Matthew 8:18-22 · The Cost of Following Jesus
Jesus’ Authority to Perform Miracles
Matthew 8:18-22, Matthew 8:23-27, Matthew 8:28-34, Matthew 9:1-8
Teach the Text
by Jeannine K. Brown
Loading...

Big Idea: Matthew encourages his readers to trust and follow Jesus wholeheartedly, as he shows Jesus’ power and authority to be greater than sin, the demonic, and even nature.

Understanding the Text

Matthew continues in this passage to emphasize themes of Jesus’ authority—here over sin (9:1–8), the demonic (8:28–34), and nature (8:23–27)—and faith as the appropriate discipleship response to Jesus (9:21–22; cf. 8:26). The call to follow Jesus wholeheartedly is issued in 8:18–22, picking up the call stories of the first four disciples (4:18–22) and anticipating that of Matthew, a tax collector, in 9:9. The story of Jesus’ calming the storm shares a plot connection with 14:22–33, where Jesus (with Peter momentarily) walks on the sea. Jesus’ (messianic) identity and the disciples’ little faith are emphasized in both accounts. The story of Jesus’ claim to forgive sins (9:2, 8) evokes Matthew’s identification of Jesus as the one who “will save his people from their sins” (1:21) and foreshadows Jesus’ death, which will be “for the forgiveness of sins” (26:28).

Interpretive Insights

8:20  the Son of Man has no place to lay his head. Jesus here refers to himself as the “Son of Man,” a designation familiar from its Old Testament usage. This is the first of thirty occurrences of “Son of Man” in Matthew; in each case Jesus uses the phrase to describe himself (in Matthew as well as in the other three Gospels). Although in many cases it functions primarily as a circumlocution for “I,” the echoing of Ezekiel (in which God frequently calls Ezekiel “son of man”) may suggest Jesus’ solidarity with Israel. At a few key points in Matthew “Son of Man” occurs as part of an allusion to Daniel 7:13–14; these occurrences signal Jesus’ vindication and authority (Matt. 10:23; 16:27–28; 24:30–31; 26:64).

8:22  Follow me. The message of 8:18–22 concerns discipleship, and specifically the sacrifice (8:18–20) and priority (8:21–22) involved in following Jesus. Jesus has already called four of his disciples to “follow me” (4:18–22). This call comes from Jesus and is not self-initiated, similar to the call of the first four disciples at 4:19 (see comments there). Here Jesus seems to deter one who volunteers to follow by emphasizing the cost involved (a nomadic existence). But the passage also indicates that one who is called must be ready to give uncompromising allegiance to Jesus. Rather than keeping a focus on the particular circumstances of these would-be disciples, the passage highlights the importance of following Jesus as one’s highest priority and following him despite the cost (cf. 6:33).

8:26  You of little faith. Jesus has already referred to his disciples as those of “little faith,” as they are the most explicit audience of the Sermon on the Mount (6:30; see 5:1–2). In the present occurrence their “little faith” (oligopistos) is tied to their fear of the storm and waves around the boat. Their fear displaces what should be their trust in Jesus, who has already shown authority over illness (8:1–17). Now Matthew highlights Jesus’ authority over creation by calming the storm. The characterization of “little faith” follows the disciples across Matthew (see 14:31; 16:8; 17:20; cf. 28:17).

8:27  What kind of man is this? Even the winds and the waves obey him? The disciples’ question that concludes the story of Jesus’ calming the storm is an important one for Matthew and his readers and hearers. It is the first time in the narrative that the question of Jesus’ identity has been raised explicitly since before his public ministry (1:1–4:16). The disciples have heard him teach and have seen him heal the sick. Now when they see his authority extending even over nature, they press to know what kind of man it is who stands before them. This question will guide the narrative in subsequent chapters, as Matthew highlights differing opinions of who Jesus might be (e.g., 11:2–3; 12:23; 14:1–2, 33; 15:22), culminating in Peter’s affirmation that Jesus is indeed God’s Messiah (16:16).

