In a culture where even the atheists claim to have a "spirituality," it's time for the church to soul out.
Until March of 1997, the approaching Third Millennium sneaked up on us like some great, fun adventure. For intrepid entrepreneurs, the year 2000 promises huge sales in commemorative junk. Party planners have been plotting big New Year's Eve blowouts for years. Except for those nerdy computer types who are wringing their hands and predicting crash and burn for all computer systems that use just two digits to designate a year, there has been a generally jovial, party atmosphere about the whole event.
But the deadly, misguided, apocalyptic-steeped visions of the "Heaven's Gate" cult have suddenly brought us up short. Thirty-nine sad, strange, purple-shrouded figures have forever tinged our frivolity with fear. What will the approaching end of this millennium really hold in store? How many other "Heaven's Gate" groups and "end times" individuals are out there? Should we be looking at this approach of "MM" or "2000" or "21C" as a hinge moment in history? Or is it just a good excuse for a big party, a sigh-of-relief celebration that we somehow managed to survive 20C?
What the tragedy of Heaven's Gate has brought into sharper focus is the spiritual hunger that is consuming our culture in these latter decades of this century.
The Search for Soul
Postmodern culture is entheogenic, which means "the birth of the divine within." There is a massive Soul Search, a huge quest for personal spirituality, a "widespread turning inward across the land," as sociologist Wade Clark Roof puts it ("God is in the Details: Reflections on Religion's Public Presence in the United States in the Mid-1990s," Sociology of Religion, 57, 1996, 149-162, 153). People want to grow spiritually above all else.(See George Barna, The Index of Leading Spiritual Indicators [Word, 1996]; Alan J. Toxburgh, Reaching a New Generation: Strategies for Tomorrow's Church [Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 1993].) Experiences of "good sex" are now taking a back seat to "good soul" experiences. "Great Soul" is the Holy Grail of postmodern culture.
Postmodern culture is one of the most God-besotted cultures in the history of the planet. But the waters of superstition rise as high in postmodern culture as anyone could wish. We are less a culture of "seekers" than a culture of "believers." People believe in everything and anything mind reading, witches, ESP, crystals, spells, UFOs.
A spiritual tsunami is coming and is already being felt. People no longer want to know about God. People want to know God. People want to experience "the Beyond" in "the Within." It was this kind of spiritual quest that led the Heaven's Gate cult to combine the technology of the Internet, the science of Hale-Bopp, the science fiction of Star Trek, the theology of New Age and the hope of UFOs to create a new sacred reality for themselves.
The strange amalgam the Heaven's Gate cult pieced together points out to this entheogenic culture that the spiritual quest can be dangerous. As one marketing expert writes, "If the '80s were the decade when nothing was sacred, then this is the one when everything is" (Cyndee Miller, "People Want to Believe in Something," Marketing News, 28, December 5, 1994, 1). And when we allow the label "sacred" to be affixed to everything from crystals to UFOs, we are treading on hazardous ground.
Al Winseman, an Omaha pastor, tells his congregation that "we are living in a secular society but a spiritual culture." We are one of the most religious nations in the industrial world, yet at the same time one of the most secular (Thomas Reeves, "Not So Christian America," First Things, October 1996, 16-21). This double ring can be confusing, as it was in The New Republic (September 12, 1994), where on the same day, and on the same page, one story read "Spiritual Renewal Flourishes" while another story was headlined, "Religion's Influence May Be Fading."
Jessica Lipnack and Jeffrey Stamps predict that "the search for soul will accelerate and move from the individual and family to organizations of all sorts and sizes" (The Age of the Network: Organizing Principles for the 21st Century [Essex Junction, Vt.: Omneo, 1995], 232). C. Jeff Woods adds a voice that should make Christians who call the church their home sit up and take notice: "Society is not disinterested in God; society is disinterested in the institutionalized church .... Society has not detached itself from spirituality; it is just rebelling against the ways that the church has sought to guide spiritual experiences" (C. Jeff Woods, Congregational Megatrends [Maryland: Alban Institute, 1995], 88).
Hollywood Spirituality
Indeed, "society has not detached itself from spirituality," as Woods points out. One of the hottest television shows for the last couple of years has been The X-Files, which proclaims in its opening trailers, "The truth is out there." The culture says that the "truth is out there," and that is why God is "hot" with Hollywood. In looking at last year's PBS fall lineup, which includes five religious specials, The New York Times declared, "God is Hot." All The New York Times needed to do to learn this was look at their own best-seller list: Seven in 10 were about spirituality and personal growth.
A USA Today feature article on "Hollywood immersed in a Spiritual Rebirth" announced that "as movie makers are being bashed more than ever for glorifying wrongdoing at its lowest levels, new films are reaching more blatantly than ever into religious imagery to harvest heavenly heroes" (Ann Oldenburg, "Hollywood Immersed in a Spiritual Rebirth," USA Today, November 1, 1996, 1-D).
For example, take our fascination, even fixation, with haloed heroes, as Oldenburg suggests. The ever-growing angel attraction of the last decade (Denzel Washington is an angel, Whitney Houston a preacher's wife in the Disney movie The Preacher's Wife; Greg Kinnear is a post office angel in Dear God; John Travolta is an angel who drinks beer in Michael) has at last come to a head in prime time. CBS's Touched by an Angel has become one of the most popular prime-time shows and the first explicitly religious drama to break into the Nielsen Top 10 in the ratings service's 46-year history.
The first big movie of DreamWorks SKG, the powerhouse studio run by Steven Spielberg, Jeffrey Katzenberg and David Geffen, is a biblical, animated telling of the story of Moses called The Prince of Egypt.
