1. Indeed, God’s Spirit is our place is beauty, rest, wholeness, and assurance.

But we dwell with Him through faith. We trust in Him, trust to come close to Him, trust to be in relationship with Him, trust that He is with us no matter where we are, and that we can always find refuge in His loving arms.

But Jesus also says to His disciples, “when the Son of Man returns, will He find faith on earth?” For in the days of Noah, God looked everywhere and could not find a “resting place.” Only in Noah, whose name means “resting place” could God dwell, and as the “ark” waded through the turbulent seas of disillusion and contention, it landed on Mt. Ararat, and God’s covenant found a new “resting place” in Noah and his family.

In our world today, we look everywhere for answers except in our faith.

We may not look to mediums as Saul did. But we look to our finances, and our culture, and to our own problem-solving skills, and to our resources. Yet we cannot find assurance. We continue to be plagued by worry, anxiety, feelings of unworthiness, and fear. When God does appear in our midst, instead of calming us, we are spooked. For faith is also grounded in expectation, the kind of expectation that prepares and welcomes the unexpected. And the Holy Spirit nearly always catches us by surprise.

While we seem to expect tragedy, somehow, we never expect God to appear.

God always appears in the midst of us unexpectedly. With grace and patience that could calm a tornado. And even then, we find it hard to believe. Hard to waylay our fears.

When the disciples see Jesus walking on the water, they are spooked!

When the people in the wilderness see Moses shining ethereal face, they are spooked!

When Paul is thrown off his horse by a disembodied voice of Jesus, he is spooked!

When Mary at first receives her visitation from God, she is spooked!

When the guards at the tomb see the angels roll back the stone, they are spooked!

When Saul sees the vision of Samuel and understands that his “appearance” is God’s doing and nothing that the medium has done, he is so spooked, he falls to the ground and refuses to eat!

And yet, at nearly every visitation, God, and Jesus too, speaks the words: “Do not be afraid.” For God always brings us the offer of rest, and the promise of life and an abundant future. All we need is a little bit of faith.

Jesus surprises us every day with his continual resurrections of hope, love, forgiveness, and rest.

No matter how hard we try, how convinced we are, we can take matters into our own hands, no matter how much effort we put into trying to change our lives, there’s one thing God needs us to know, and it’s the same message He gave to Job those years ago:

Only God resurrects.

Only Jesus offers us resurrection and a life of resting in God’s loving presence.

And it all begins with faith.

Today, I invite you to pray, not for what you want, not for what you need, not for things to go the way you hope, but for faith. For in faith, you will experience the presence and the downright spooky power of God!

In Faith.

Just Faith.


Based on the Story Lectionary

Major Text

The Ghost of Samuel (1 Samuel 28)

The Story Circulated by the Guards After the Resurrection (Matthew 28:11-15)

Minor Text

The Song of Moses (Exodus 15)

Psalm 77: You Are the God Who Performs Miracles

Psalm 91: The Lord Will Guard You

Psalm 111: Fear [Respect] of the Lord is the Beginning of Wisdom

Elihu’s Sermon to Job (33)

The Raising of Lazarus (John 11)

Hebrews (4)

The Lament Over Babylon (Revelation 18)

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., by Lori Wagner