8:28  Gadarenes. Jesus and his disciples have now crossed the lake (the Sea of Galilee) and arrived in the region of the Gadarenes, which is part of the Decapolis (see 4:25).1According to Josephus, Gadara was home to Gentiles as well as some Jews (J.W.1.155). A mixed population makes sense of the presence of a herd of pigs (8:30), since Jews considered pigs and their meat unclean (Deut. 14:8). It is not clear, however, whether the two demon-possessed men healed by Jesus are Jew or Gentile. Given that Matthew otherwise clearly delineates Gentile recipients of healing (8:5–13; 15:21–28) and highlights the Jewish scope of Jesus’ mission (10:5–6; 15:24), it is more likely that this story also fits Jesus’ ministry to Israel in the regions in and around Galilee (see 4:23–25).

8:29  before the appointed time. The kairos (“appointed time”) indicated here very likely refers to the final day (see the same phrase, pro kairou, with this referent at 1 Cor. 4:5), when God was expected to make all things right and Satan and his powers would be destroyed. The only explicit reference to Jesus as “Son of God” in Matthew up to this point has been Satan’s taunt during Jesus’ temptation (“If you are the Son of God” [4:3]). What the demonic realm seems to know already, Jesus’ disciples will come to recognize (14:33; 16:16). For the import of “Son of God” in Matthew, see comments on 4:3, 6.

8:34  they pleaded with him to leave the region. Matthew has already begun to narrate a range of responses to Jesus and his kingdom ministry, including great faith (8:10), little faith (8:26), amazement (7:28; 8:27), and hesitance (8:21). Here the people of this town respond to Jesus’ display of power over the demonic by begging him to leave. Matthew seems to be indicating that the restorative power of the kingdom is not welcomed by everyone.

9:2  When Jesus saw their faith. Matthew highlights the faith of the friends of the paralyzed man (“their faith”), in concert with others in chapters 8–9 who come trusting that Jesus can heal someone they care for (8:5–6; 9:18). The theme of faith is pervasive in these miracle chapters, both implicitly and explicitly (8:2, 10, 13; 9:2, 18, 22, 28–29; cf. 8:26), as Matthew highlights the importance of trusting in Jesus’ authority to heal in line with Isaiah’s picture of eschatological restoration (8:17).

Take heart, son; your sins are forgiven. In chapter 8 Jesus has healed the sick, demonstrated power over a storm, and cast out demons. Now Matthew indicates that Jesus has power even to forgive sins. This scene of Jesus forgiving sins is unusual in Matthew: Jesus frequently heals, but only here does he claim to forgive sin. The scene foreshadows the Passover celebration that Jesus shares with his disciples, when he connects the Passover cup to his death (i.e., blood) as a means of “the forgiveness of sins” (26:28).

9:5  Which is easier: to say, “Your sins are forgiven,” or to say, “Get up and walk”? With this question, Jesus responds to teachers of the law who challenge his claim to forgive a man his sins. It seems clear that it is easier to claim to forgive sins than to claim to heal, since the latter claim is easily and quickly debunked if the man remains unable to walk. But to demonstrate his authority to forgive sins, Jesus heals the man, who then gets up and walks home (9:6–7).

9:8  they praised God, who had given such authority to man. While the teachers of the law seem to think that Jesus has crossed a line of authority—they consider his offer of forgiveness to be blasphemy (9:3)—the crowd that witnesses the healing attributes the action to God, “who had given such authority to human beings [anthropois]” (NRSV). If Matthew intends a wordplay here between the “Son of Man” (9:6) and “man” (9:8), as captured in the NIV, then it is precisely Jesus’ role as representative humanity that is in view in this passage (see comments on “Son of Man” at 8:20).

Teaching the Text

1. Jesus, as rightful king of this world, has power over nature and forces that work against God’s purposes. Matthew continues to emphasize Jesus’ authority in his Galilean ministry, both in word and deed. Not only does Jesus have authority over illness and disease (8:1–17), but also Matthew demonstrates Jesus’ power over the created world (8:23–27), over evil (8:28–34), and over sin (9:1–8). The cumulative effect of these displays of power is to show that Jesus is the true king of all. His arrival signals the return of the rightful king of all things, whose power will be made explicit in the final moments of the Gospel (“All authority in heaven and earth has been given to me” [28:18]). So the displays of power in chapters 8–9 are displays of kingdom authority. In line with good Jewish theology, God in Jesus is reclaiming what rightfully belongs to God (e.g., Ps. 24:1).

