John 6:1-15 · Jesus Feeds the Five Thousand
The World's Largest Covered Dish Lunch
John 6:1-15
Sermon
Loading...

The Rev. Paul Brunner tells a wonderful story about a young man named Jeff. Jeff learned one Sunday morning that his church was holding a picnic that afternoon. He hurried home from church to pack his lunch and get to the picnic grounds. But, lo and behold, when he opened the refrigerator door, he discovered only a single piece of dried up bologna and two stale pieces of bread (one of them a heel). And to make things worse, there was barely enough mustard to color his knuckles when he tried to scrape the bottom of the jar. Nevertheless he made his sandwich, wrapped it in waxed paper and placed it in a large paper bag (so it would look as if he had a great deal more than a single sandwich) and set out for the picnic.

When Jeff arrived, the grounds were already crowded and the only empty spot he could find was at the end of a table next to the Lawson family. As he took his sandwich from the bag and began to unwrap it, the Lawsons began to spread their feast as well. They had a warm, red checkered tablecloth, heaps of fried chicken, potato salad and baked beans that smelled like heaven to Jeff. To top it all off, Mrs. Lawson brought out two of the biggest chocolate cream pies Jeff had ever seen!

He glanced at the bountiful feast and then back at his own meager meal when he felt a hand on his shoulder. It was Mrs. Lawson, “Why don’t we pool our food?” she was asking. “And we can all eat together!”

“No, I don’t think so,” Jeff embarrassingly told her. “I’m not really all that hungry, so I only brought a sandwich,” he said, hanging his head somewhat.

“Oh, please!” she smiled. “We just love bologna; we’ll cut it into pieces so everyone can enjoy it along with some fried chicken and all the fixings, and of course, some chocolate pie.” And so, says Rev. Brunner, Jeff came to the picnic that day as a pauper and stayed to feast like a king. (1)

Some people say this is exactly what happened when Jesus fed the multitude with five small barley loaves and two small fish. The people shared with one another and there was more than enough to go around. Whether that is a sufficient explanation of this miracle or not, it always amazes me how much food is left over at covered dish meals.

A little boy was asked what his favorite Bible story was. “Oh, I don’t know,” he said. “I guess it’s the one about the crowd that loafs and fishes.”

 Today’s story is one of the best known stories about Jesus. In fact, it is the only miracle, apart from Jesus’ resurrection, which is recorded in all four Gospels. That alone makes it important for us to study. We know from last week’s lesson that people were following Jesus wherever he went, in boats and on foot. There was no place to hide. And Jesus was moved with compassion by the crowd’s great need.

In today’s lesson from John’s Gospel, seeing the great multitude, Jesus asks Philip, “Where shall we buy bread for these people to eat?”

Philip seemed surprised by the question, and with good reason. Philip was from Bethsaida which was the closest town and would have known of the local resources. He answers, “It would take more than half a year’s wages to buy enough bread for each one to have a bite!”

He was saying that there was no earthly way they could feed that many people. From a human standpoint that was correct. There were no restaurants or supermarkets nearby, and even if there were, they didn’t have anywhere near enough money to buy food for a crowd numbering in the thousands.

Another of his disciples, Andrew, Simon Peter’s brother, spoke up, “Here is a boy with five small barley loaves and two small fish, but how far will they go among so many?”

That’s a good question. The needs are so great. Our resources are so few. From whence will the necessary help come? So often in ministry, we are faced with needs and all we see is the insufficiency of our church’s budget and the impossibility of meeting those needs. The early church in Acts had that very same problem on the very first day it all began. Three thousand Jews were converted and the young church had to find a place for them because they were now seen as traitors by their families and abandoned. That is why we read in Acts 2:45: “They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need.” Jesus had compassion on people and so did the early church.

Before they could meet the people’s needs, however, they needed to get organized. Jesus said, “Have the people sit down.” Here was the man with a plan. There was plenty of grass in that place, and they sat down. About five thousand men were there, John tells us. Add in an unknown number of women and children and you come up with a crowd that could have numbered 10,000.