And since our cultural and spiritual pivot is increasingly in the East, there is Kundun, a Martin Scorsese film about the Dalai Lama's life. Not to forget Brad Pitt's film, Seven Years in Tibet, the story of the spiritual changes that come after climbing the Himalayas and meeting the Dalai Lama.
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is "hot" with antiquers. Gothic revival furniture is now all the rage, partly because the "Gothic" style connects us with a more spiritual past.
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is "hot" with publishers. In 1995 and 1996 alone, says editor-at-large for Publishers' Weekly Phyllis Tickle, spirituality has been "the fastest growing segment in adult publishing the last two years" (quoted in "Spiritual Reality," Forbes, January 27, 1997, 70). Sales of religious publishers topped $1 billion in 1996, with over 150 million book units sold. No wonder Wal-Mart, Target, Borders, Barnes & Noble are expanding their religious inventories. Syndicated evangelical columnist Cal Thomas appears now in 450 newspapers, second only to George Will.
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is "hot" with musicians, with Jars of Clay and Kirk Franklin named Top Billboard 200 Album Artists in 1996. Christian music sales alone topped $550 million in 1996.
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is hot even with the atheists, who confess to be on a spiritual search. Here is Peter Lamborn Wilson, in an article on Timothy Leary's successor in the technology and culture magazine 21C: "While I am not atheist in the strict sense of the word, I don't think you have to believe in God to understand that there can be an experience of the Divine Becoming Within" ( Peter Lamborn Wilson, "Neurospace," 21C, March 1996, 28). (See also some of the selections in Sarah Anderson's editing of The Virago Book of Spirituality [Virago, 1996], especially where Simone Weil says that "not to believe in God, but to love the universe, always, even in the throes of anguish, as a home there lies the road toward faith by way of atheism.") Another atheist/agnostic claims that he lives spiritually, defining spirituality as "like heaven naked, but with an attitude" (As quoted in Phyllis A. Tickle, Re-Discovering the Sacred: Spirituality in America [New York: Crossroad, 1995], 100).
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is "hot" on the Internet, which now boasts 9,000 Web sites devoted to psychic and spiritual phenomena, including such exotica as "The First Presleyterian Church of Elvis the Divine," a church founded for those who worship Elvis (http://chelsea.ios.com/~hkarlin1/welcome.html). As of 1997, there were 71,200 Christian Internet sites, 28,600 of which were Catholic, 11,800 Methodist and 11,000 Baptist. There were 27,100 Islam sites; and Christianity Online was named in 1996 one of the most popular sites on America Online.
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
The culture says that "the truth is out there," and that is why God is hot on Madison Avenue. Spirituality sells almost as much now as sex. Tierry Mugler calls his popular scent "Angel"; Karl Lagerfeld names his "Sun, Moon, Stars." The Gap introduces a unisex fragrance OM, which was presented to Gap executives on the Buddha's birthday. "I wanted to do a fragrance about simplicity, sensuality and spirituality." Or look at Kentucky Fried Chicken ads, where a girl is on her bed in a yoga position doing her mantra. Aveda is doing a line of products for Deepak Chopra's wellness centers. The 1997 Infiniti Q45 ad has as its motto "Everything changes but the soul," and the challenge is to "Take one out for a guest drive and see why the soul is eternal."
It's time for the church to say, "The truth is not out there; the truth is in here, right here, right now (lift up the Bible and point to it).
Counterfeit Spiritualities
This unexamined, headlong spiritual search, unencumbered and thus unguided by any institutional boundaries, is bound to result in some spectacular hoaxes. The world is awash in a host of counterfeit spiritualities. A culture on a soul train is bound to get derailed.
The apostle Paul also found himself living in frenetically "spiritual" times. Recall that he began his sermon on Mars Hill with these words: "Men of Athens! I see that in every way you are very religious...." But the Athenians were caught up in idol worship. They were fervent. They were committed. But they were wrong. They were investing their lives in a spiritual being that was nothing more than a metal statue. Their hopes and prayers were addressed to false gods and faulty visions.
In today's gospel, Jesus cautions his disciples against falling prey to the parade of pretenders that will pass before them. As Jesus' specially chosen disciples, Peter, James, John and Andrew found themselves privy to some pretty astounding eschatological predictions But even as Jesus speaks to them about the "end times," he warns these disciples to keep their wits about them. "Don't go off after everyone who claims to be the Messiah," Jesus admonishes. "Just because I have chosen to let you know these things are coming, don't stamp every crazy leader, every tragic war or every natural disaster with the label 'eschatological event.'"
The Soul Train
Jesus' words call us back from the edge of a spiritual waterfall to a respect for moderation and discipline. While the rest of the postmodern culture is a bit too anxious to jump on any "soul train" that is going down the tracks, Jesus' warning reminds us that before we jump on any soul train, we had better have some decent soul training under our belts. This means training mind and body and spirit to recognize the false gods of both junky, excessive material accumulation and junky, excessive spiritual accumulation.
What Jesus does urge on his disciples is vigilance. This means keeping a watchful, skeptical, critical eye on all the events and leaders and stories that will be trying to gain their attention and allegiance by presenting themselves in an eschatological light. "Do not be deceived," Jesus cautions. "Reject those who would lead you astray." Hard times are not necessarily end times.
Has our soul training been rigorous enough to enable us to tell the difference? Can we distinguish between what is truth and what is false? Let us ask God to help us train with vigilance and watchfulness in a postmodern world where God is "hot," but truth is not.