It is fairly common to hear Jesus’ miracles, both healings and especially his power over nature, used to prove his divinity. This equation has arisen from modernist debates about Jesus’ identity. While Matthew does portray Jesus as the embodiment of Israel’s God (see the section “Matthew’s Narrative Christology” in the introduction), he does not highlight this portrayal through the miraculous deeds of Jesus. In fact, Matthew makes it clear that these miraculous deeds point to Jesus as the Messiah—that is, the human agent of God’s restoring work (e.g., 11:2–5). This is Matthew’s burden: to prove that Jesus is God’s Messiah. In the Old Testament those who performed miracles by the power of God—both healings and miracles of nature—were not considered divine for doing so (e.g., Elijah in 1 Kings 17; Elisha in 2 Kings 6). So in preaching and teaching on Jesus’ miraculous works, we might focus where Matthew does. Jesus’ miracles signal that Jesus is God’s agent of restoration—the true Messiah—as God inaugurates the kingdom in this world.

2. Putting trust in Jesus and following him are right responses to experiencing his authority. Interspersed in these two chapters focused on Jesus’ authority over illness, sin, and evil are discipleship sayings (8:18–22; 9:9–17). The first of these two discipleship moments highlights the cost of following Jesus. It is not enough only to be willing to follow Jesus; potential disciples are called here to count the cost (8:19–20). Since Jesus has no permanent home, his followers must reckon on following him wherever he would lead. Allegiance to Jesus displaces home and even family commitments, something that we see in 8:21–22, where family obligation is shown to be secondary to following Jesus. To first-century ears, this would sound quite countercultural, given the significance of family loyalty and obligation in the ancient world. Jesus in Matthew will speak to this question at a number of points (e.g., 10:37–39; 12:46–50; 19:29). Following Jesus means reorienting oneself in relation to all other commitments. No allegiance is left untouched.

So as we teach this passage, we might ask people to consider their loyalty to Jesus and the kingdom that he is bringing. Have other loyalties displaced this primary one? Do we value comfort and security more than the values of the kingdom? And might our families become places for reflection and practice of kingdom values such as mercy, justice, and faithfulness?

Illustrating the Text

Jesus, as rightful king of this world, has power over nature and forces that work against God’s purposes.

Quote: Our modern worldview leads us to assume a God who is distant from creation, with the laws of nature alone explaining natural phenomena. So passages like this one where Jesus demonstrates authority over creation might seem foreign to our way of thinking. G. K. Chesterton, in Orthodoxy, suggests an interesting mediating view in this regard.

Because children have abounding vitality, because they are in spirit fierce and free, therefore they want things repeated and unchanged. They always say, “Do it again”; and the grown-up person does it again until he is nearly dead. For grown-up people are not strong enough to exult in monotony. But perhaps God is strong enough to exult in monotony. It is possible that God says every morning, “Do it again” to the sun; and every evening, “Do it again” to the moon. It may not be automatic necessity that makes all daisies alike; it may be that God makes every daisy separately, but has never got tired of making them. It may be that He has the eternal appetite of infancy; for we have sinned and grown old, and our Father is younger than we.2

Putting trust in Jesus and following him are right responses to experiencing his authority.

Poetry: “A Tent for a Home,” by Jeannine Brown. This lyric about allegiance and security is drawn from Matthew 8:18–22:

The fox has its hole and the bird its nest,

But the Son has no place to lay his head,

So they followed the Lord and they gave up their homes,

And they journeyed as strangers.

My roots go too deep, I care far too much,

For all of the things of this world.

So I’ll follow my Lord and I’ll give up my home,

And I’ll find my home in you.

Baker Publishing Group, Teaching the Text, by Jeannine K. Brown