Jesus told them to sit down. Then he took the loaves, gave thanks, and, says John, distributed to those who were seated as much as they wanted. He did the same with the fish. When they all had enough to eat, he said to his disciples, “Gather the pieces that are left over. Let nothing be wasted.” So they gathered them and filled twelve baskets with the pieces of the five barley loaves left over by those who had eaten.

It’s an amazing story. Jesus fed 10,000 people with five small barley loaves and two small fish. How did he do it? As we noted, some theologians say he did it by getting the people to share what they had. Like the Lawsons sharing their fried chicken and chocolate pie with Jeff in our opening story. Like people at a covered dish dinner sharing what they have and there is always plenty left over. It’s a good explanation, though, again, I’m not sure it is a full explanation.

Notice what John says next: “After the people saw the sign Jesus performed, they began to say, ‘Surely this is the Prophet who is to come into the world.’”

John calls this event a “sign.” Scholars tell us that John’s record of the life of Jesus is very specific in its purpose: “. . . that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and by believing you may have life in his name” (John 20:31).

John refers to all of Jesus’ miracles as “signs” signs that Jesus was the Messiah. This particular sign was a spectacular one, for it made Jesus wildly popular with the crowd. They even wanted to make him king. I’m not sure that just getting the crowd to share with one another would make that large of an impression. Of course, none of us knows how he performed this miracle. Or how he changed the water to wine in another of John’s stories. Or how he healed the blind or raised the dead. All we can do is agree with John that this is a sign that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that, by believing, we may have life in his name.

There is much to see in this story. First is Jesus’ concern that people’s needs be met. Jesus saw the people and their need and he felt compassion toward them. That is why he had so much to say about caring for the poor.

 Some of you are familiar with the work of evangelical activist Jim Wallis. Wallis once took some scissors to his Bible. This sounds sacrilegious, but that was not his intent. Wallis was a seminary student at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School when he and some classmates decided to eliminate a few verses. They performed surgery on all sixty-six books of the Bible, beginning with Genesis and not stopping until Revelation. Each time a verse spoke to the topic of poverty, wealth, justice, or oppression, they cut it out. They wanted to see what a compassionless Bible looked like. By the time they finished, nearly two thousand verses lay on the floor, and a book of tattered pages remained. They discovered that if you cut concern for the poor out of the Bible, you cut the heart out of it. (2) I wish more of us had a heart for the down and out like Jesus did. So many people have needs that are so great. 

There is a legend about Martin of Tours who is said to be the first military chaplain. He followed the Roman Army from place to place ministering to the soldiers, and to people in the places they conquered.

One cold winter day he was following the Roman Army into a city. There was a beggar at the gates of the city freezing from the cold and asking for alms. Martin had been in the field with the soldiers for weeks. He had neither coin nor crust of bread. So, he took off the battered old Roman soldier’s cloak he had over his shoulders, and with his sword he cut it into two pieces. One half of the cloak he gave to the beggar and the other half he kept for himself.

That night Martin had a dream in which he found himself to be an observer of a scene in heaven. He saw Jesus surrounded by a group of angels, and to his surprise the Lord Jesus was wearing the half of a Roman soldier’s cloak.

One of the angels asked Jesus, “Master where did you get that old dirty and torn half of a Roman soldiers cloak?”

And in the soft silence as the angels waited for Jesus to reply, he heard Jesus say, “My good servant Martin gave it to me.” (3)

Jesus saw the crowds and had compassion on them. Jesus taught us this is what the kingdom is all about. Sometimes we can ignore people’s’ needs, but not Jesus. He was moved with compassion by the people’s needs and he sought to help them. He viewed them as sheep without a shepherd, lost and helpless, without guidance, nourishment, or protection.

Jesus not only had compassion on the crowd; he was also moved to help them. Many people look on others in need with compassion; only a few are moved to help them in their need.

“What a pity,” we say when we see a person on the street in rags, asking for a handout. “How sad,” we think when we see a child in a magazine with their stomach bloated and covered with flies as if feeling sorry for people was the same as really helping them.

One day a student asked anthropologist Margaret Mead for the earliest sign of civilization in any given culture. He expected the answer to be a clay pot or perhaps a fish hook or a grinding stone. Her answer was “a healed femur.” The femur, of course, is our thigh bone. In a society based on hunting and gathering, a person with a fractured thigh bone would be useless. Mead explained that no healed femurs are found where the law of the jungle, survival of the fittest, reigns. A healed femur shows that someone cared. Someone had to hunt and gather for that injured person until his leg healed. The evidence of compassion, according to Margaret Mead, is the first sign of civilization. (4) Who can question that she is right? Compassion is certainly at the heart of our faith.

Mike Barrett, in his book, The Danger Habit, tells how difficult it is for highly competitive people to be compassionate. He tells about men who tried to climb Mount Everest in 2006 and some of the choices they were forced to make. He tells about a fifty year old climber, Lincoln Hall, who was left for dead by his team, and other passing climbers, on the side of that treacherous mountain. But a small team led by Dan Mazur of the U.S. stopped to help Lincoln down the mountain. In the process they saved his life but they gave up their own opportunity to make it up Everest.

Weeks later, the guide who led the rescue told The Today Show, “We just immediately sprang into action. You have to move quickly up there. If you mess around and start thinking about what to do, he could already be gone.”

But this story of heroism and self sacrifice contrasted with another less heroic story that took place only days earlier on the same mountain. Thirty four year old David Sharp died after forty climbers passed him and refused to help.

Think of that. One climber is left for dead, but is rescued and lives. Another is left alone to die . . . and dies. David Sharp was left to die so that other climbers could complete their ascent.

It’s easy to understand the motivation of those who passed by. They had invested many years of hope and dreams as well as thousands of dollars in their bid to climb Everest. Do they throw away all that to help a person who might not survive anyway? (5) They do if they are a follower of Jesus. Jesus had compassion on the people and thus was moved to act.

 A blog on the Internet written by someone who calls himself Chaplain Mike the Internet Monk recently told about a church in Texas that holds a community meal every Thursday night. They open their doors and invite in the homeless.

When the congregation started the meal, they did not know how long the ministry would last or how they would fund it. About 15-20 homeless folks showed up at the beginning, and they were nervous too, wondering what the catch was. However, after five years, the church now welcomes about 200 homeless people who come in from the streets each Thursday. The people of the congregation sit down with them and they eat a family-style meal together. They put out tablecloths, cut flowers and platters of delicious food with identifiable meats, and over the years folks in the congregation and the homeless people of their city have become friends. One guest said, “We know the food is good because you sit and eat it with us.”

After the meal they worship around the tables. They announce this ahead of time so that those who don’t feel comfortable can leave, and about half do. Then they go to the chapel and offer communion and perhaps only fifteen of the guests come. But the opportunity is always there. Today, after five years of doing this, 30,000 meals have been eaten around those tables and the church has never lacked funds to provide for these gatherings. (6)

That sounds like something Jesus might do, doesn’t it? And, of course, that is the whole point. Jesus wants us to be compassionate and caring as he was compassionate and caring. And don’t worry about resources. We in the church are always worrying about where the money is going to come from, as if God cannot provide for His people. When Jesus fed the multitude with five small barley loaves and two small fish, there were twelve baskets left over. Act with compassion and let God provide the resources. That’s what this story says to us.

Jesus saw the multitude and had compassion on them. What can we do in our community to show our compassion for those who need it most? When shall we get started? How about now?


1. http://www.lumc.net/uploads/sermon/Sermon0729.pdf.

2. Richard Stearns, The Hole in Our Gospel (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2008), 11. Cited in Max Lucado, Outlive Your Life: You Were Made to Make A Difference (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, Inc, 2010).

3. Rev. Dr. Thomas Lane Butts, http://day1.org/767-dear_god_where_are_you.

4. R. Wayne Willis Louisville, Kentucky Gerald Flury, http://www.sermoncentral.com/sermons/helping-a-hurting-world-gerald-flury-sermon-on-church-purpose-of-93272.asp?Page=2.

5. (Colorado Springs: Multnomah Publishers, 2006), pp. 94-96.

6. http://www.internetmonk.com/archive/sermon-jesus-vs-the-little-red-hen-john-61-15.

ChristianGlobe Networks, Inc., Dynamic Preaching Sermons Third Quarter 2015